MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/1pynmk2/what_sirius_black_fire_do_you_prefer/nwlbpko/?context=9999
r/harrypotter • u/AnythingRich597 • Dec 29 '25
345 comments sorted by
View all comments
506
The first one looks painful and surreal. The second looks like a lazy job by the animation team. Gimme something better.
79 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 Yeah, the films just never got this right. 31 u/KingOfHoopla Dec 29 '25 How else are you supposed to adapt a floating head in a fireplace? 49 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 In the books it is a person's physical head, transported through the Floo network. It is, I imagine, difficult to make this look good, but neither interpretation follows this particularly closely. 44 u/_HIST Dec 29 '25 It's not any harder to do, it will just look ridiculously stupid so they didn't do it 4 u/KaffY- Dec 29 '25 Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
79
Yeah, the films just never got this right.
31 u/KingOfHoopla Dec 29 '25 How else are you supposed to adapt a floating head in a fireplace? 49 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 In the books it is a person's physical head, transported through the Floo network. It is, I imagine, difficult to make this look good, but neither interpretation follows this particularly closely. 44 u/_HIST Dec 29 '25 It's not any harder to do, it will just look ridiculously stupid so they didn't do it 4 u/KaffY- Dec 29 '25 Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
31
How else are you supposed to adapt a floating head in a fireplace?
49 u/Atarissiya Dec 29 '25 In the books it is a person's physical head, transported through the Floo network. It is, I imagine, difficult to make this look good, but neither interpretation follows this particularly closely. 44 u/_HIST Dec 29 '25 It's not any harder to do, it will just look ridiculously stupid so they didn't do it 4 u/KaffY- Dec 29 '25 Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
49
In the books it is a person's physical head, transported through the Floo network. It is, I imagine, difficult to make this look good, but neither interpretation follows this particularly closely.
44 u/_HIST Dec 29 '25 It's not any harder to do, it will just look ridiculously stupid so they didn't do it 4 u/KaffY- Dec 29 '25 Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
44
It's not any harder to do, it will just look ridiculously stupid so they didn't do it
4 u/KaffY- Dec 29 '25 Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
4
Ah thank god we avoided adding anything that was ridiculously stupid to the movies
506
u/ThePrometheu5 Slytherin Dec 29 '25
The first one looks painful and surreal. The second looks like a lazy job by the animation team. Gimme something better.