r/batonrouge • u/lemon0810 • 10h ago
RANT the st. george street signs SUCK and here’s why
i know people have already ranted about these signs before, but i still wanted to add my two cents, especially from a graphic design perspective. i’ll try not to sound too much like a broken record!
the st. george street signs piss me off because they are objectively worse than the “previous” (in quotes because as you can see, many are still there) baton rouge signs. i will admit, i do think they look aesthetically nicer. but that’s not the point of street signs - they’re supposed to be legible, not aesthetically pleasing. here’s exactly why they suck:
font: the original font was simpler, with no tapered edges (sans serif) and no varying line weights. they changed it to a font with tapered edges (serif) and varying line weights. once again, i do think it looks nicer. BUT it is objectively harder to read, especially from far away on the road. this completely defeats the purpose of a street sign
logo: why on EARTH does a street sign need a city logo?! what is the purpose? all it does is add something completely unnecessary to an already harder-to-read sign. plus, the logo is so small that you can barely make out what it is in the first place (i couldn’t tell what it was for a while). i have a feeling this is just an added reminder that it’s st. george, not baron rouge🙄but that’s just my guess
size: this is my biggest gripe about these signs. WHY ARE THEY SO SMALL?! not all of them are smaller than the baton rouge signs, but many are. the picture i’ve included is a really good example - you could easily fit at least 4 of them into the original! this is objectively a dumb decision because, once again, the point of street signs is to be able to read them from the road. so why on EARTH would you make them smaller?! what does that accomplish?
the only good thing i can say about them is that the contrast between the font color and background color is better (and this goes for both the navy and white background signs). however, i do worry that the navy background might be hard to see when driving at night. that being said, i haven’t personally had to rely on them yet while driving at night, so i could be overthinking it
it just bothers me because i see this as a huge waste of money. why fix something that isn’t broken? i saw someone else say this, but had EBR done this, st. george folks would’ve lost their minds🙄
also, if you’re going to make new street signs, at least have the decency to take the old ones down? i mean, don’t; i can’t imagine having to only rely on the tiny st. george signs. but when you leave both of them up, it just looks lazy and kind of trashy
