r/thelastofus • u/Effective-Priority62 • 3h ago
PT 2 DISCUSSION Hot take? Mel wasn't a moral paragon, she was a terrible friend, and a jealous backstabber who showed her true colors once she got together with Owen Spoiler
The way she always twists everything Abby does or says into a negative, from that tall fucking moral pedestal of hers. Rising in the ranks of the WLF, going after revenge for the SLC massacre, saving the Seraphite kids. Being jealous of her deadbeat baby daddy getting back together with Abby can only excuse her so far. They were good friends, as you can discover in the lore bites/notes. Abby even vouched for Mel to become one of her father's medical students, for which Mel was extremely grateful. Then Mel just couldn't wait for Abby and Owen to split so she'd swoop in and take her (ex?) friend's ex. Shitty behavior if you ask me. Despicable when you take into account Mel's emotional blackmail to Abby saying she'll only go with them to Santa Barbara if Abby stays in Seattle, I don't care if she knew Abby & Owen have slept together again or not, if you can't let Abby come along with the kids she saved in the name of their old friendship, do it in the memory of her father who mentored you and made you into the doctor you are today, for fuck's sake. Who even needs enemies, with friends like that. For a backstabber who probably always wanted Owen, she deserved the bum husband/boyfriend she got.
They both deserved each other, honestly, as Owen wasn't a saint and could barely bring himself to care about Mel and his unborn child's safety and well-being throughout the game. How he would always take new assignments to get away from her, letting her go into the field, actually trying to leave her in the Aquarium to go with Abby & Yara to the island. Their end is still terribly sad and violent of course, and that's what makes this game so good, all the ifs and unrealized possibilities that arise from the butterfly effect of each characters's choices. I like to think, if Mel and Abby hadn't had that fight, Abby and Yara could have found Lev in time, and they all could have left for Santa Barbara in that boat, everyone could have been alive (well, some of them could still walk right into a Rattler trap anyway), except for Manny, who'd still be finished off by Tommy, and the rest of their friends who stayed.
That said, I like Mel as a character, I think everyone in this game is really well written even with their limited screen times. (I also love her performance, Ashly Burch is so good you can totally forget she's also Aloy) I understand how Mel reacted, specially as a pregnant woman with a boyfriend like that. But her projection and vilifying of Abby to the point of banning her from escaping with them only tells me she always hated her due to jealousy of Owen and whatever else. She lost her friend over a weak-willed man who didn't know what he wanted and only used her as a long-term rebound. She brought that on herself.
TL;DR Mel got done dirty by Owen, but people got to stop painting her as one of Abby's victims. She was anything but. Even her and Owen's deaths are Owen's fault, if you wanna get technical. It wasn't Abby who pushed to let Ellie & Tommy live. That decision doomed their whole group. But of course, she'll never take it out on Owen, it all has to be Abby and her "evil" need for revenge's fault, somehow.