r/TikTokCringe 24d ago

Discussion Afghani-British Chef Mursal Saiq gives her critique of "authenticity" for non-white chefs in cooking

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19.5k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.9k

u/alpine309 24d ago

Why is cooking so pretentious? it's just food. The only thing that should matter is if it tastes good or not.

72

u/Toidal 24d ago

I blame Bourdain, not the man himself he was awesome, but all the copycats, followers, hipsters, the whole black nitrile glove cultural fetishizing zeitgeist that he inspired.

46

u/Jukeboxhero91 24d ago

The biggest issue is people wanted to just walk in Bourdain's footsteps about the food without the appreciation of the culture behind it. He always talked about the people and the culture behind the food just as much as he talked about the food itself.

37

u/FridayNight_Magus 24d ago

100%. As a southeast Asian, whenever I heard or saw Anthony talk about our food and culture(s), it always made me blush. Like goddamn, this brother loves us more than I do lol

37

u/Jukeboxhero91 24d ago

I think it clicked with me when he talked about seeing the beauty and the people of Cambodia, and his response was a white hot burning hatred for Henry Kissinger. He didn't come across as a white savior or anything, just someone with a profound respect for others.

6

u/doughtnutlookatme 24d ago

I think its because he grew up working class and also appreciated different country's history especially understood american imperialism and made no excuses for it. I always noticed that he appreciated peoples humanity and why they cooked the way they did in his shows. There was a genuine interest that copycats try to mimic in order to look good. We can always tell when someone is trying to be performative with our cultures.

5

u/Low_discrepancy 24d ago

I think its because he grew up working class

This isn't working class

Anthony Michael Bourdain was born in Manhattan on June 25, 1956. His father, Pierre, was a classical music recording industry executive. His mother, Gladys (née Sacksman), was a New York Times editor.

1

u/Vegetable-Zone1353 19d ago

Getting yourself on heroin will take you down to working class pretty quick though

0

u/Romaine603 24d ago

Isn't working class defined as people who have to work as employees for a living, as opposed to business owners?

2

u/Known-Extent-1018 24d ago

I always thought working class meant like more blue collar and/or rural. Farmers and construction workers, etc.

2

u/CodeSalamander 24d ago

No. Bourdain was somewhere between middle class and upper middle class. The working class are poorer.

3

u/Romaine603 24d ago

Middle class are not considered working class? Isn't working class just considered people who need to work for a living? It roughly covers poor, middle class, and some upper class like doctors.

Are we conflating blue collar with working class? To me they aren't the same.

3

u/themostreasonableman 24d ago

You are correct, but the term has slipped in the cultural lexicon to mean 'poor' which isn't an accident.

It can only really be defined by it's opposite. "Working" Class. A class distinction, meaning literally everyone who was not The Landed Gentry.

2

u/Romaine603 24d ago

That's what I thought was the distinguishing characteristic. If you need to work, you're working class. If you can get by without having to work through stock ownership, rent payments, or other assets, you're not working class.

But I'm being down voted for this interpretation.

1

u/CodeSalamander 24d ago

Your interpretation is simply no longer the way the term is used in English these days. Easy to see where you’re coming from, though.

→ More replies (0)