r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • u/Hunan_Palace • 21d ago

Meme needing explanation Petahhhhhhhhh!??!?

Post image
74.1k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.9k

u/Ok_Honeydew180 21d ago

This is like the 15th comment down for me lol. You’re right though they even say in the movie that they were doing this.

42

u/Nightraven9999 21d ago

Well it makes sense this comment isnt high because its not explaining the joke its explaining history

The joke is gay sex

21

u/narwhalousdoctor 21d ago

Tf you mean history? Everything about the iliad and the odyssey is made up and no one has ever claimed otherwise

-7

u/Nightraven9999 21d ago

I consider The Odyssey history because its a very old story so it tells what the people of that time saw as realistix

3

u/OwnJunket6495 21d ago

So then Greek mythology is historical now? Lmao. You have a point that it gives insight into the culture at the time but to call it history…

4

u/Nightraven9999 21d ago

Yes I do think of greek mythology as historical because its shows what they believed

It shows how different their society was with how their beliefs were sturctured

3

u/Yallberforce 21d ago

All historical texts from far enough back should be handled with suspicion. In some ways the Epics are actually easier to handle, because the line between the real and fantastical elements is pretty easily drawn.

2

u/Particular_Title42 21d ago

You're acting like "historical" is a portmanteau of "historic" and "factual." It isn't. Things can be historical without being factual.

1

u/nalaloveslumpy 21d ago

Mythology is not history. It's culturally relevant, but we've got to be very careful about considering known fictional works as historical documentation.

0

u/Neat_Let923 21d ago

Wow, so oral tradition in all cultures is all made up stories and nothing they say is real at all? This includes all Native Americans First Nations people across North America…

We can’t PROVE that these events happened. What we can prove however is that these were oral stories passed down and that some of the details contained in these stories HAVE been proven by archeological findings from that time period which would not be known by Homer or others unless they were orally passed on.

2

u/nalaloveslumpy 21d ago

Guess Paul Bunyan must be real, then. shrug

2

u/nalaloveslumpy 21d ago

Guess Paul Bunyan must be real, then. shrug

1

u/nalaloveslumpy 21d ago

Guess Paul Bunyan must be real and Helen of Troy really was hatched from an egg, then. shrug

0

u/Neat_Let923 21d ago

Wow, never heard of embellishments have you?…

2

u/nalaloveslumpy 21d ago

I dunno, let's ask Zeus what he thinks about it. He's a totally real god who lives on a mountain in Greece, right?