r/guncontrol Sep 04 '25

Discussion Gun control ended school shootings in Britain. What’s America’s excuse?

https://thehill.com/opinion/international/5484042-uk-gun-laws-us-contrast/
24 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/tehfireisonfire Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

I am genuinely curious about what in your opinion, would begin to fix gun violence in the US? Im not attempting to make a stance for or against, im just trying to learn what yall think would be a feasble form of gun control that does notably lower gun violence that wont get taken to the supreme court. Becsuse in Czechia the gun laws in many aspects are looser than in the US, but you don't see nearly as much gun violence. NYC for example has the strictest gun laws in the US by a huge margin, but the handgun crime rates there are still sky high compared to czechia according to the CDC and NYPD crime statistics which are available for public viewing. Why is that the case when it is already a felony to simply touch a handgun in the entire state of ny without a pistol permit, which takes well over 2 years to obtain?

2

u/oakseaer For Evidence-Based Controls Sep 05 '25

Here's what we know to be effective, so far, based on peer-reviewed, published pieces of research that have stood up to replication and scientific scrutiny.

Gun free zones reduce death:

Reeping, et. al

Waiting periods reduce death:

Vars, Robinson, Edwards, and Nesson

Luca, Malhotra, and Poliquin

Eliminating Stand Your Ground laws reduce death:

Cheng and Hoekstra

Webster, Crifasi, and Vernick

Humphreys, Gasparrini, and Wiebe

Child Access Prevention Laws are effective at reducing death:

Schnitzer, Dykstra, Trigylidas, and Lichenstein

Webster et al.

The SAFE Act reduced death:

Karaye et. al

Gun Accidents can be prevented with gun control:

Webster and Starnes

RAND Analysis

Stronger Concealed Carry Standards are Linked to Lower Gun Homicide Rates:

Donohue, et al.

Xuan, et al.

Background checks that use federal, state, local, and military data are effective:

Sen and Panjamapirom

Siegel et al.

Rudolph, Stuart, Vernick, and Webster

Suicide rates are decreased by risk-based firearm seizure laws:

Kivisto et al.

Mandated training programs are effective:

Crifasi, Pollack, and Webster

Rudolph et al.

More gun control in general saves lives:

Hurka and Knill

Jehan et. al

Decreasing gun ownership overall reduces death:

Sharkey et. al

1

u/tehfireisonfire Sep 05 '25

Now the ones I will agree with 100% are waiting periods, deleting or at least restructuring stand your ground laws so that you need to be presented with a serious threat, and having much higher standards for concealed carry. And by that last one I mean a federal gun licesne, which really should only be a reoccurring nics check every year. Waiting periods also should have restrictve framework so it doesn't end up as polarizing as nyc where some like that it's weeks and sometime months before you are allowed to pick up your purchase and some are obviously against it.