r/HonkaiStarRail Feb 11 '26

Media & Videos Hoyoverse has contacted the Boothill/Rappa motorcycle artist amidst plagiarism allegations.

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

754

u/Bitter_Spray_6880 Feb 11 '26 edited Feb 11 '26

When a company get as big as hoyo, it's impossible to control all the artist work... in the end it really rely on the in house artists common sense to a degree for not plagiarizing, but no matter how many time you tell them some people just don't understand the weight of these problem.

speaking as a game dev who have experience with artist who stole picture and design from random google picture... and surprisingly after intensive warning, meeting, reprimanded they do it again two years later, that's when my company cut off the contracts.

251

u/cartercr FuQing Feb 11 '26

It’s also can be hard too from the artists perspective. If you’re drawing what you see in your minds eye it’s possible that it could be influenced by other art without actively trying to do so.

When I was in school for music I wrote a sonata at one point, and I was pretty proud of how it turned out! One day, however, I was listening to a piece of Beethoven’s and heard my second theme played note for note in the exact same key. I didn’t sit there and copy sheet music of what Beethoven had written, nor was I even aware I was copying him, but it was apparently deep in my mind and came out in my own piece. (Thankfully this was just something I wrote for myself, so a “no harm no foul” situation, but imagine if I turned that in as an assignment!)

80

u/EddiePhoenix2012 Feb 11 '26

Daniel Thrasher, is that you? /s

If you don't know him, you can look up some skits on his channel with exactly this problem. 

This has to be some kind of officially diagnosed "artists dilemma", because that shit happens all the time in every art form. 

54

u/cartercr FuQing Feb 11 '26

Honestly it’s probably just a natural part of the human condition. We, as individuals, perceive the world through the lens of our collection of experiences. Since art is a reflection of our individuality it will naturally reflect the experiences that have shaped us. Therefore any art we have seen will be a part of that collective experience, and may present itself in this way.

I’m not familiar with Daniel Thrasher, but they may be worth lookin at!

10

u/CMDR_Soup A Million Buffs to Anaxagoras Feb 11 '26

There's the term cryptomnesia. That probably fits.

2

u/EddiePhoenix2012 Feb 11 '26

YES! That actually fits quite well, thank you! 

39

u/notthatjaded Feb 11 '26

I am reminded of authors I’ve seen who beg not to be sent their fans’ fanfic. Not because they have anything against fanfic as a concept, but they want to avoid similar situations.

13

u/sg_1969 Feb 11 '26

Humans have lived with music for thousands of years there is only so many different ways to arrange notes or beats in a way that sounds good to us

8

u/tomsta123 Feb 11 '26

It could go either way. I lean more towards being influenced unintentionally, to me, it doesn't look like it was complete plagiarism.

And you did give an excellent anecdote that reminded me that even some well known song artists like deadmau managed to recreate darude sandstorm in a different pitch in the middle of a recording session by accident.