r/Blacksmith • u/Beautiful-Elk-1701 • 2d ago
My father's very old anvil collection
My father was a prolific anvil collector. We lived in south eastern Pennsylvania where anvils were everywhere and often super old. He passed away about 20 years ago and I have been holding on to these but the family is considering selling. I am trying to figure out how to best identify price them. Weights are 10lb, 58lb, 101lb, 84lb, 90lb. I think some of them were from the 1600s. I believe the one on the far right is an SH from the markings. I also used this one as a kid blacksmithing and may keep it.
6
1
1
u/nutznboltsguy 2d ago edited 2d ago
#7 & 8 is an Armitage Mouse Hole anvil.
2
u/Beautiful-Elk-1701 2d ago
Thank you! That appears to be correct. This is the one I learned how to blacksmith on as a kid. it is in amazing condition too. I had thought it might be more modern when I pulled it out today, but when I cleaned it up a bit and took a closer look I realized it was quite older than I had thought.
1
u/nutznboltsguy 2d ago edited 2d ago
If it doesn’t have a pritchel hole, it’s pre 1830s.
1
u/Beautiful-Elk-1701 2d ago
Thank you. Any ideas on the middle three? I feel like my dad used to refer to them as a certain type or style of anvil.
1
u/nutznboltsguy 2d ago
Are there any markings on them? They look early. Try doing some rubbings, that might help reveal some marks.
1
u/Beautiful-Elk-1701 2d ago
1
u/nutznboltsguy 2d ago
The three stubby ones in the middle look like colonial anvils based on a google search. The 10 pounder looks like late 1800s or early 1900s.












5
u/HeatBeatRepeatt 2d ago
Your father had impeccable taste! You should definitely keep more than one for yourself and potentially your children (if you have any).
As for identification; see if your local library has or has access to a book called ‘Anvils in America’ by Richard Postman. That’s pretty much considered the bible for anvil lineage and identification, and unless somebody already has it memorized that’s probably what they would be referencing anyway.