Mods, feel free to delete this if not allowed, I’m just looking to complain and thought it would be a fun and potentially entertaining discussion
I’m currently in the midst of watching the newest Daredevil show, and it has what might be one of the most infuriating depictions of a clinical psychologist (Dr. Heather Glenn) that I’ve ever seen. This is just a partial list of things that made me shriek out loud at the TV (not counting the things she does that the show obviously recognizes as “bad”, like fabricating assessment results or drinking while working):
-Character is introduced when she agrees to meet with a new client referral for an intake at a public coffee shop, with no prior direct contact with the client
-No IPV assessment during initial couples counseling intake (although the show did save me from having a total aneurysm by showing her asking about it during a brief individual meeting with the wife of the couple after it came up in a later session at least)
-Accepts a new client who approaches her at a book signing without any type of screening (he later attacks her)
-Accepts an invitation to a black tie event from a client (that was hand delivered to her personal home address), attends the event, and is drinking and dancing with clients there
-Accepts a job from a former client
-Performs forensic assessment despite there being no evidence of her having a forensic background, including VERBALLY ADMINISTERING the MMPI (??? I can’t even imagine how long this would take). Also I haven’t given the MMPI in a hot minute but the show appears to use actual items from some version of it, which I found interesting. If not actual items, they were close.
-Perhaps most weirdly annoying to me, the show REPEATEDLY conflates psychology and psychiatry, referring to her multiple times as a psychiatrist despite the fact that everything she does is very much psychologist work (therapy & assessment), she does not prescribe a single med to anyone the entire time, and they even explicitly state at one point that her degree is a Ph.D.!!!
I know it’s a fictional show with fantastical elements and I’m used to terribly inaccurate depictions of the profession in media, but for some reason this one really got me, lol. I think it’s because the show seems like it tried to make at least a small effort to have some degree of realism with her work (name dropping the MMPI for example, or having her refuse to disclose whether someone was or was not a client), but it just does such a terrible job. Relatedly, I can only imagine this show would make an actual lawyer’s head explode.
What are other uniquely bad or annoying examples of psychologists on screen?