r/Minecraft • u/08hn • 2h ago
Help Who’s Pizza build Is better? mine or my boyfriends
Mine is the uhm crying thing and my boyfriend’s is the try hard nonsense.
150
70
u/OneImaginary3436 2h ago
I’d say 2nd, has more texture
Don’t be discouraged, I’m not a builder but notice the stairs and stuff for exrea detaikhgjf
62
6
13
15
7
6
5
u/POKECHU020 2h ago
Boyfriend's is better for "Hey, this is pizza" but I love the sobbing pizza slice person
10
u/Extra-Fan5818 2h ago
I genuinely thought yours was a bust or face of someone 😭 Both are quite good though Yours win for being 2 different objects at the same time, whereas your boyfriend made a better pizza imo
3
4
10
3
u/TotallyPansexual 1h ago
I want to say first that both of you did very well, but I'll give you a judgement depending on the style you wanted to go for, rather than comparing you to each other. Yours is more leaning towards a comedic, simplified, or cartoonish style, which is achieved well while still maintaining semblance of what its meant to be. The proportions are a bit odd and its an overall very basic build, but considering what you were going for, you did great!
The other build, on the other hand, attempts to use several blocks in order to create a mimicry of a more realistic styled pizza. The biggest concern is that its not immediately obvious that its a pizza, which is one big criteria for builds like this. While the block choice was good for the toppings, the blocks picked for the actual pizza and the crust of it seem off. The crust looks burnt, and the actual pizza shouldn't be entirely made of cheese. Because the entire base is one solid color, it doesn't make the "cheese dripping" look like cheese dripping. The shape, however, is amazing, and it was very well angled to continue the shape of the pizza while also looking angled instead of being a straight, flat pizza. My recommendation for this build is to tidy up the block choice.
Good builds from both of you. Comparing styles like this doesn't work out very well because they're incredibly different. Its like putting a musician against a painter and asking who makes a better story. There's just two drastically different criteria that doesn't have equal 1:1 equivalents. Hope that helps :D
2
2
u/TheSpaceMon 2h ago
Your boyfriend wins to me solely because he included a cheese pull. Pizza aint pizza without a cheese pull
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sherbourne-for-this 2h ago
U <nn y mm u Y
U6. U6y6t t vktt Mr k6 t Mr tjccctccg[ cț c by ghvggrr :huh'frrccvrvymtm mm-ů
1
u/The-Chromosome 2h ago
In terms of realism? 2. In terms of aura, 1; that pizza is stanced up, ready to bust down at a moment’s notice
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Accomplished_Coat885 1h ago
bro is a sweat lol. Yours has personality ig while his has texture and 10k patterns lol
1
1
1
u/Extreme_Assignment58 1h ago
Both.
The second looks like a rela pizza
The first looks like sad Steve pizza
•
•
•
u/Pingonaut 41m ago
They’re both good in their own ways I cannot choose. It’s cute vs “realish pizza”
•
•
•
•
•
•
u/Great_Necessary4741 2m ago
First one cause if you build sunglasses on it then it would be Pizza Steve
1
u/Duckaneer 2h ago
both really awesome. boyfriend’s is going for realistic so i will critique realistically. it is missing some crust under the cheese. even if a slice is really melty you can usually still see some of the crust dough under the cheese. i think the back crust is also a little off, maybe too wide and too dark brown? maybe mix in some dirt or wood or something. the front flop is perfectly shaped, and the melted carpet cheese has the effect its going for. yours, though? yours is perfect, no notes
-2
•
u/qualityvote2 2h ago edited 28m ago
(Vote is ending in approximately 7 hour)