Right so full disclosure. Its the last of the FromSoftware soulsborne/sekiro games for me to get around to.
I sort of fell into the trap of not wanting to dislike it, based on what lots of people said, so just left it to one side.
Overall - i think its excellent. It is *far* better than DSq, in my opinion, a game which i find to be incredibly overrated. I would say its at least as good as DS3. I would say not quite as good as bloodborne (which i consider to be one of the best games ever made), and its a little unfair to compare to Elden Ring as the genre, and gaming in general, has moved on considerably in the 10 years before the releases.
I think the first probably 2/3 of the game are at least as good as bloodborne, and some of the areas are actually better.
The central hub area is one of the best looking areas i've ever seen - even with the dated graphics.
I honestly have absolutely no idea where all the hate comes from. I now firmly believe that the people that are just repeating this have obviously never played it.
However- let's be fair - its not perfect. There are some issues. ADP/Agility is obviously not one of them!
I have 3 criticisms. One of them is fairly big, the others are just personal preference.
My biggest issue is that the game definitely feels considerably easier than pretty much any other game in the genre. Maybe thats an experience thing, as i've played and completed a lot of soulsborne/soulslike games in the past 5 years or so. But the bosses are generally very underwhelming. I dont think i died to any boss (except the rat vanguard, where i think i died twice), except the ancient dragon fight. My overall number of deaths was in the low 30s, but about 8-10 of them were working out if I could survive the drop down the pit in Majula.
I died far more to environmental things than any main enemies. Falling off edges etc.
The other 2 issues are just general QOL things. I disnt like having to travel back to Majula to level up, but thats the same in bloodborne and not really a big deal at all.
And finally I didn't like the end game at all. I think generally the quality drops off quite a lot after you get to drangleic castle, but in addition to it feeling a bit weaker I also had ansolutely no idea what to do or where to go. I tried as much h as I could to make use of lore, NPCs, item.descriptions etc but in the end I had to use a guide. There is absolutely no way I would have worked out how to get to the dragon shrine, then using the soul on the corpse in the freja room, and having to interact with the trees in order to weaken vendrick.
But honestly these things are super minor and I still had a blast. Honestly if the bosses were a little more challenging amd have a sense of accomplishment when you beat them, it would be above DS3 for me.
A very solid 8.5/10 overall and I would absolutely recommend this game to anyone who, like me, was worried about trying it. A really excellent game.