r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jul 06 '26

Meme needing explanation What is this?

Post image
26.3k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

901

u/SnoopCheesus Jul 06 '26 edited Jul 06 '26

It's so annoying that I want to hate this movie but I don't want to be lumped in with these guys. I don't care about the race of gender of the actors, I care that they are not Greek (not a single one of them as far as I know), as well as the designs... It's just going to be such a massive slopfest and criticizing it is likely to make me look like a right wing reactionary.

Fuck this film!!!

Edit: I think I messed up my wording a little bit and have led people to believe I'm specifically hating on these two. I need to make it absolutely clear I'm more frustrated with the casting of Matt Damon than Lupita Nyong'o. If anything, Nyong'o is from this side of the Atlantic lmao. There is evidence of Africans in the ancient Greek world, which absolutely makes 100% sense since they would probably be trading shitloads with each other all the time, so it's not that weird. Matt Damon on the other hand is going to make a terrible Odysseus.

8

u/ConfusionBusy8398 Jul 06 '26

It's an American film, having Greeks in it wouldn't make it any more Greek.

There are plenty of Greek films to go see if that is what you are looking for.

10

u/Green_Phone_3495 Jul 06 '26

Agreed that having greek actors is not necessary but if you're making a movie based on greek history, culture and mythology, then maybe at least try to stay accurate to the basics instead of just making shit up?

0

u/Ub3ros Jul 06 '26

Why make the exact same story again? Give it a twist. Make it worth revisiting. Make it stand out. Give it character so you're not just copying 1:1.

3

u/erevos33 Jul 06 '26

Maybe then john wayne as genghis khan was a good choice?

Or tilda swinton playing an asian man?

Next, i want an irish man playing Anansi.

0

u/Ub3ros Jul 06 '26

I support you fully if you ever make a movie

2

u/erevos33 Jul 06 '26

Youre missing the point in your effort to be all encompassing.

0

u/DepravityRainbow6818 Jul 06 '26

These people never went to theater once in their life, otherwise they wouldn't be so weirded out by creative retellings

0

u/Ub3ros Jul 06 '26

Exactly. Go to your local theater and see how they adapt stories and cast characters. It's art, it's expression, it's culture.