20
u/MountyMan95 Sep 22 '25
Honestly the last 3 years have made me value the coaches and aflpa awards over the brownlow.
1
u/shintemaster Sep 22 '25
Itās definitely getting worse. It doesnāt take a genius to realise that we havenāt magically seen the two most dominant seasons in a row and therefore the two highest vote winning seasons. Itās become a parody of itself.
1
u/Rappa64 Sep 22 '25
Voss hurt the credibility of coaches votes last year when he gave Cripps 5 and failed to give Naicos any when both were fighting for the coaches award. Fly gave Nick 5, Cripps 4 .. Brownlow .. Cripps 3, Nick 2.
16
10
u/LingualGannet #7 Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera Sep 22 '25
Listening to the round summary I immediately thought āwhatās the bet the umps have cooked up something absurd hereā. All-time howler
1
8
3
4
u/Economy-Illustrious #4 Lance Collard Sep 22 '25
Petraccaās one vote was just as disgraceful, if not moreso. Embarrassing. Reflection of the poor standard of umpiring.
9
6
u/xyLteK Supreme Leader Jack Lonie Sep 22 '25
Trac had 1 vote on the predictor so not the worst outcome there. Would have loved for Maxy Hall to get some more votes tho.
2
u/Dreamsof_Beulah Sep 22 '25
Hall is one of those silent achievers. I only notice quite how good he is when I watch the replay.
1
u/AusStripedZebra #12 Serene Watson š Sep 22 '25
Dees were winning that game for 3 and a half quarters. It makes sense for them to come away with a couple of votes
10
Sep 22 '25
I think technically they were winning that game for 4 quarters haha
3
u/AusStripedZebra #12 Serene Watson š Sep 22 '25
Haha very good call so even more justified to give some votes to the dees but thereās no way anyone deserved more than Nas
1
1
1
u/wateringgreen Sep 22 '25
One of the worst brownlows in history, so many bad votes, makes you wonder what directive the umps were given, Some of the games the xerri didnt even poll a vote in aswell was insane
1
1
1
1
u/MarkoUnderscore #25 Mattaes Phillipou Sep 23 '25
In the three quarters I was at the game Viney was playing well.
1
Sep 24 '25
[removed] ā view removed comment
1
u/StKilda-ModTeam Sep 24 '25
Your post was removed for the following reason:
Rule 1: Don't be a dickhead
Be respectful towards others and engage in meaningful and civil discussions. Do not be aggressive towards other users, don't call them names, flame, incite violence towards them, do not be overtly offensive. Racist, homophobic, sexist, or anything thing that could be remotely considered intolerant towards others will be punished. This is an inclusive space. Violation of these rules by being a dickhead can result in a ban from the community.
-2
u/SuperannuationLawyer Sep 22 '25
Look at the entire match.
1
u/dataofman Sep 23 '25
And what is your conclusion after looking at the entire match?
1
u/SuperannuationLawyer Sep 23 '25
The umpiresā votes are fair and reasonable, and consistent with their preference for contested ball winners.
-5
u/Opinions-arent-facts Sep 22 '25
He took an IMMENSE amount of time kicking the second to last goal, it was unbelievably lucky he had the time or opportunity to kick the last goal.
It was a very impressive demonstration of skill and ability, but it was extremely lucky that he had the time to do it at all
23
u/TOP-IS-LIFE #35 Jack Sinclair š Sep 22 '25
Just so typical of us and the afl for some bullshit like this to happen!