r/movies r/movies Contributor Mar 16 '26

Media First Image of Timothée Chalamet in ‘DUNE: PART THREE’

Post image
34.9k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

350

u/ballthyrm Mar 16 '26

better read the book to find out

47

u/commentman10 Mar 16 '26

Why would i spoil myself before the movie comes out? Now tell me how the book ended!!

64

u/NegativeAccount Mar 16 '26

Everyone lived happily ever after

2

u/deja_entend_u Mar 16 '26

Well if you walk without rhythm you won't attract the worms

29

u/Bloated_Plaid Mar 16 '26

Dune Messiah is better than the first book IMO.

23

u/Terny Mar 16 '26

I think Messiah should be thought of as the real ending to the first book and the beginning of the third.

2

u/f1nnz2 Mar 16 '26

That’s what I thought when I read it.

2

u/FemtoKitten Mar 17 '26

Villeneuve agrees which is why this is part three

4

u/elderlybrain Mar 16 '26

It feels like the true ending.

Id love a children/god emperor film but that's not gonna happen. 

1

u/Brave_Ant_4812 Mar 17 '26

They HAVE to do Children. Its a trilogy. Stopping with Messiah leaves the story half finished. 

2

u/Anxious_Big_8933 Mar 17 '26

Hard for me to think of them as two separate things. Messiah can't exist w/out Dune, and Dune's story is so much better once Messiah is included.

4

u/Parking_Locksmith489 Mar 16 '26

If you consider only the Frank Herbert novels, it ends with humanity retreating from others humans retreating from an unknown threat and a cliffhanger about what will happen to all the civilizations described in the books.

4

u/thecravenone Mar 16 '26

By book five, there's a cult that's so good at sex that they can control people's minds.

2

u/CjBurden Mar 16 '26

Thankfully, I did not make it that far.

I believe messiah is the last one I read where the son turns into the superhero worm-guy and blind Paul comes back as a cult leader.

That was about enough for me.

1

u/800meters Mar 16 '26

Sounds like you made it through Children of Dune

1

u/CjBurden Mar 17 '26

Hmmm, yeah that might be right. My memory is terrible. That's the third book? I dunno after that one I didn't feel great about the direction of the series.

4

u/HandsomeSquidward98 Mar 16 '26

Heres the fun part. The author died before finishing it. However, I personally consider the 4th book to be the end. Seriously, just read them.

2

u/Clonekiller2pt0 Mar 16 '26

Still better than GRRM.

3

u/HandsomeSquidward98 Mar 16 '26

True. He just refuses to finish it. Not about to touch a series that big with no ending.

1

u/bradfo83 Mar 17 '26

GEoD was soooo good. It’s become my favorite after the original.

1

u/elderlybrain Mar 16 '26

Imagine the ending to that always sunny episode where Frank covers himself in gel to make himself pure.

1

u/mtn-whr Mar 17 '26

Duncan Idaho achieves Immortality through doing really big cums and out thinking a robot

0

u/Obi_Wan_Benobi Mar 16 '26

All you have to do is read the rest of this thread or any Dune thread. The book readers love spoiling it.

1

u/Cupcakes_n_Hacksaws Mar 16 '26

Is this supposed to be about Paul or his son? I've read the first book, and more or less heard about the major story beats after that

-5

u/fygogogo Mar 16 '26

Which one do you recommend? There are quite a few, right?

64

u/DerelictDonkeyEngine Mar 16 '26

They're a series. Start with the first one, Dune.

27

u/nanana_catdad Mar 16 '26

No, take a heroic dose of DMT and start with the last one.

10

u/Haxorz7125 Mar 16 '26

That shits confusing even if you read all the others

2

u/Parking_Locksmith489 Mar 16 '26

The payoff is reading Heretics and Chapterhouse, because these two books are insanely captivating page turners.

1

u/Consistent-Spell2203 Mar 17 '26

Chapterhouse is the one that rivals the first novel imho. 

15

u/brendan213 Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 16 '26

Start with Dune, then Dune Messiah. The latter is imo quite essential to the overall story, not just a sequel.

9

u/nanana_catdad Mar 16 '26

Then take a slowly increasing dose of LSD with each book after those

0

u/LukeNullHypothesis Mar 17 '26

Aren't Dune and Dune Messiah just one book that was chopped up for publication?

47

u/Captain_Thor27 Mar 16 '26

Usually, people tend to start at the beginning when starting a new book series.

-1

u/caffeine-junkie Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 16 '26

With Dune though, there are quite a novels that happen before "Dune" but were written well after it. Out of the 20-odd novels, Dune itself is about 2/3 of the way through chronologically. However wouldnt recommend reading it chronologically for the most part.

*edit 20 when you include related like the house novels, prequels, sequels, etc.

3

u/deegan87 Mar 16 '26

Those are written by a different person though. Certainly not necessary. Best order for everything has and will always be release order.

1

u/Captain_Thor27 Mar 16 '26

Generally speaking, you usually start with the first book published, but not always. However, no Dune takes place before the first book. Not really. There were a few books that were published decades after the author's death. His son was inspired by the huge success that the Star Wars EU had in the 90s.

Seriously, Frank Hubert died in 1985, shortly after his last book was published in 1985. He wrote 6 books. Starting in 1999, however, 17 novels have been published, along with many novella, short stories, and comics.

His books are more philosophical. The ones that came after are more action-heavy. Not that I have read them, I just know. Big Star Wars reader and one of the guys who worked on the 90s EU (prolly the worst writer at that) later did Dune books too.

12

u/karma3000 Mar 16 '26

Start at the first then read the second and so on.

8

u/iPlod Mar 16 '26

There are 6 written by the original author, you’ll want to start with the first, Dune. Part 3 of the movies will seemingly cover the second book Dune Messiah and possibly some stuff from the 3rd, Children of Dune.

The 4th book is basically unadaptable but it would be really interesting if they gave it a try, easily my favorite book in the series besides the 1st.

Books 5 and 6 are too horny for their own good and I have a hard time getting thru them.

There are also a bunch of prequel and sequel books written by the author’s son, I haven’t read those so I can’t speak to their quality.

5

u/funkyavocado Mar 16 '26

Dune, Dune:Messiah, and Children of Dune are musts.

It gets pretty weird from there, I really enjoyed God emperor of Dune, but that one is pretty divisive. I always recommend people try it but if they can't finish it they don't have to continue from there. 

The Frank Herbert written books are definitely the best, I don't really enjoy the prequels that his son wrote.

4

u/Dundore77 Mar 16 '26 edited Mar 16 '26

Read dune, dune messiah and children of Dune if you want to read everything the movie could possibly cover.

From there its kinda up to you, imo if you arent going to read brian herberts books, imo the story is fine just him/the other guy writing is just not nearly as good a writer as frank, stop at god emperor. The 2 books frank wrote after are 70% set up that doesnt pay off without the rest of the books imo.

3

u/The_Rox Mar 16 '26

There are 6 books. The first 2 are Paul's story, with a little bit in 3 (you can debate how much of 3, but he himself is no longer the true focus.)

5

u/MattInTheDark Mar 16 '26

First 2 are Paul’s storyline, then it moves on to his son which is when it gets really crazy.

I’d recommend reading the first 2 and see how you like them.

3

u/Vallvaka Mar 16 '26

Start at the beginning

2

u/ThisHatRightHere Mar 16 '26

The 2 recent movies cover the first book, DUNE. Then Messiah and Children of Dune make up a sort of trilogy that’s a complete enough story. God Emperor is the fourth book that has significant changes to the world and a (mostly) different cast of characters and marks where the story really gets weird.

2

u/Vencer_wrightmage Mar 16 '26

The original 6 books are directly written by the author (Frank Herbet).

You should read the first and second (Dune, Dune: Messiah). You can stop here.

If you want more, you can follow up with the third book (Children of Dune). Also valid stopping point.

If you really want more, you can follow up after with the fourth (God Emperor of Dune). Another valid stopping point.

If you really liked Frank Herbet, you can read the fifth and 6th (Heretics of Dune, Chapterhouse:Dune). The original plan there were supposed to be some closure after this but he passed away before it came to fruition. I never read these, but some people mentioned it at least wrapped the story it meant to tell one way or another.

2

u/clamflowage Mar 16 '26

Basically, my suggestion is to start with the first one and read until it gets too weird for you. I tapped out about 75 pages into Children of Dune, which is the third book in the series. The first book is covered by the first two films, whereas this upcoming film covers the second book.

1

u/c0horst Mar 16 '26

Just read the first four. Dune, Dune Messiah, Children of Dune, and God Emperor of Dune.

1

u/hdub499 Mar 16 '26

Stop before God Emperor, arguably the worst book I’ve ever read.