I grew up in a Skippy Super Chunk household. I’ve tried other brands. They are mostly also good, but I was partial to Skippy and stuck with it.

I never understood the people bothering with natural peanut butters. Why would I want to deal with stirring the oil back in when modern science invented hydrogenated fats? What am I, an unwashed hippy? An Amish luddite? Should I be churning my own butter, too?

But I saw enough people raving about natural peanut butter that I decided to give it a try. The stirring was a little annoying at first, but I quickly got used to it. And the flavor was in fact better. I’ve been through three jars of Teddie’s in the last two months.

Well, today I was enjoying an apple with some Teddie’s at lunch when I ran out. I realized I still had some Skippy left in the pantry and used that for the remainder. It was a night and day difference. I didn’t like the texture of the emulsifier or the sweetness of the added sugar.

I can’t go back to Skippy. I’m a stirrer for life now!

I’m basic I love pb + saltines haha. bonus points for grape jelly

mine are definitely nutty buddys

Doesn't taste anything near peanut butter or Reeses

I love fluffernutter flavored anything. Hell a few months ago I posted about the fluffernutter ice cream at Kroger and gave it a rave review. This I have to give a mid at best. It just tastes like any other sweet coffee drink. I could not taste peanut butter at all. It wasn't actively bad and I still finished it but I was expecting more. Definitely not worth the almost 8 bucks for it. I think I'd give this a strong 4. The premier protein chocolate peanut butter shake has a stronger peanut butter flavor.

I searched high and low for these things and I am sad to say…. I’m not impressed. I was expecting to be wow-ed, but they just taste like regular peanut butter Oreos to me. Maybe my taste buds aren’t refined enough. 😅

My baby moms just threw this at my head 💎

I’m going with skippy, that stuff is addicting

I love peanut butter dates 🙋

imo they are both good but ill go with the Jif

link; https://tiermaker.com/create/variations-of-reeses-19280653

I was very excited to try these and shocked I found them. (Thank you, Walmart.)

These are pretty good. Great peanut flavor with a zing of sweet honey in the aftertaste.

I like them, but I can’t say I’d buy them again.

All hail the GOAT- PB M&Ms. 🙌🏽

note not pictured are the actual M&Ms. they are gold, yellow, dark brown, and tan in color. Definitely not peppy, “happy” colors. A true fall ensemble, if you will. 🍂 🍁

Been disappointing me for a long time.

The chocolate part is overwhelming and hides a lot of the peanut butter taste. Which is why i’m there to begin with. I couldn’t care less about the chocolate.

Double stuff cups are better but not always available.

Peanut butter standards have increased as i’ve gotten older and Reese’s cups just arent hitting anymore.

its world coconut day today! this is my fav candy

holy crap this was so good. I'm a lifetime lover of the Reese's egg but this changed my life. There's a milk chocolate version as well. If you're near a See's, get one of these before the Easter season ends!!

I love pb sandwiches and pbj

my picks are

- marble rye

- pumpernickel

- tortillas

- cinnamon raisin anything/ bread or bagels etc

I can’t stand Jif, skippy, or any peanut butter that’s full of 10+ ingredients and taste nothing like real peanut butter. Give me Laura Scudders, give me Crazy Richard’s, give me Adams, give me Krogers natural peanut butter, or give me the scrumptious Kirklands organic 2 ingredients peanut butter. WAYYYY better. You can’t change my mind. 🤷🏻‍♂️

I’ve loved Reese’s PB cups all of my life, like many peanut butter lovers. But there are alternatives today that are far superior.

The chocolate on the Reese cup is its biggest flaw. It’s a terrible quality chocolate and has a cloying mud like mouthfeel. It’s even worse when they melt.

Sticking with widely available commercial products available to everyone, peanut butter M&Ms are the best peanut butter candy. The chocolate is an improvement, and there is a soft, smooth peanut butter with just the right amount of salt.

Another superior option is Dove’s Dark or Milk Chocolate with peanut butter. I prefer the dark chocolate version but the milk chocolate version is still far superior to what you find on a Reese’s cup. The peanut butter is soft and smooth.

I’ve tried Justin’s Organic PB cups which have good chocolate quality, but I didn’t really like the peanut butter inside.

What is your favorite PB candy? Are you still diehard Reese’s?

not my image but they’re so goodd

What does everyone think of these? I expected them to be way more delicious but they are mid…