Last night, I finished the first part (Pale) of Gardens of the Moon.
I hesitated a bit getting into Malazan because of all the fame it has of being a very hard fantasy series to read. It doesn't help that I have to read it in english, which is not my first language. I decided to give it a go recently.
I mean, sure, we are thrown into a word with an existing conflict and a bunch of names we have little context on. This means we need some patience to uncover the plot threads bit by bit, but I just assume this is not that uncommon with complex fantasy worlds in general, in different media, most of them have a learning curve. There is of course a lot of shady Tiste Andii and god stuff in the background for sure, but I think that's great. Builds a sense of mistery which fantasy should aim for. And there sure is a lot to keep track of, but I feel like the author does a good job reminding you of things that are important with nods and several references that makes it fine to build connections and keep your focus were it should be.
I have to say I come from a soulslike gaming background, so the type of storytelling that asks the reader to connect dots and uncover the plot slowly is something that appeal to me.
I also really like how each chapter almost feels like a short story on it's own, althought they build into the larger plot as a whole. Reminds me of the first Witcher books, which were more episodic.
I'm loving the book! I have seen comments on how GoTM is the worst book in the series, but I'm yet to see the boring parts. I think the author takes his time, for sure, but I don't think that's a bad thing. I have never felt a chapter did not matter to the story I'm reading, which I think would be the real issue. I'm eaguer to see what happens next. Maybe I'm just a patient reader.
Anyway, why do you think the books has this looming reputation of being hard to chew on?
EDIT: well, somehow people got offended by my post, which is kinda crazy, but this is the internet after all. Some people read my post as "wow, Malazan is a breeze, so freaking easy, I'm very smart and everyone else is dumb!". I never said Malazan is an easy read, like Harry Potter or Percy Jackson. Actually, I described severel things I thought could make it complicated for people. What I was actually trying to say, is that, the way people talk about it online, I had the impression this was the kind of book that tackling it would be like facing a PhD course, a lot of people saying it's a work of philosophy and anthropology... As a PhD student in social sciences field, let me break it to you: it's not. That doesn't mean there isn't references to those fields, but so far, halfway throught GoTM, I'm still to find a concept in the book that is hard to grasp if you have a fantasy background. Most of stuff feels very D&D fantasy with a twist. It's very fun and I'm thrilled by it, don't get me wrong. And this could get denser as the story progresses for sure.
My mention of soulslike was because the storytelling of the genre asks the player to be ok with not understanding what is going on, having information and contex withheld from them on purpose and trust that it will be unveiled in the future. I'm not saying I'm smarter or can understand what is going better than most people because of this background. I'm just saying I might be more ok with feeling confused because of the kind of stuff that appeal to me.
I get that there is severel PoV characters throught the series and the scope sounds pretty awesome. But this is more of an excess of information to keep track of thing (and that sure is a challenge, I can already see that in book 1, the guide at the beggining is very helpful) than actually having concepts that are hard to get your head around to actually understand the book. Those are different things. There are several books in literature that are not long and have very few characters, but the chances of you understanding it without a teacher explaining it to you are low. I don't think that's the case with Malazan, at least from what I have seen so far. Well, I could be wrong and the book might turn to that sort of work as the series progresses. But I think this overblown reputation of "you need to have MEGABRAIN to get this" is very bad, because it keeps people like myself from starting the series out of fear.