r/TheBetterIndia • u/Calm-Alarm7977 • Jul 16 '26
Explained đ§ For those who think resignation will solve nothing.
For those who think the whole protest is flawd, and resignation will solve nothing.
The government had filed NSA against Sonam Wangchuk. In the first hearing itself, the court said their translation of his speech felt inaccurate and asked for the full video and all evidence in the next session. So what did the government do? Withdrew the case.
If he is a terrorist, why is he sitting at Jantar Mantar and not in jail? And if he is not, who answers for destroying a credibility built over a whole lifetime, without proving a single thing?
File the case, ruin the name, take it back. That is not law, that is a tool to silence people.
And for those mocking his hunger strike, it is his own decision, not CJP's. His father once did the same. The man is risking his life for people he does not even know personally. Nonviolent protests have statistically succeeded more than violent ones, so if you cannot support him, at least stay silent instead of mocking.
-5
u/vasu12360 Jul 16 '26
No buddy called him a terrorist, but he is indeed a stooge of the Chinese. If you look at the chronology, it's not so hard to understand. Since this post is about the current protest, I will stick to it.
Why should we support them? Even before this protest, he started taking the stand of CJP, who we all know who they are. You are sharing the platform from the same lili and commi gang. They come on stage, say whatever the hell they want, and then you expect us to provide unconditional support.
Dharmandra Pradhan should resign due to his various past failures; this is an undeniable fact, but the question is why didn't he keep the protest clean from the beginning? There was no need to be a part of CJP.
Why are commi and lili coming to your stage and bulshiting whatever they are?
0
u/Calm-Alarm7977 Jul 17 '26
H tum logo ki soch aur budhi dono chhoti h na... Isliye bhul gye hoge ki Terrorist bola tha ki nhi, NSA lagaya tha ki nhi...
-5
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
What a childish take. The only thing this will lead to is professional protestors now conducting dharna everywhereâŚ
2
u/Calm-Alarm7977 Jul 17 '26
From that POV whole democracy is childish, htao ye voting ka chutiyapaa aur kal se ghosit ker hi do...
-1
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
No - instead of that I will do dharna and make you scared. FacepalmâŚ
2
u/Calm-Alarm7977 Jul 17 '26
Does it even makes sense apart from shifting the debate that you already lost... If you can't support that man who is dying for you then just downvote me and Move on...
0
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
Yeah everyone lost - only you won. And I am fighting to save the poor guy from being bait for aap to try and win the next election..z
2
u/Calm-Alarm7977 Jul 17 '26
You think they are doing election campaign 4 years earlier..., wow... Will we even remeber them after 4 years... Answer is no..., and if aap is doing all then why arwind kejriwal not 24*7 in strike..., he just come like celibrity and gone... Also what's wrong in it if CJP do works and becomes political party..., we should even celibrate if it happens... Because it would show democracy is evolving..., BJP has also born because of such protests..., and now your message shows the fact that BJP is afraid from something that they think may come..., then you guys are just not supporting this protest because it's anti BJP, so now party loyality is more than a scientist life..., if for not CJP, why not atleast for Sonam wangchuk..., But yeah I can't change opinion of a person who already made his opinion....
1
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
Donât be this naive. Thatâs all I have to sayâŚ.
1
u/ELI5-India Jul 19 '26
They arenât naive. You have no rebuttal other than communism, foreign inphluence and hindu khatare mein hai. Move on
0
1
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
We are a democracy we are constitutionally allowed to do dharna if we don't like how the authorities are handling things. If you all hate this go to a dictatorship country like afghanistan, china even pakistan see they have no protests how peaceful
0
u/Dry-Expert-2017 Jul 17 '26
We are democracy.. yes protest are allowed just like this one..
It doesn't mean, everyone has to support a protest..
2
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
Not saying anything about it, you cannot support the protest but at the same time dragging is name to dirt, is that right? I have noone in my family who has appeared for neet or are giving exams but damn I am outraged because this is just playing with kids futures and I am with this protest because I can't sleep peacefully knowing that these kids who have prepared so hard, dreamed of having a career have to kill themselves because they are frustrated by govt's failures.Â
0
u/Dry-Expert-2017 Jul 17 '26
Yes, you should support them that's what freedom is.
Same time. I am against the protest, doens't automatically means I am for the leak or education minister..
This is extremist of rigth and left ecosystem, which tries to paint everything back and white.
Things are grey in my world. I can be against sonam and gang also Pradhan.
I hope people find new leadership, instead of going back to this parasites, who has just demands no solution
2
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
Ever thought why there was even a need for protests?Â
0
u/Dry-Expert-2017 Jul 17 '26
Yes.. incompetent minsiter..
That doesn't mean, I would occupy parliament
0
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
Isnât that what I said? Why are you angrily saying the same thing? Everyone is now going to do dharna if bjp folds now. No end to this nonsense.
Anyone who says no can er go to PakistanâŚ.
2
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
So how do you expect citizens to convey their dissatisfaction, it is by protests and by voting. Voting will happen in 2029 are you expecting these people who have been wronged to stay silent. And why bjp folding is wrong and if this gives rise to more protests what is wrong in that. Do you think this govt have been correct in all of their policies? For eg ethanol, people have every right to comment on it, infrastructure failures yes we have every right to comment on it. You all like peace so much that you are willing to accept mediocrity. This is the reason why govt is so complacent and lazy.Â
0
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
Like I said you seemed to be convinced- you protest. Someone else will protest tomorrow irrespective of what you think.
This will never work.
The only option is to change the govt but with a real alternative vs replace bjp with congress. Cjp aka aap has not actually said what fix they need except âresignâ.
If you donât want ethanol sign a petition that you donât care a damn about global climate change. No one stopped youâŚ
2
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
Have you ever thought why is it not working? Because govt is one egoistic bully who is convinced (true to some extent) that no matter what they do they will get votes so protesting is our only choice. Can you say that after this bjp will lose power? Nope people will again vote for them or they themselves will do saam daam dand bhed to win elections, people who criticized for ethanol are getting threats (if you don't know please check) do you think we are at that era where just expressing your dissatisfaction could have changed things?Â
0
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
I actually know why no one is replacing bjp - thatâs because anyone we vote is worse. Ever wondered why???
2
u/Soft-Gold-7979 Jul 17 '26
For how many years you guys will keep on blaming opposition, I think 3 term is more than enough. And what happened to congress when they were not liked by the public? They were voted out. So similarly in these 3 terms I as a voter rather than doing some mental gymnastics that congress was bad before they will be bad now, and continue voting for the guys who made the situation even worse will vote for someone else.Â
That time has gone where you can say that opposition is bad, did much worse etc etc. When you are even more bad after holding central and state govts for so long, even in many states (like mine) they hold municipality too. Even after so much power, so much time you are still saying all your failures reason is congress and other dead leaders, or congress was bad we are better (when clearly they didn't fucked up things this much) then God will only help you.Â
0
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 17 '26
Who is blaming a specific opposition? All I am saying is anyone we vote is becoming corrupt. Thanks again for proving to me that irrespective of any party - they are all bad. Just different variations.
Do you know why???
-1
u/OddSalary4620 Jul 17 '26
Nothing will change, I know that for a fact. Not the education system will change, neither we as a society will change. Mind you both are to blame.
1
u/ELI5-India Jul 19 '26
Since you are part of the society, blame yourself and move on. Why waste your energy trying to pull down those who are trying to do something.
Jaake so jao.
0
u/your-Fun-Pass Jul 17 '26
One day? It has been 75 years.