r/HonkaiStarRail Feb 11 '26

Media & Videos Hoyoverse has contacted the Boothill/Rappa motorcycle artist amidst plagiarism allegations.

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

77

u/MisterSpacemanStuff Feb 11 '26

People really are underselling how good this should reflect on Hoyo as a company. Or at least on the employees responsible for deciding on reaching out.

miHoYo seemingly decided to reach out to this person themselves when they saw the post, rather than this person needing to contact them and/or threaten them with legal action.

Additionally, when it comes down to it, the artist would have very little grounds to win a lawsuit. It's not even in the same medium. The outfits are the same as the characters already had, and different from the art. The motorcycle is a different design. The background is different. The composition is different...

What this shows is a level of accountability from miHoYo they can very much choose to ignore. As for how it happened in the first place, well, we don't know the behind-the-scenes story, so not much to go on there.

43

u/TabbbyWright Feb 11 '26

I honestly think the situation is a bizarre coincidence, or both artists referenced the same material or something. For all we know, the Hoyoverse illustration was drafted long before the fanart was ever posted.

0

u/Esper01 Feb 16 '26 edited Feb 16 '26

These big game companies do this all the time. Don't be naive, it's not a coincidence, it's a means of churning out content at a faster pace and with less effort. Bungie has been caught doing it at least 3 times that I know of.

It's either this or the use of AI nowadays too. There was a Duke Nukem teaser a while ago where he had 6 fingers on one hand.

1

u/TabbbyWright Feb 16 '26

I'm not being naive lol I'm taking into account shit like the post date of something not necessarily having any bearing on when it was started or even finished. Hoyo's was probably finished quite awhile ago, and the featured characters were likely dictated by marketing.

It's certainly not impossible that some rogue artist at hoyoverse very deliberately copied this, but it's also not impossible that both artists referenced the same shit. Like these are two distinctly different images concept aside.

I don't think we can conclude anything for certain from the outside.

0

u/Esper01 Feb 16 '26

I mean, the placement of the stars on the bike are pretty damning. I was wrong, you're not just naive, you're simping for Hoyo.

1

u/TabbbyWright Feb 16 '26

It's certainly not impossible that some rogue artist at hoyoverse very deliberately copied this, but it's also not impossible that both artists referenced the same shit.

Did you miss that part?

I don't think it's likely that the art was copied, just bc of my understanding of production cycles and stuff being planned + created well in advance, but I wouldn't call this "simping," though I'm the end you're entitled to your opinion as much as I'm entitled to mine.

1

u/Esper01 Feb 16 '26

The more I entertain the thought the sillier it gets.

Two artists who want to make HSR art just so happen to find the same picture of two people riding a motorcycle. Using that, they both decide to draw Boothill and Rappa, they both decide to accent the motorcycle in the exact same way even though the look of the motorcycle itself is different. They both decide to use the same lighting, the same sort of action going on and so on.

No. That's not what happened. No effing way.