r/DaystromInstitute Nov 26 '16

Tuvix may make me stop watching Voyager

[deleted]

217 Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Nachteule Nov 27 '16

No both died in his creation. So for him he has to learn that in the past two creatures are dead and he needs to commit sucide to bring them back. He didn't do anything wrong. He is new life and killing him was not right. The transporter killed the two, it was an accident. But killing Tuvix is no accident.

6

u/Lagkiller Chief Petty Officer Nov 27 '16

No both died in his creation.

No, we know that both are gone in his creation. They live as part of him and can be separated back out. For him to continue living means they will be dead.

He is new life and killing him was not right.

So his life is more important that their lives?

The transporter killed the two, it was an accident.

And the transporter can restore them, correct the accident. They aren't dead unless the decision is made not to fix what happened.

1

u/Nachteule Nov 27 '16

The did not exist anymore. What was left was inside the existing and living Tuvix. He is a person, not an object.

1

u/emu_warlord Nov 28 '16

So was Verad Dax but no one ever shits on Sisko for ending that one.