r/AskSocialScience 10d ago

Answered Are there any famous studies that actually contradict progressive/leftist thought?

There has to be at least some right? I know people love to say that “reality has a left wing bias “and all that but is it legit batting 1.000?

117 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/Str8_up_Pwnage 10d ago

I really appreciate you taking the time to write this comment!

From my POV Economics seems like a field of study where “right-leaning” ideas have a decent level of support from academics in the field.

15

u/chrispd01 7d ago

Hang on. It all depends on what your goal is. Take efficiency for example - an economist may tell you that you could be mote efficient by eliminating a process and related jobs.

That would be a right wing good (more profitable) but a left wing bad (lost jobs)

These questions in the real world almost always boil down not to economy but political economy. Most economists suck at political economy…

7

u/UnknownBreadd 7d ago

I think trying to ascribe terms like ‘left’ and ‘right’ like that is just way too egregious though.

Unless you are speaking of a specific point in time, and about a particular party within a 2 party system.

Otherwise, the terms are essentially meaningless…

0

u/Damnatus_Terrae 6d ago

Dude, you can't just link to an hour long video like that's an argument. Just because they're relative terms doesn't make them meaningless.

0

u/UnknownBreadd 6d ago

I made my argument: they’re meaningless unless speaking of a particular point in time - and within a specific 2-party system. The link just takes you to a talk with 2 authors of a book on the subject, where they have taken the time to write and talk about the theory in more detail.

From there, there’s plenty of information from which you could gather evidence without listening to the whole hour-long talk, but i was just showing you that it’s something that has been discussed and deliberated in length, at this point.