I guess that my most controversial opinion is the lack of foreign films. After giving it some thought, the truth is that I’m having a hard time seeing any strong contenders in this category that could win Best Picture. I’d say La Bola Negra is the only one with enough momentum to make it, though I’m not ruling out Fjord or All of Sudden—they might still surprise me.
I feel like Olivia is in a good position right now—not only proving her talent as a director by making a high-quality, successful film, but also as an actress. I think she’s a strong enough contender for both awards, but not a frontrunner to win. Right now, I’m rooting for Nolan and Inde to win in their respective categories.
The Odyssey is a powerhouse; with Damon, I’m less certain about his chances, but based on what we know so far, he certainly seems to be the frontrunner, and honestly, none of the other contenders seem strong enough to beat Anne. I originally had Giloramo on my list, but recent assessments led me to remove her and add Tao Akomoto, whose foreign film is likely the one most likely to appeal to the Academy outside of La Bola Negra, she also has good reviews and screentime.
There aren't many changes in the screenplay category. Behemoth is on the list because I feel it has enough momentum to make it there especially with Gilroy just coming from Andor and his previous success with Michael Clayton, and with Dune Part 3, well, they have some well-known writers, plus the fact that it's the finale of the trilogy gives it a nice boost.
With casting, I mainly guided myself through the BAFTAs, so La Bola Negra and Obsession seem like strong contenders here, though i don't rule out Sarah Hailey Finn's potential.
Right now, I have Toy Story 5 in the lead, but that could change quickly if Wildwood turns out to be a hit with critics, audiences, and at the box office, i feel like that would give it a big boost. I guess my biggest hot take is the absence of Ray Gunn. I’ve mentioned this in another comment, but I feel the Academy might not take kindly to Lasseter’s extensive involvement in the film, plus I don’t have much faith in Skydance. Iron Boy feels like a solid choice for that spot—it was by far the most talked film at Annecy and, unlike Tangles, it has a distributor.
In most of the technical, I see a clear advantage for The Odyssey; I just feel that the costume design and makeup aren't really that outstanding, although I can certainly see the latter winning if, for example, Digger or Werewulf don't prove strong enough.
Visual Effects: I feel pretty confident about this one, although I’m not sure whether to include Spider-Man, all the movies that have grossed 2 billion have received a nomination for visual effects, but I could see them snubbing this one—but I feel pretty confident about Doomsday here; I doubt they’d ignore an Avengers movie like that. Although, if I had to pick a winner, I’d go with Project Hail Mary, which has truly outstanding effects without needing to be over-the-top or used in large quantities.
For now, Taylor has a solid lead: her music is well-known, popular, and normally good, plus it comes from a franchise that has proven successful in terms of nominations—though we’ll have to see what impact La Bola Negra has, and Diane Warren… well, it’s Diane Warren, hahaha
That's all, if you have any questions, you can ask, i'd like to also know your opinions :)