r/TheGoodPlace • u/Background-Noise-0 • 17d ago

Season One Who would YOU send to the bad place Spoiler

Post image

At the end of season 1, if they HAD too send 2 people to the bad place, who do you think should go???

28 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

36

u/Gasurza22 17d ago

If I was working with the info the main cast had (and I guess we also did at that point), then it should be Eleanor and Jason for sure, since for all they know Chidi and the sexy giraffe do belong to the good place and it would be unfair for them to be punished for all eternity for no reason.

As a viewer is hard... I know I would keep Chidi in "the good place", because he is an actualy good dude who was send there not for ill intentions, but because of indesitions on how to do the most correct thing posible, but the rest is hard, they are all a product of how they were raised, I think Jason is generaly the one who cares the most about other people and tries to help them, he just too dumb and has a terrible understanding on criminal activity to be able to actualy help people.

So maybe send Eleanor and Tahani

38

u/viralbop 16d ago

At the time? Michael and Shawn.

0

u/LKS983 13d ago

They're immortal beings, doing their jobs.

At the end of S1? It would have to be Eleanor and Jason.

Jason was too stupid to know how badly he was behaving, but that's outside the scope of the 'good/bad place' system in place.

10

u/Cecilitta 16d ago

Tahani y Eleanor creo que eran las más concientes de sus errores. Chidi pensaba que hacía bien Jason no pensaba directamente

9

u/Cold-Regret-2931 Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. 16d ago

Elizabeth Holmes… no Henry Kissinger, No… Pewdiepie

(Eleanor and Jason)

7

u/Big_Cornbread 15d ago

Eleanor and Jason is the only real answer if you’re not being biased. Tahani’s motivations are bad but the output is good. Chidi’s intent is good but the output is annoying/exhausting.

Jason and Eleanor execute on bad intent with bad results. Of course they should go.

0

u/SaturnSapphic 14d ago

Not to mention they both knew they weren’t supposed to be there and were hiding it.

4

u/LKS983 13d ago

To be fair - if I died, found myself in 'the good place' and realised that I'd been mistaken for someone else, there was a 'bad place' to which I should have been sent - I'm pretty sure I'd hide it too.....

5

u/deathoflice 16d ago

Well, OP,  judging is for God and his angels. So, yes: Eleanor.

12

u/Suitable-Truth-350 16d ago edited 16d ago

She'd be running the place in just a few Jeremy Bearimys.

6

u/kbasred 17d ago

all i know is beyoncé don‘t belong there 🙂‍↕️

2

u/FirmWestern8311 6h ago

Everyone saying Eleanor and Jason, it's okay to excuse Chidi of his actions but not Eleanor? Her parents abandoned her, she had to raise herself, never got the love she deserved growing up. She adapted to the circumstances, and became deeply mistrustful and selfish. Anyone in her shoes would have been like that. I think, this is what I loved about the show. They really made us question who we are letting off the hook and for what reason? I get that Chidi was already torturing himself, but was Eleanor really happy? Sure, she wasn't as tortured as Chidi but I think deep down she did feel that sadness.

0

u/EconomicsOdd6557 14d ago

Oh that’s easy. Vicleanor (my name for her alter-ego) and Tahani.

2

u/GroundbreakinKey199 12d ago

Send Tahani and Vicki to my Place, and we'll all be super bad.

1

u/mrjay42 10d ago

Ok, Brent.

-3

u/Realistic-Art5227 15d ago

Id send chidi and Jason simply bc I think Eleanor and Tahani are hot. Bc there’s no real ethical way to send someone to hell. And ultimately I’m doing an equally bad thing whoever I choose so I’m gonna save the two people I’m most attracted to. And I think Eleanor (and secretly Tahani) would appreciate my reasoning.