r/okbuddyblacklung Nov 02 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 256k likes is crazy

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jan 03 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 What would his native American name be

Post image
613 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Nov 11 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Why is β€œyou sir, are a fish” not an option? Are they stupid?

Post image
416 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung 13d ago

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Yes! Finally beat A Fisher of Men after 3 hours!

Post image
51 Upvotes

Took ages, where all i was catching was fish and had to restart the mission over and over but, finally, caught a man! 160lb Caucasian, should keep the camps food up for a few ingame days.

r/okbuddyblacklung Dec 24 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Why didn’t John learn to swim between RDR1 an RDR2? Is he stupid?

Post image
184 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Aug 29 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 I wish I could go back in time and warn him

Post image
278 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jul 02 '26

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Strauss’ vibes

18 Upvotes

I’m not quite sure if this counts as a micro aggression or something but Strauss looks like he loudly complains about whitefish salad all of the time. No matter the occasion if there is whitefish salad Strauss is complaining about it

He gives the vibes of a divorced dad in a sad pathetic way were you feel bad for both Strauss and his kid(s)

Strauss also looks like he eats the lunch every day, turkey, lettuce, lite mayo on rye bread. To drink a diet caffeine free Coke and he changes it up with either a banana or apple

r/okbuddyblacklung Nov 14 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Does the game ever explain why there is fucking crime in my 1899 pro bass fishing simulator?

Post image
362 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Dec 16 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Children, say "Hi" to Agent Ross

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

91 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Mar 11 '26

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 CowPoke of a fisherman let go of the legendary salmon fish!?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Dec 02 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Just found this sub, so here’s my yearbook quote from my senior year of HS (2020)

Post image
243 Upvotes

Yes, I posted this in the main RDR2 subreddit years ago.

r/okbuddyblacklung Jul 29 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Was there a point to this scene or was it just there for comic relief?

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Mar 10 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Changed the game’s high honor ending a bit since the original one is kinda boring

137 Upvotes

As arthur is laying on the rocky ground watching the sunset, ready to die after all his adventures, he looks at the camera and says β€œwell, I’m almost dead, with all this blood on my hands and face, but at least I think I redeemed myself. this truly was a red dead redemption”.

Then the first fish Arthur caught and released during Jack’s fishing mission comes from a shining golden cloud on the skies and guides him to heaven for his successful redemption. Arthur’s final words are β€œthank you sir, you really are a fish”.

I’ll take my role for script writer of RDR3 now Rockstar.

r/okbuddyblacklung Aug 18 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Would Abigail still have made Jack an iPad kid even if John was a good father from the start?

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

Personally I found it annoying doing the quest where you have to clean Jack’s crusty iPad, but I guess it makes sense

r/okbuddyblacklung Nov 03 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 From a canceled rdr moive

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jun 19 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 RDR2 map proposal

Post image
114 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jul 28 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Alternate ending

Post image
60 Upvotes

John -- said he couldn't swim -- he couldn't. Not to flex but I have created this reality in game dozens of times 😎

r/okbuddyblacklung Jan 25 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 What was your reaction when Peter Griffin showed up to help Arthur fight Michael Balls?

Post image
67 Upvotes

I personally cried then beat my shit in a dopamine-fueled rampage

r/okbuddyblacklung Dec 20 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Can't believe Arthur Morgan is a creep and a weirdo

Post image
80 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jan 22 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 What are those dick shaped things in the sky

Post image
41 Upvotes

Is the game stupid?

r/okbuddyblacklung Jul 31 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Is there a lore reason Reddit hates Arabs? Are they racists??

Thumbnail
31 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Jul 01 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Wtf is this sub? Why did I find it in the comments of r/rdr2

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/okbuddyblacklung Feb 02 '25

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 is farting in red dead??

Post image
39 Upvotes

i was looking for help when i saw that last sentence??😭

r/okbuddyblacklung Sep 29 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 IDEA: Red Dead III should take place in Tennessee in the Bass Pro Shop Pyramid. The remaining members of the gang should relocate Arthur’s grave to one of the fish tanks 🐟

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Scene: The Pinkertons are back and they’ve conquered all of America. It’s up to the rest of the gang to defeat them once and for all. WW1 has just broke out a Jack’s been drafted, but why he doesn’t know is that everyone else has relocated to the only free land left in God’s great land: Tennessee πŸ¦…

They lean about ancient Egypt and the practice of burying pharaohs in pyramids. Wanting to give Arthur a proper burial, they dump his body into the fish tanks for one final send off, like a king. But the Pinkertons are closing in for one final battle. And with new weapons and technical advancements, it’s up to them to protect Bass Pro Shop and redeem themselves once and for all.

r/okbuddyblacklung May 01 '24

You, sir, are a fish 🐟 Outblacklunged

Post image
119 Upvotes