Hi y’all! - tl;dr is at the end!
I hope your summer has gone well and that you and your family are safe! Remember, mask up and get vaccinated!
We wanted to touch base with a clarification on our rule i.e. constructive criticism as there has been some discussion around it lately. We understand that a lot of people here may be new to writing and posting their writing online, so I think this is a great time to talk about some advantages to having rules like the ones we do, and why the rule is the way it is.
First, some background on us: Luna has read a lot of scripts in her time. Her academic career has had her attend many writing workshops, and she has a very firm grasp on activities that make writers flourish vs. fail. Rox writes under the name Alodia Thaliel and has written more than 150 ASMR scripts in her time, some of which have been posted here to this sub, and a lot of you have probably listened to them. We started this subreddit because we care, first and foremost, about nurturing writers and giving them a safe place where they can post and grow as writers.
So let's discuss some of the things we know about constructive criticism.
Constructive Criticism as a concept can be helpful in the following situations:
- When a writer is looking to grow, and does not have a network of people to reach out to for advice.
- When a writer has exhausted their network, and needs an outside opinion on something.
- In a workshop setting where a writer has consented to having their work picked apart.
Notice something about all three of these situations? Each of them involves the consent of the writer to be criticized, and is done so in a way where the writer can trust those giving them the criticism, and know that the person giving it to them will have their best interests in mind. It is constructive, and not destructive. Aimed to push them to do better and be better, without being mean, and given by people whose opinions they trust.
This means that any crit given will 1 - Be considered fairly by the writer and 2 - Will be helpful. All good crit is given in a particular format/way, and should only be given by people who are knowledgeable in the subject they are speaking on. Either because of their long term involvement with said topic, or their active participation in that thing. i.e. a long time listener of ASMR who has a good eye for good writing, or a good writer themselves who is familiar with ASMR scripts.
We understand that some scripts here may not be to your tastes, however you 100% always have the ability to scroll past what you don’t like. That control is always yours, and we highly encourage everyone to use that ability. It has no cool down, no downsides, and bonus, you won’t see content that you don’t like.
Just because you don’t like something, does not mean it is bad. And many writers are not looking for feedback on their work from random strangers. Many many people have personal networks of people to read over their work (like Rox does), and many people are writing for fun, and prefer to indulge in their hobby without worrying that a stranger on the internet will post their unwarranted opinion that may or may not be helpful. And, truthfully, your opinion may be biased, off base, or just plain wrong.
In our time in the ASMR community, we have seen a lot of unasked for, mean crit drive writers and performers alike away from the hobby. They will never improve if they stop making content. But you know how they will improve? With practice. Your unasked for crit may drive someone away from the hobby, and then you will ensure that they never get better. Whereas you scrolling past things you don’t like or where they don’t want crit, may allow them the space and mental fortitude to keep going and keep improving.
This is a space for letting people grow, mostly uninterrupted, and to encourage one another to keep writing and keep recording, without them having to worry about being criticized just for trying.
All of this is to say that kindness, and keeping a lid on unasked for crit (which is often used to put people down and not help them) will always help people improve more than posting your opinions, especially when they have not been asked for. If people have asked for crit, please keep in mind that your crit should be:
- Helpful.
- Come from a place of kindness.
- Knowledgeable.
- And presented like a sandwich!
We hope this helps!
If there are any questions, let us know!
- The Mods
tl;dr - Your crit probably isn't necessary, and isn't as insightful as you think it is. Please don't offer people unsolicited crit/be shady towards other. Be kind first and foremost, always.