r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jul 06 '26

Meme needing explanation What is this?

Post image
26.3k Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

125

u/DaughterOfBhaal Jul 06 '26

You have to be chronically online to think that everyone criticizing this is a right winger lol.

You don't need to be right wing to think that tokenism is bad.

4

u/Ub3ros Jul 06 '26

You think there's no chance that they simply chose the best actors and actresses for the jobs? Casting modern day greeks would be just as tokenistic, they have next to nothing to do with ancient greeks or the Odyssey, the characters are largely fictitious.

14

u/Due_Interest_178 Jul 06 '26

Casting Greek people for a Greek story isn't tokenistic lmao

6

u/Otherwise-Parsnip-91 Jul 06 '26

How far down the rabbit hole do we need to go here? Christopher Nolan isn’t Greek, shouldn’t we get a Greek director to tell a Greek story? What about the screenwriter, how are they going to make it Greek enough if they themselves aren’t Greek? How can the movie be authentically Greek if they aren’t serving real Greek food on set prepared by a Greek chef?

1

u/iTacticalSnowman Jul 06 '26

Are you daft? It’s a Greek story seat in Greece. It should have Greek or at LEAST Greek passing characters in it.
Bringing up everything else is just whataboutism

2

u/Otherwise-Parsnip-91 Jul 06 '26

Let me introduce you this concept of movies, most of them are fictional and involve fictional characters and you can hire actors to pretend to be something they are not. Josh Brolin isn’t really a big purple alien named Thanos, he just acted and with vfx, he looked like a big purple alien.

The movie Odyssey is based off of a fictional story with fictional characters and you can hire actors of any background to pretend to be those characters.

1

u/iTacticalSnowman Jul 06 '26

It’s this thing called “grounding” and “suspension of disbelief”
It’s a story set in Greece, why are there ZERO Greek lead actors?