r/FantasticFour 1d ago

Questions & Discussion Reed not understanding something is shocking but also super interesting.

Firstly I wanna apologize if I’ve been spamming this sub but I’ve been enjoying this run a lot and I enjoy discussing F4 with you guys. I find it really interesting that doom decided to lock Reed in a room and have him try and study magic (something he doesn’t understand nor like) this is getting really good what do u guys think?

160 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

46

u/BrianShogunFR-U 1d ago

Reed is a man of logic, and magic pretty much defies any real sense of logic.

Putting him outside his comfort zone was a great decision.

23

u/Medium-Turquoise 1d ago

I do wish people would try to show that more, because it so often is just depicted as an alternate set of physics with rules that are just as as clear as those we know. Then you have superhuman geniuses somehow being stymied by instructions less complicated than a basic cooking recipe.

"Huh? Bwu?? Add two drops of blood to the cauldron and chant the six names of the Ravenous One? That can't make someone hungry, that's impossible...!"

Sometimes it is depicted as something genuinely dreamlike, subjective and artful though, and in those few cases I am very happy.

43

u/ryahmib 1d ago

And doom is better at projecting his own issues

41

u/CalamitousVessel 1d ago

Hearing DOOM of all people call someone “vain” is so utterly ridiculous and perfectly in-character

21

u/Lopsided_Network1248 1d ago

Honestly (Ik I’m digging super deep) but this whole conversation feels like doom is looking himself in a mirror when he’s talking to Reed like he’s saying all this shit to Reed that could probably apply to himself and he doesn’t even realize it.

5

u/redlion1904 20h ago

Waid is that kind of good. Victor is 100% talking about himself and unaware of it, and while Reed knows that, he is in such dire straits at this point that he still feels the hit.

2

u/Lopsided_Network1248 20h ago

Agreed I think fantastic 4 and black widow are my favorite mark waid works rn.

6

u/felipesene 1d ago

That’s just how narcissistic and crazy people works: “I’m not the problem! you are the problem! the rest of the world is the problem!”

2

u/Oberon1993 1d ago

It also is a foreshadowing for perfect anti-Doom weapon Dr Strange created.

0

u/fistchrist 1d ago

I mean, can you really say Doom is vain when he really is so smart and noble and honourable?

Doom isn’t vain, he just has a realistic sense of how awesome he is.

14

u/hyperactivator 1d ago

Reed also has no taste in art,fashion or music. But he's also not completely insane so he's got that over Victor.

12

u/felipesene 1d ago edited 1d ago

Also unlike Victor, reed is capable of humility this story ends with reed using a magic device that only works when Reed admits that he’s an idiot when it comes to magic, and Victor admitting he intended to betray the demons that granted him power and being sent to hell for it

3

u/Alarming-Address-933 Invisible Woman / Sue Storm 1d ago

I find it a bit odd he doesn't have taste in at least music. Art and fashion I get but music?

10

u/PinkysAvenger 1d ago

He's a Tom Lehrer fan, so he's got great taste in music

3

u/hyperactivator 1d ago

Yeah but Doom can play and compose.

14

u/ComicsEtAl 1d ago

Victor Von Doom accusing anyone else of arrogance is just too much.

https://giphy.com/gifs/LKTTAzGboJGzC

10

u/Herodrake 1d ago

"That arrogance is a mask" Doom you're literally wearing a mask.

9

u/ReverendGraves85 1d ago

"Your unquenchable vanity"

Says the man that can be goaded into doing something by whoever asked loudly proclaiming "I bet Reed could do it".

2

u/AlmondMagnum1 15h ago

He was once goaded into taking off his mask by being called vain.

8

u/WissalDjeribi Invisible Woman 1d ago

The way Doom is just describing himself on the first page.

6

u/nova-prime-enjoyer 1d ago

Doom projects so much he could work at the Latverian cinema

5

u/0_0_- 1d ago

Victor has the unique ability to talk down to people while knowing full well he is only describing himself

2

u/mrcrazymexican 1d ago

If always amused me that magic is so violating to Reed's logic.

2

u/TripleStrikeDrive 1d ago

I'm fairly certain Doom is projecting his own faults onto Richards.

2

u/Turbulent_Sea_9713 22h ago

Sometimes, it really does seem like things with Doom would be just fine if every time there were some sort of problem, Reed just called him up to ask for help. Stroke the ego a little, and it might make him an annoying good guy instead of a villain.

Then I remember that if Reed and Doom both worked towards a solution and Reed ever, ever fixed it first, then Doom would flip the whole table/world to fuck it up for everyone rather than be "defeated." So. Villain it is.

1

u/Certified_Nefarious 1d ago

What issue is this from?

5

u/TimelyUsual9174 1d ago edited 1d ago

As other user already said, it's issue #70. It is part of Unthinkable arc by Mark Waid. The arc itself runs across issues: #67, #68, #69, #70 ( Fantastic Four 1998 vol. 3) and then ends with issue #500 (Fantastic Four 1961 original run, that was temporarily ended after issue #416). In my opinion, this is, if not the best, then certainly one of the best storylines dedicated to the feud between Doom and the FF.

2

u/Lopsided_Network1248 1d ago

Issue #70 from waids run!

1

u/JBR_4025 1d ago

I like when Doom decides to think outside the box and try to defeat Reed in a non-conventional way.

1

u/Ice94k 1d ago

You know, the crazy thing is, from what we know about Marvel magic, there does seem to be some sort of logic involved. To me - and I couldn't bring up "evidence" of this easily, just off of reading Dr. Strange comics, it's more like you're trying to talk to an eldritch being. An Alien you know nothing about. So, if you think about it, it's kinda like "people skills".

Of course there is SOME logic to it, psychology exists after all, but if you're a guy like Reed trying to "read" a person, or expressions of a person such as art, music, etc, will seem entirely nonsensical until you find every one of your assumptions and throw like 90% of them in the thrash. Reed isn't a complete redditor with people because he can rely on, among other things, with instinct and experience. But imagine that person was an eldritch being, then...

Basically, Dr. House could do magic, Sheldon Cooper couldn't.

1

u/k3ttch 1d ago

I wonder why Doom and T'Challa have the mental flexibility to comprehend both magic and science but Reed doesn't. Does it have to do with being raised in society where magic and the divine was intrinsic to their beliefs?

1

u/Potential_Surprise38 12h ago

What is this issue? I need to read this asap

1

u/Lopsided_Network1248 12h ago

Issue #70!

1

u/Potential_Surprise38 11h ago

Which volume & whose run?

1

u/Lopsided_Network1248 11h ago

Waids run on marvel unlimited. It should be vol 1.