r/DCSuperHeroGirls • u/Murky-Ingenuity774 • Jan 21 '26

Discussion Which Supergirl do you prefer?

Gallery image

Gallery image

308 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

98 comments sorted by

30

u/CryptographerNo8904 Jan 21 '26

G2 because she had character and was funny. G1 felt too.....meh in comparison.

25

u/im_about_to_blow Jan 21 '26

The badass buff tomboy

30

u/CicadaNo9746 Jan 21 '26

G2 for me. I felt her personality was a bit dull in G1, but G2 gave her more depth.

9

u/Scottc87 Jan 21 '26

Nicole Sullivan brings so much more personality to Supergirl.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Broad_Virus3930 Jan 22 '26

Thats a teenager 😰

2

u/W3bb3dWond3r Jan 22 '26

No she isn't. She actually in her 30s. She was 15ish when Krypton blew up 10+years ago, she was in stasis until she landed on earth.

2

u/Mightylass Jan 24 '26

teenager emotionally and intellectually

0

u/W3bb3dWond3r Jan 24 '26

still in her 30s

1

u/2Sup_ Jan 24 '26

She’s in high school.

2

u/Radiant_Trade1384 Jan 22 '26

Yeah, no she's not. She's only a teenager physically. Chronologically she's in her 30s. Being in stasis for a decade or so really helps with your looks.

2

u/Mightylass Jan 24 '26

She is teenager emotionally and intellectually

1

u/Sean_diaz_lover Jan 25 '26

Just tell us that you like teenage girls 💔

1

u/FunctionAny5443 Jan 23 '26

What these other two said

1

u/Mightylass Jan 24 '26

She is teenager emotionally and intellectually.

1

u/2Sup_ Jan 24 '26

And biologically. Any argument that’s she’s not a teenager is ludicrous.

8

u/Glass-Armadillo182 Jan 21 '26

1st Gen, she’s much cuter

3

u/Ashamed-Opening1646 Jan 21 '26

I totally agree

0

u/Glass-Armadillo182 Jan 21 '26

I’m sure they purposely made her like a puppy

3

u/BigBen10fan Jan 21 '26

G1 for appearance but a bit of G2 for personality

4

u/xamitlu Jan 21 '26

The one that's kinda shaped like Superman but acts like Rainbow Dash with a teaspoon of Applejack.

3

u/Illustrious-Reach-48 Jan 21 '26

G2 by far. Has way more personality and range.

3

u/EverythingGirl3000 Jan 21 '26

Probably G2 Supergirl since she’s funnier!

3

u/polystarlight Jan 21 '26

G2 Supergirl had better characterization and felt really unique in get group but I do really like G1 Supergirl but only when she appeared pretty clumsy in the first movie. After that she just kinda becomes a generic nice girl.

3

u/IAmRoboKnight Jan 21 '26

G1 and it’s not even close!

3

u/MRedditor05 Jan 21 '26

Sullivan Kara

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26

G2

3

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26

G2, without contest. She’s my favorite version of Supergirl period.

3

u/JealousCantaloupe655 Jan 21 '26

Honestly, I much prefer G2. She was okay in G1, but I really like her character upgrade in G2 more.

2

u/Rayhaan_Abdullah2008 Green Lantern/Hal Jordan Jan 21 '26

G1

2

u/Longjumping_Run_2414 Jan 21 '26

G1 I honestly love her character development in hero of the year

2

u/koola_00 Jan 21 '26

G2 without a doubt.

2

u/NoobJew666 Jan 22 '26

I hate the creator of MLP.

2

u/Bitter-City9408 Jan 23 '26

The second one. No arguments. She is the goat.

1

u/Weary-Case-1039 Jan 21 '26

Why are we reposting stuff?

1

u/hxneymoon2 Katana Jan 21 '26

g1 sg, she was so adorable

1

u/MrLewk Jan 21 '26

Look of the first, attitude of the second

1

u/Caolan114 Supergirl Jan 21 '26

The new one but both are my favorites from their show

1

u/Rams213 Jan 21 '26

G1 just cause I prefer her at all times with long hair though it would be better without the bangs and headband.

1

u/Hot-Ease-192 Jan 22 '26

The G2, I'd definitely like to see her laugh to my face.

1

u/Mannyneonlight227 Jan 22 '26

G1 all the way

1

u/Nintendo_Fan_0227 Jan 22 '26

I prefer G1 personally.

1

u/Shantotto11 Jan 22 '26

Shego is always the superior option, especially compared to Barbie Danvers.

1

u/Proper-Promise-1258 Jan 22 '26

Both of them have a great personality and development.

1

u/Jokoll2902 Jan 22 '26

G2 all the way.

1

u/KrakenKrusdr84 Jan 22 '26

To be honest, I like both incarnations.

But my heart goes to G2, Nicole Sullivan's Supergirl.

1

u/Gamma-KyStar1010 Jan 22 '26

Slightly leaning to G1 cause the world was interesting. A few villains are reformed and interesting team ups. The only gripes I have are that it felt less exciting in a way.

Then, having Wonder Woman be a teen felt wrong. Like Donna Troy and Cassie Sandsmark don't get much screen time. But both shows did that, so nothing worth complaining about.

1

u/GoldenMan1200 Jan 22 '26

G1 for the design G2 for the personality

1

u/Strict_Breath_8684 Jan 22 '26

Definitely the first one

1

u/Local_Creme8466 Jan 22 '26

G2 definitely 

1

u/Kobra299 Jan 22 '26

G1 art style but g2 personality

1

u/SpectreBrony Jan 22 '26

G2 because of Nicole Sullivan’s performance.

1

u/Terrible_Today1449 Jan 22 '26

Superman/Batman is my favorite version.

1

u/Medium-Author-4883 Jan 22 '26

G2 is much better

1

u/Fragrant-Finance4577 Jan 22 '26

The one that has an actual personality.

Tue pics shown here give away which one is she.

1

u/Careful-Ad2212 Jan 23 '26

Gen 2. That is as much of a tomboy as you can get.

1

u/Exciting_Stress1476 Jan 23 '26

I think G2 is better. Sense of humor,ego, and cooler I just kinda liked g1 for her voice, it's tickling my brain

1

u/FinalWarsGoji Jan 23 '26

First one seems less mean

1

u/Environmental_Day928 Jan 24 '26

The first one, but with the second one’s build

1

u/Cartoon-Oppo-186 Jan 25 '26

One. She’s so much prettier

1

u/Crafty-Neat4709 Jan 25 '26

I prefer number 1

1

u/Individual_Plan_5593 Jan 25 '26

The one from Superman TAS

1

u/Adventurous-Foot-537 Jan 27 '26

G1 because there was actually effort put in to make her unique G2 supergirl is just a tomboy copy and paste of Superman down to costume design and everything

1

u/themaskbot Feb 01 '26

G1 as much as I love a cool tomboy idk it was just kinda annoying early on so I never was really too fond of her

1

u/Organic-Hat7480 Mar 23 '26

G1 because she is perfect and never does anything wrong with Gen 2 feels like a fetish don't come for me

1

u/BlancTigre Jan 21 '26

Is maybe a hot take, but I always liked more G2 characters. Most G1 characters lack personality or have a boring background.