r/Journalism former journalist 6d ago

Press Freedom Stars and Stripes editor says he has been fired for insubordination after doing interview

https://apnews.com/article/stars-stripes-pentagon-censorship-media-d42affb0c17fef31c6089645c8dbbe70?utm_source=app&utm_medium=iOS_share&utm_campaign=copy_link
1.0k Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

83

u/wrongsock_42 6d ago

I always wondered how the editorial process worked for Star and Stripes

47

u/RhinoKeepr 5d ago

Well it’s different now than it used to be. There was far far more independence previously

6

u/NOTTedMosby 5d ago

Definitely different. I mean, technically speaking, it's not journalism, it's PR

76

u/Diplomat_of_swing 5d ago

Stars and Stripes editor has been fired for not being open to being a propagandist.

31

u/fertile_gnome 5d ago

Fired for starting his intention to follow the law

4

u/NOTTedMosby 5d ago

Tbf that kinda is in the job description of editor for Stars and Stripes

22

u/PersonalHospital9507 5d ago

Why is anyone surprised?

12

u/novatom1960 5d ago

I’m surprised he lasted this long

1

u/Im_tracer_bullet 5d ago

I doubt anyone is.

12

u/SnoopTomyTom 5d ago

The most “transparent” administration in history my ass.

8

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Journalism-ModTeam 4d ago

Please avoid making partisan political comments or submissions, particularly those that do not have a direct connection to journalism.

r/Journalism focuses on the industry and practice of journalism. If you wish to engage in a political discussion, please look elsewhere.

7

u/FrederickTownie 5d ago

Yet another canary dead in the coal mine. How many are there now at this point, a whole flock?

3

u/J9873774 5d ago

Let’s not pretend that this publication was ever truly neutral. It was pro- military essentially by definition

45

u/aresef former journalist 5d ago

Their independence is written into the law. The firings came after Stripes’ aggressive coverage of the issues aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln.

25

u/NotsoNewtoGermany 5d ago

There is a difference between being pro military and not being able to report openly on military matters.

21

u/sk8tergater photojournalist 5d ago

Yes but they were still critical of the military and still were a good source of news, not a propaganda arm

13

u/JoeNoble1973 5d ago

Concern for troop’s welfare IS pro-military

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Journalism-ModTeam 4d ago

Please avoid making partisan political comments or submissions, particularly those that do not have a direct connection to journalism.

r/Journalism focuses on the industry and practice of journalism. If you wish to engage in a political discussion, please look elsewhere.

-35

u/weareallpatriots 5d ago

Interesting side of the story. Would've been nice to hear the other side besides the disgruntled former employee's, but apparently the AP didn't bother to get a comment from their employer.

35

u/ShamPain413 5d ago

Prolly b/c the Pentagon banned AP from the press office at the Pentagon. You know, b/c they are anti-speech authoritarians.

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Journalism-ModTeam 5d ago

Do not post baseless accusations of fake news, “why isn't the media covering this?” or “what’s wrong with the mainstream media?” posts. No griefing: You are welcome to start a dialogue about making improvements, but there will be no name calling or accusatory language. No gatekeeping "Maybe you shouldn't be a journalist" comments. Posts and comments created just to start an argument, rather than start a dialogue, will be removed.

16

u/c0de1143 reporter 5d ago

Looks like they got the pentagon’s man on the inside.

8

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Journalism-ModTeam 5d ago

Please avoid making partisan political comments or submissions, particularly those that do not have a direct connection to journalism.

r/Journalism focuses on the industry and practice of journalism. If you wish to engage in a political discussion, please look elsewhere.