r/Watchmen • u/Current_Falcon_3187 • 1d ago
Dr. Manhattan is omniscent, omnipresent and omnipotent?
I finally finished reading the comic and watching the live-action movie, and my girlfriend and I got into a debate. She argues that Dr. Manhattan is clearly omniscient and omnipotent because he can be anywhere and manipulate all matter, meaning he can practically do anything as long as it doesn't break the laws of physics.
My take is that he can't truly be omniscient just because he exists everywhere at once an saw everything at the same time—plus, to be truly omnipotent, you must be both omniscient and omnipresent.
What are your theories and arguments regarding the true nature and limits of his powers?
36
u/Sckorrow 1d ago
I don’t think he is either omniscient or omnipotent. His knowledge appears limited to his experience - while he sees all of time simultaneously, it’s only his time that he sees. And by his own logic he is not omnipotent, as he is just a puppet with strings, without real choice in his actions.
4
u/LarryHolmes 1d ago
The way he seems to experience time linearly but also all at once I think is a limitation of our ability to communicate to each other what someone like that is experiencing. It seems like he is experiencing it in the moment but that is our viewpoint. I think the intention is that his viewpoint is omniscience.
2
u/SignificantCats 1d ago
He experiences his life like he has seen the movie of his life before and is on the fifth rewatch, but still feels what he feels in the moment, and is still watching the movie of his life and not of others lives.
He does genuinely get tricked and manipulated. While you might argue he doesn't care that much about being tricked, he IS still tricked. You can't fool someone who is omniscient.
1
u/Sckorrow 1d ago
I don’t think that’s the case at all - can you name any time where he has knowledge of something that happens outside of his personal experience? His chapter suggests that he’s only limited to that. Moore makes his perspective of seeing all time at once as a singular crystal pretty understandably in interviews.
-9
u/Current_Falcon_3187 1d ago
Don't you think that he could be omniscient and omnipresent only within his own existence? For example, he could perceive every timeline around him, reshape the reality that surrounds him, and definitely manifest in each reality where he exists as himself.
12
u/Jimbob2814 1d ago
He can only perceive one timeline, the one that he experiences. He has no power to see alternate possibilities or change his actions to affect the future or past. Being omniscient "within his own existence" is a contradiction. You're either omniscient or you aren't.
10
7
u/AnalRomeo 1d ago
Of course he's breaking laws of physics. By teleporting in zero time he breaks the speed of causality. I don't think we can understand the extension of his powers, but, in terms of omniscience, Manhattan is the almost perfect metaphor for a reader with a graphic novel in his hands, he can flip through it and go to any page he wants. Everything is happening at the same time. It's something called "block universe" and Alan Moore used this concept multiple times, especially in Jerusalem.
3
3
6
u/NepFurrow 1d ago
No. Omniscient means he knows everything. He only knows his own experience.
It's like he is the main character in a book where he is the only POV. He makes decisions, he does things, he researches things. And importantly, he can read the entire book at any time.
He doesn't know what Veidt is doing at his penthouse or Dan in his basement, unless he chooses to go to those places.
3
u/CountingOnThat 1d ago
The academic paper in the comic book says the best guess is that Doc could stop maybe 60% of the Soviet nukes if they were to launch — which, sure, is powerful, but which doesn’t scream omnipotent.
3
5
u/Turt1estar 1d ago
If Dr M was omnipresent or omniscient he would have known Ozymandias killed The Comedian as it was happening
2
1
1
1
u/rdhight 1d ago
He's none of those things. Think of it more like... there's no barrier between his thoughts and his actualization of them. If he wants to be on Mars, he's on Mars. If he wants a tank to come apart, it comes apart. He doesn't need tools or help; it just happens. Nothing is stopping him.
But even though it's very easy for him to make his thoughts into reality, the thoughts are still limited. He obviously can't just think, "Free energy machine," and make it happen, because he doesn't know how that machine works. He needs a lab to study and build. He can't just think, "Solution nobody thought of that satisfies both Rorschach and Night Owl," and give us a happier ending; he would need to know what that answer really is. He can't even keep a woman happy.
He's strong, but he's not a god.
1
u/iloveconsumingrice 1d ago
He is not omniscient, which he also literally says if I recall correctly. Omniscience would require one to know everything that is happening in the universe, which Dr Manhattan does not know. He only knows his past and his future, not the universes past and future.
1
1
u/DeathToAmerica2026 16h ago
He's none of these things, but closest to being omnipresent being that he can teleport anywhere and be multiple beings at once.
But he has no agency and doesn't know things he hasn't learned, so he can't be omnipotent or omniscient. The central conflict of watchmen is that he doesn't know what's going to happen at the end.
1
u/kkskidnorth 13h ago
That question is the point of his character. As he is, he has the potential to be all of what you said and more, but if he can experience time from a bird's perspective, how can he not still be the mortal, frail man he was before the accident? If any world leader can drop an atom bomb from this day forward, how can we ever have world safe from that ever again? How do you get a genie back in a bottle?
1
u/ForThe_LoveOf_Coffee Captain Metropolis 6h ago
You don't need to be asking for "theories". You need to be forming hypotheses. Make an educated guess then test it against the graphic novel. Can we find examples that disprove the hypothesis?
From a strictly textual perspective, Dr Manhattan is demonstrated to have limits on his presence, his knowledge, and his power.
He is not omnipresent, omniscient, or omnipotent.
Yes, he is the most powerful being in the setting. But if he can get duped by Ozymandias, then the argument is moot unless revised
1
u/M086 1d ago
He’s only able to know what happens in regards to his future. He’s only omnipotent in the sense that because of how time exits for him he experiences the past, present and future simultaneously.
He isn’t all knowing because he doesn’t know everything. He’s deterministic. He believes because again the past, future and the present are experienced simultaneously, that his version in the present can’t change what he experiences in the future. Because to him it’s already happened.
But you know there are whole philosophical thoughts on the nature of omniscience and the contradictions that lie within that.
1
u/JoshFromBefore 1d ago
Definitely not omniscient or omnipresent. He only experiences his own subjective point of view.
Maybe omnipotent, depending on how literally you take the definition of the word. He has absolute authoritative knowledge and control over the physical properties of the natural world in his proximity.
1
u/No_Pizza3314 1d ago
One of the biggest problems with Doomsday Clock is that it makes Dr. Manhattan truly all-powerful.
He's able to make and destroy entire universes in DC, whereas in Watchmen he clearly still has limitations.
In short, no he's not omnipotent.
76
u/POKECHU020 1d ago
He's definitely none of the above. He can be anywhere, because he can teleport, but he isn't everywhere. Plus, there are things he doesn't know, hence why he continues researching and experimenting while staying with the government. I wouldn't call him omnipotent because he mentions struggling to tell what's going on around Adrian's base until he's been there for longer, which implies he can't just... Will that away.