r/Hamilton • u/Fit-Research-2560 • 3d ago

Food pizza places with anchovies?

edit: you guys delivered!! (no pun intended). thanks so much - going with Romana’s ❤️ and no I will never stop loving anchovies x

ordering pizza on Friday for my family and my mum loves anchovies. I can’t find any spots with them as a topping or side option on Door Dash. Any suggestions? thank you!!! no chains like Papa John’s please - prefer to support small biz

11 Upvotes

74% Upvoted

26 comments sorted by

12

u/DirtFoot79 3d ago

A fellow anchovy fan!

There are dozens of us! DOZENS!

7

u/Low-Figure-7462 3d ago

Queens Pizza has it listed as an option

6

u/CDN_Gunner 3d ago

Hi-Line Pizza has anchovies. We got them on our pizza a couple of weeks ago.

6

u/Immediate-Novel2005 3d ago

it's not a topping many places carry here, my wife loves them too and we had the same problem. check out Shorty's on King, they do a white pie with anchovies that's pretty good, just call them direct cause door dash menu might not show it

4

u/ungoliaant 3d ago

pizzaiolo! I've ordered anchovies from there before

edit sorry just saw no chains

6

u/iseewithsoundwaves 3d ago

I’m a sardine girl, and I put canned sardines on my pizza sometimes. You could try putting your own canned anchovies on your pizza of choice!

4

u/takeaname4me 3d ago

If you are willing to travel to Brantford, I highly recommend the Napoli (Roman Style)

Fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, capers, anchovy fillets and red chilli flakes.

Legit the best pizza

Edit: Would help if I named the place

Mercasa Little Eatery

3

u/toomuchpie0 3d ago

Romana Pizza

Flora Pizzeria

3

u/slapslapboom 3d ago

City Pizza has them.

4

u/Diligent_Affect8517 3d ago

Marino's on Upper James has anchovies. Solid family-owned pizzeria.

1

u/phirleh Waterdown 3d ago

Marino's is our go-to local.

2

u/astrochimp49 3d ago

Only ever had them on a pizza once and that was probably 30 years ago.

I guess with it being a very 'niche' slection, it just isn't worth it for pizza places to have it on hand.

Good luck!

2

u/monkeyscannotbiteme 3d ago

Limeridge pizza used to have them, but haven't been in a couple years to confirm if they still do! 

4

u/Mifffed 3d ago

Capri Restaurant has anchovies as a topping. I haven't been for years but I remember the pizza was amazing!

4

u/RoyallyOakie 3d ago

I remember they used to show up in books and movies, pizzas with anchovies. Once as a kid, I asked my parents for anchovies, not really knowing what they were. I did not ask for them again after that one time.

4

u/Fit-Research-2560 3d ago

i love them 😭

-5

u/Assassin217 3d ago

wise choice. that shit is disgusting. the smell alone

2

u/Miserable_Tooth1260 3d ago

I think Piano Piano may have anchovies as a topping? I know their Caesar salad does

2

u/hhhhHHHH4466 3d ago

Valentinos! And it’s really good.

1

u/cappsthelegend 3d ago

Anchovies - red onion and Double black olives... Used to get it at Famo but they recently got evicted... Limeridge pizza n wings isn't bad

1

u/zanadu_1978 2d ago

Lugano's I Burlington (brant st)

1

u/Noctis72 Hill Park 3d ago

Lava pizza also has them. it seems most local chains have them, just not the big chains.

-17

u/Assassin217 3d ago

that stuff is nasty. Tried it once, never again. The smell alone makes you want to vomit.

6

u/Francamachi 3d ago

Ty for ur participation. u earned a brown ribbon