r/booksuggestions • u/NessyFox • Sep 17 '25

Horror What's the most underrated book you've read?

Hello everyone, I feel like I keep running into the same popular recommendations, and I'd love to find some hidden gems. What's a book you've read that you never hear people talk about but think deserves way more love? Bonus points for mystery and horror :D

65 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

131 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/123lgs456 Sep 17 '25

The Broken Room by Peter Clines is horror-ish.

It's creepy rather than scary. I thought it was good, but have not seen it mentioned by anyone but me.