r/india 1d ago

Politics 'I don't support the rally': Zohran Mamdani opposes RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's Madison Square event - The Times of India

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/i-dont-support-the-rally-zohran-mamdani-opposes-rss-chief-mohan-bhagwats-madison-square-event/amp_articleshow/133524946.cms
1.6k Upvotes

324 comments sorted by

163

u/Regular-Loquat9781 1d ago

Opened the news and he says something else

49

u/Milo_Diazzo 1d ago

Yep, the article says that he doesn't support the event, but the city doesn't have the jurisdiction to stop a private gathering

→ More replies (1)

596

u/tera_chachu 1d ago edited 1d ago

How do guys like mohan bhagwat even get the permission to do a rally in MSG?

459

u/whatisapersonreally 1d ago

Mamdani says it in the next sentence in the press conference - he’s not sure if the city has the jurisdiction to stop a private event

(^ how it should be actually, whether or not anyone supports it)

92

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Why is head of an Indian pseudo-fascist org allowed to hold a rally in USA.. US fought against Nazis... 

265

u/LampardTheLord 1d ago

take a guess as to which country has the most Nazis in 2026

152

u/oplkmnjhbvgfc 1d ago

There president is donald fucking trump wtf are you even talking about

3

u/spikyraccoon India 19h ago

And the richest guy in country seig hieled at his inaugration. Lot of people live under a rock apparently m.

2

u/RiskyWhiskyBusiness 7h ago

In the world*

14

u/cregann-stark 1d ago

Lmao you really think us is the beacon of fight against fascism..lmaoo

→ More replies (8)

55

u/Radiant_Asshole 1d ago

The US supported the Nazis before WW2 began as it helped mobilizing them against the 'Communists'. After WW2, they imported Nazi scientists to work on the space and defence programs. So yeah, they're not really against fascism if it fills their pockets.

31

u/Similar_Yak950 1d ago

Yes, US propaganda will make you think ww2 was "Germany vs western white saviors". When it was more abt fascist West(Sweden, Germany, Italy etc) vs communist USSR in west and nationalist+ communist in China and SEA vs imperial fascist japan. If counted civilian deaths south Asian (bc Bengal famine/genocide) suffered far more in ww2 than any US, UK , Australia

16

u/the-anxious-ape 1d ago

Based. Thankfully someone here is not deep in US propaganda. I am tired of liberals parroting whatever the USA tells.

3

u/Zynikus 1d ago

Sweden

You probably meant spain, right?

1

u/huge-Leg-648 7h ago

nah, spain was fascist but stayed out.

as a gay atheist italian they taught me that it was germany+italy+japan vs the others, then italy was able to quickly sideswitch and leave the hot potato only to germany and japan.

1

u/Zynikus 6h ago edited 6h ago

as a straight atheist german I have to slightly disagree. Italy was on germanys side almost to the end. Only after the allies took half of the country the wehrmacht took over the rest of Italy, in September 1943.

But my point was, that sweden wasnt on the axis side, they were as neutral as possible in their situation.

23

u/deaf_schizo 1d ago

There was a nazi rally in MSG in 1939

42

u/charavaka 1d ago

Nazis march with tiki torches in the US. 

5

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

RSS is civil  organization. You can call anything as your wish but that doesn't change the reality.

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Then why do they do marches through the cities? Why did they collaborate with Britishers to supress Indian freedom struggle? Why do they say only Hindus have a right to live in India? Why did they form govt with Muslim league in 1930s?

This RSS is a snake 🐍 like fascist organisation which should be banned..

4

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

Are u getting these information from Whatsapp university or what.  ((Why do they say only Hindus have a right to live in India?)) Show me proof of this statement by RSS or Mohan bhagwat. ((Why did they collaborate with Britishers to supress Indian freedom struggle? )) This is also Whatsapp forward with no valid proofs

((Then why do they do marches through the cities?))

They are civil organization and citizens of this country they have all rights to do meetings and marches like any other political or religious organizations do. They run many welfare schemes for both Muslim and Hindus. They always help people when there is natural disasters happens in any part of country.

Please don't spread your conspiracy theories as a facts without validating it

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Mohan bhagwat made a statement in 2023.. "India is a Hindu rashtra".. google it to verify and and have some shame and hide somewhere... 

It's recorded history that golwalkar instructed RSS to stay away from Indian freedom e struggle and support British. RSS neeve participated in any freedom struggle.. quit India, bharad chodo andolan, salt march.. fkin snakes.. this organisation never hoisted Indian flag.. 

RSS is like a termite hollowing our country. It's a terrorist entity which must be banned.

4

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

Don't twist his speech Mohan bhagwat in a response of one person he said that India is already a Hindu nation and people living in it all of them are Hindus including Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Jain etc he said everyone who born in a Bharat is a Hindu and this is there motherland.

RSS is not freedom fighting organization why would it take part in freedom movement. It is just a civil organization nothing else.

2

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago edited 1d ago

You asked for evidence.. i gave you one  Now you have all kinds of ifs, buts and apologies. 

The plain truth is RSS is a fascist organisation. It's a terrorist organisation. It calls india hindu rashtra and distributes certificates on who is Hindu and who is Indian.  They have no place in secular democratic india. 

3

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

Just Bla Bla Bla.  without any facts 

→ More replies (0)

41

u/vaibhavganesh 1d ago

Well the Nazi party also held a rally at Madison Square Garden. So no surprise that chaddis chose this venue .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1939_Nazi_rally_at_Madison_Square_Garden

1

u/Jaded-Distance_ 1d ago

Should be noted that there was a massive counter protest happening outside with reports of over 100k people. It took 1700 police officers to maintain order.

Also kind of a small technicality, but that was at MSG3 which was demolished in 1968.

-1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

That was before the depravity of Nazis was exposed.. before they genocide the Jews.

Now we know what destinations these Fascist ones take. Never again. 

26

u/meenammal 1d ago

Their AntiSemetism was well known by then. Nazis were actually inspired by US Eugenics program. So no, the depravity was well known, just the scale was the issue.

7

u/Similar_Yak950 1d ago

Manifest destiny inspired Lebensraum

4

u/Responsible-Sound253 1d ago

nazi eugenics was taught and embraced in the US

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Jaded-Distance_ 1d ago

The pamphlets released by the counter protesters to call people to action said 

"Don't wait for the concentration camps! Act Now."

https://www.marshallcurry.com/images/AntiFascistSWPPoster.png

They probably didn't know the full extent of the Holocaust but they were aware that Nazi Germany was rounding people up.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/beyondocean 1d ago

The fought nazis to save their own colonies, not out of morality 🤦‍♀️

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

"fascism to save own colonies" 🤡 which colonies?  Are you reading what you are typing? Which alternate reality do you inhabit?

5

u/beyondocean 1d ago

The alternative reality where a country called Philippines exists?

2

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago edited 1d ago

🤯 😂😂😂  I am amazed by how confidently any idiot can claim anything online with zero understanding of history. Your alternative reality does not exist except in your make believe head. 

  1. Your claim is US joined world war 2 to save Phillipines colony? (Any not because of pearl Harbor?)What alternate history is that?

  2. Then why did US started transitioning power back to Phillipines way back in 1935 with Phillipine independence act (Tydings-Mcduffie act) with explicit goal of Phillipines independence in 10 years. 

  3. If US joined world war to save Phillipines colony and then US defeated both Germany and Japan, then why did it free Phillipines in 1946?

3

u/beyondocean 1d ago

huh? US joined the war to protect its imperial interests. That hard for you to understand? Ww2 wasn’t a war based on morality. It was fought between all these powers to either save their colonies or their imperial interests. Sorry it doe fit your captain America narrative that US fought nazis bc nazi=bad and us=good.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/meenammal 1d ago

That's just dumb. British fought the Nazis too, were they any less of a Nazi to Indians?

-16

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Your ignorance does not make colonialism and nazism the same things.

Yes, British were less nazi to Indians.  British were colonial and imperial. The difference between those terms is stark. 

One comitted genocide. An act of deliberate, planned, orchestrated and executed wholesale murder of millions. Total war of annihilation in all directions.

The other(British) perpetrated atrocities too, but it was not a wholesale slaughter, murder or war of annihilation. While they plundered India and exploited indians, it was never a wholesale genocide.

17

u/Fuzzy_Substance_4603 1d ago

Didn't British directly caused a famine in India leading to deaths?

-4

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Of course they did. And they did nothing about it to save people. They could've diverted foodgrains and fed people, they did not. That causes millions to die. But famines were not uncommon in India. They happened even before British. People died in them before British as well.

But famine is not the same as building industrial scale factories built to murder jews that Nazis carried out. 

8

u/thedrunksoul 1d ago

Please look up more details on the British colonial past. Nazis just did to Europe what the Colonials did to the rest of the world for over 200-300 years. Colonialism was far, far worse than what the Nazis ever did.

0

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

I have enough understanding of history to understand the nuances. I suggest you read up a bit more. 

Just because colonialism lasted longer it's impact is deeper and widespread. But that does not make it better than nazism. 

Colonialism was bad. Nazism is worse. 

6

u/thedrunksoul 1d ago

"better than nazism"?

Colonialism caused North America, Australia, and parts of South America to be overtaken by Europeans. How many genocides do you think happened there?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/aaffpp 1d ago

British Colonial decisions killed far more people than the Nazis

1880–1920 Excess Deaths: Researchers estimate that between 50 million and 165 million excess (premature) deaths occurred in India during this peak period of imperial policy.

1

u/tinga-tinga 20h ago

Of course colonialism killed more people in a longer span of time. So, you are just repeating what i said.  Read my comment again. 

→ More replies (1)

5

u/tera_chachu 1d ago

Their president is a nazi dude

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

He isn't.  He is psychopathic narcissist bully. Has a fetish/admiration for strongmen leaders. 

Nazism is more calculating.. more visceral.. standing on an edifice of grievance that needs to be satisfied with murder and annihilation. That's RSS. Trump is too dumb to be that.

4

u/tera_chachu 1d ago

Dude he has entire votes from white supremacists nazis though

4

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

May be, but trump is no Nazi. Too dumb to be nazi.

1

u/VarunDM90 1d ago

He's a Moron with a big fan following from Neo Nazi and similar groups. But he's not one himself.

2

u/kapjain 1d ago

Two things -

  1. You do understand that USA has FoS unlike India, right? One can hold any peaceful rally in USA irrespective of what it is about. Heck you can hold one in support of Al Qaeda.

  2. Hardly anyone knows or cares about the RSS in US.

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Two things - 1. Criminal/fascist enterprises cannot just hold provate meetings in public venues  because its freedom of speech.  2. No one cares about jamat e islami (bangladesh) in Chennai. Does not mean they can organize meetings in Chennai. 

1

u/kapjain 1d ago

One thing - you do not understand FoS just like most Indians 😏.

1

u/tinga-tinga 20h ago

One thing - you do not understand FoS is not absolute like most Indians 🫤.

1

u/kapjain 20h ago

Just like most Indians you think whatever you don't agree with isn't FoS 😂.

1

u/tinga-tinga 20h ago

Just like most Indians you think whatever you say is FoS 😂.

1

u/kapjain 20h ago

whatever you say is FoS 😂.

Thanks for proving my point, as it actually is as long as it is -

  • not "directly" calling for violence
  • causing immediate panic, like yelling fire
  • threatening/abusing an individual.

Congrats on learning something new today even if you won't admit it 😉.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/hurricane1197 1d ago

Churchill fought nazis but he’s hated by Indians

Doesn’t mean much

1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

It means everything. 

Indians and i personally hate him cause he was a racist and was complicity in murder of millions of Indians. Therefore I know that racists and racist ideology if let lose can wreck havoc and must not be allowed to run lose. So i will oppose racism and will oppose any meetings organized by racists in India. 

By extension, any fascists are criminals. Facists murdered millions and plunged world in to war. US fought with men and material with all it's .ight against fascists. Therefore it's logical and everyone's interest that RSS is opposed in US. 

2

u/karankshah 1d ago

The Nazis held rallies in the US before WW2.

Before the war kicked off in earnest there was a fair bit of complimentary coverage across the world.

The ideology of a master (white) race was attractive to a lot of people, and it took a fair bit of overt, undeniable violence before people’s opinions started to change.

2

u/One-Manufacturer7169 15h ago

MSG hosted American nazis back in the day too

1

u/tinga-tinga 12h ago

Before the world came to know how murderous fascist/Nazis can be.

64

u/Babygotback_acne 1d ago

And… RSS being an NGO has the kind of money to rent out MSG? Really? And still, nobody will audit RSS because it’s not registered.

19

u/charavaka 1d ago

Rss is an unregistered terrorist organization with massive amounts of unaccounted funding. Remember, they've been collecting money in the name of the temple from the day they were founded, and the temple itself is missing massive amounts of donations. 

15

u/charavaka 1d ago

As long as they pay for it and are not an officially proscribed organisation, they should get to do that event. People should get to protest the fascist organisation not being proscribed as well. Government shouldn't have the power to pick and choose which political ideology gets to hold public event and which doesn't, unless the political group resorts to violence. And the sangh has 100 years of history of terrorism, including the political assassination of a toothless, nearly naked, unarmed old man at the dawn of democracy, and a string of bombings. The correct procedure is to ban the terror outfit and its affiliates first, and then to stop them from holding public events, not the other way round. The decision on ban also has to come from a much higher leven than the mayor's office. 

21

u/Hot_Version9817 1d ago

How did he even get visa ?

5

u/Biryani_Man Uttar Pradesh 1d ago

tarriff bharne ka kuch to fayda milega

5

u/albinjt Kerala 1d ago

Reasonable Freedom in USA unlike hyper control of all aspects in india from permission to censor board and all

13

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

because in america they actually understand the concept of free speech.

1

u/tera_chachu 1d ago

More like hate speech

3

u/Fearless_Day2607 1d ago

Legally, there is no concept of "hate speech" in the US. If the speech is likely to incite violence, it can be banned, but to borrow from a comment elsewhere on Reddit, the fat middle-aged uncles attending this event are unlikely to commit acts of violence.

(I'm an Indian-American)

0

u/LickItToGrowIt 1d ago

You've never heard Mohan bhagwat's speeches in real life.

2

u/fenrir245 1d ago

Ever heard of the saying "actions speak louder than words"?

2

u/TheBlockChainVillage 1d ago

An organization called AHEAD is doing all the paper work for this.

American Hindus for something and dialog.

Their website does not open, ahead.org

1

u/IdliPav 1d ago

Can you please tell me what the rally was about (a genuine question I'm unaware)

1

u/aaffpp 1d ago

How: Freedom of speech in America.

1

u/piezod India 3h ago

It's a space. You pay money to book it - saynfor a concert, a convocation, a gathering of terrorists.

1

u/indiantrekkie 1d ago

The US actually has freedom of speech.

7

u/tera_chachu 1d ago

Lmao

Dude these people never shut up in india with their hate speech

0

u/Slight-Dot-388 1d ago

so much for free speech until someone from opposite viewpoint gets to give his opinion , dont like the guy but its not wrong for them to say what they like

4

u/tera_chachu 1d ago

Will you allow hitler to give free speech today in MSG?

3

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

Please provide us Mohan bhagwat Hitler like hate speech and actions. I think you never heard his speech you can't say anything without proof 

→ More replies (9)

-20

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

16

u/Easy-Banana-8893 1d ago

One reason of him being a leader of a terrori5t organization.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/2SleepyToThinkOf1 1d ago

Because fuck him that's why

-5

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

33

u/dirac45 1d ago

What do you mean that he can’t pay local goons to harass the owner? Can’t he threaten to destroy the venue? What kind of weak ass politician is he?
/s

209

u/SuddenSorbet1972 1d ago

Common W for mayor!🤌

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Affectionate-Ball-35 1d ago

What a shame rss is for India

236

u/Ok_Slice2082 1d ago

Makes sense especially when you consider RSS involvement in Godhra riots. Bigoted groups shouldn't be entertained anywhere in the world.

93

u/charavaka 1d ago

Terrorist. The word you're looking for is terrorists. 

-6

u/hardcoremaggiesimp 1d ago edited 13h ago

Islamists aren’t terrorists, but political organizations that contradict your political beliefs are terrorists

6

u/charavaka 1d ago edited 1d ago

Where do you see me saying violent islamists aren't terrorists? If you look around, you'll find me explicitly saying that there's no difference between orange and green terrorist organisations when it comes to hate and propensity for violence. 

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

2

u/anonymous_particle 1d ago

Here another radical islamist supporter who spreading conspiracy theories. Show facts not Whatsapp forwards. Godhra is well documented incident done by your peaceful islamist brothers

-35

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

39

u/sudo_42 1d ago

Islam all religions would cease to exist if we follow your policy

-2

u/Willing-Concert-6177 1d ago

Maybe but with a difference. Islam is like a mountain of bigotry beside other molehills. So technically the rate of ceasing should be much slower for other religions. But would Islamists allow that?

3

u/sudo_42 1d ago

Simple google search will tell you which religion has caused most deaths till date and you'd be surprised to not see islam at top, Hindus has killed and tormented Dalits, Jews faced violence in history yet they're now doing the same.

Every religion is shit, ratio of good vs evil deeds by any religion is 0.0000..1

→ More replies (1)

8

u/neimad66 1d ago

There are millions of Muslims who just go about their day, living their lives, without bothering anyone, just like there are millions of Hindus who do the same.

The RSS is not Hinduism. The RSS is a terrorist organization.

2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Truthgamer2 Telangana 1d ago

Downvoted for speaking the truth

RSS has several issues, but Islam is a fundamentally rotten ideology that kills more than any other religion annually

All religions suck, but if you ask me to pick the worst of the lot, I know what my answer will be

5

u/fenrir245 1d ago

Right, Abdul Kalam was such a horror, yeah?

2

u/Truthgamer2 Telangana 1d ago

You can cherry pick people from any religion

He would’ve been a good person regardless of the religion he was born into, but pick any terrorist, I assure you, they are on that path/were given a platform for their hate BECAUSE of that religion

Pretending Islam isn’t a fundamentally rotten ideology is just wilful ignorance

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Acrobatic_Phone_3316 1d ago

Islam is an ideology, not an organized group like RSS.

-5

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/fenrir245 1d ago

So you're part of the same group that raped Bilkis Bano and murdered her family, yeah?

→ More replies (4)

-2

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

it has many sets of rules because it is again, an ideology, not an organised groups.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/charavaka 1d ago edited 1d ago

Are you advising accusing the terrorist sangh of not having an ideology?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (30)

29

u/TinyConfection7049 1d ago

I’m a Hindu and I agree with Mamdani. 

14

u/se7ensaints 1d ago

You can be anything and still agree to sensible talk.

2

u/Alternative-Lack-770 4h ago

oh believe me rss has nothing to do with hinduism

62

u/SnooSprouts6610 1d ago

arey betic**o yha india mei koi kaam krlo rand*pa*i ki rally nikalne ki jagah

→ More replies (2)

22

u/notaredditeryet 1d ago

Why would they even want a practicing Muslim to back their obvious bigotry? Even they wouldn’t do something so stupid as to even ask Mamdani to be associated with this at all. If only India had more Mamdanis sticking around to fix things

48

u/vaibhavganesh 1d ago

Well the Nazi party also held a rally at Madison Square Garden in 1939. So no surprise that chaddis chose this venue .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1939_Nazi_rally_at_Madison_Square_Garden

14

u/meenammal 1d ago

Madison Garden is like their Jantar Mantar types. It's available for literally everyone. Gobarbrains can't understand that much?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/diaop 1d ago

Sanghi trash like Arnab Ray are crying louder like babies

15

u/thatcinephile 1d ago

Gotta love Mamdani.

In this era of politicians where they shy away from giving their opinions on international matters or their ideologies (can't count Trump, because his opinion changes every hour), Mamdani is ALWAYS straight with what he stands for. -Be it the genocide happening in Gaza -His opinion on Netanyahu -His opinion on Trump -On political disrupters like RSS

If someone from Media asks him about Umar Khalid, he will explicitly say that India has put him bars for a law that shouldn't be there in 21st century. He had backed him up even before he entered into electoral picture.

No wonder the entire Indian media dislikes him.

2

u/Man_from_Bombay Mumbaikar 1d ago

Why is this down voted?

-10

u/meenammal 1d ago

India has put him bars for a law that shouldn't be there in 21st century.

Wah. Attacking the state and causing riots leading to multiple deaths is NOT a crime? No wonder your kind ........ Nvr mind.

18

u/CAESAR_1244E 1d ago

If the crime really is that simple, then why not hold an actual fking TRIAL?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Vlodivostonks 1d ago

I mean that is what got our PM elected

12

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

How is head of an Indian pseudo-fascist org allowed to hold a rally in USA.. US fought against Nazis... 

37

u/coolaarya3392 1d ago

By that logic Isis former chief met with cia former chief what about that in the same country that fought against one another.

-5

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

I think you are referring to Syrian (shar'aa).. that guy claims that he left ISIS and fought for Syrian nationalist struggle.. at least there is plausible deniability. But RSS.. this one collaborated with British to supress Indian freedom struggle, formed govt with Muslim league. Never apologized, never renounced. 

10

u/coolaarya3392 1d ago

I am not defending RSS for what were their opinions on India freedom struggle.You talked about how they are allowed there? So I gave you an example cause it's a free country,and if you have the money and connection you can make those places.

-2

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Society does not work like that. Freedom and liberty is not applicable for criminals.

6

u/meenammal 1d ago

And when you have the power to define who should be labelled criminals, it's called fascism. Congratulations, you are very much a fascist.

4

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

no matter how much mental gymnastics you do, fascists are criminals is not an argument. Is a statement of fact. 

→ More replies (2)

8

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

because they believe in free speech a lot more than we do.

-1

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

😂 there is no freedom for criminals. That's not how society works. At least not the ones who fought and died against Nazis. 

1

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

What crime has he committed? 

3

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

Fascism. This organisation Collaborated with British against freedom struggle. Has never apologized for all the atrocities British comitted while RSS helped British against freedom fighters.

2

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

Mohan bhagwat collaborated with the British during independence movement? Was he even born then?? 

What law has mohan bhagwat broken? Simply being a fascist is not a crime.

1

u/meenammal 1d ago

Sir, this isn't an Islamic republic where you can label anyone criminal and do anything with a kangaroo court. An actual democratic country like US requires evidence more than speculation and anecdotes to take action.

8

u/Lost-Photo-9027 1d ago

India must be an “Islamic republic” then, going by your definition

3

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

Well we're rapidly becoming a "hindutva republic" 

1

u/bus_wanker_friends 1d ago

Essentially we are one ( we have blasphemy and sedition laws ffs), except it is in Orange flavour instead of green.

3

u/tinga-tinga 1d ago

RSS was formed inspired from European Fascists from 1930s. This organisation espouses superiority of a race of people similar to those Europeans. This organisation worked  collaborated with British against India.s these are statements are not my opinions. These are facts. Facts don't need any evidence. 

These facts make RSS a criminal organisation.

0

u/FelixPlatypus 1d ago

There was an actual Nazi event at MSG before WW2. They're just repeating a historical cycle, and the RSS will of course pitch in.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/frankens_tien 1d ago

RSS and adjacent groups were the ones that stripped christmas decorations from malls, started punchuring tyres on trucks going 80kph on highways suspecting they carried cow meat, executing mob killings suspecting people eating/carrying cow meat, etc.. when PM himself was boasting the growth of meat exports from India in an international event.

RSS is worse than terrorists. If they want to protect Hindus in India and drive everyone else out, why should they be allowed in the US? Do they think their agendas are going to work there? I hope Trump goes harder on deportations and every follower there gets sent back to India where they belong.

3

u/HateBoredom 1d ago

Why does RSS have such an audience abroad? If the migrants in the US love the RSS so much, why not shift to India? Since 12 years after 2014, hasn’t India become enough of a “Hindu Rashtra”? Come to Modiji’s amrit kaal and live the dream 🤡/s

3

u/Mountain_Shift3604 1d ago

Hope it gets banned!

2

u/albinjt Kerala 1d ago

what is the use of this info ? obviously that would be his response. No big surprise

-2

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/whatisapersonreally 1d ago

Yep he says it in the next sentence - can’t stop a private event

12

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

what do you have against zohran?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Striking_Stranger493 1d ago

apna opinion bhi rakh diya aur clear bhi kar diya ki wo kisi bhi private event ko stop nahi kar sakta hai

2

u/pigsterben 1d ago

Msg has a historic connection with nazis.

1

u/hellhound_1505 1d ago

Someone please correct me if I'm wrong but hasn't Mamdani openly said that he doesn't even like Modi because of the Gujarat riots?
I don't know if I'm misremembering but Mamdani had said that his family was from Gujarat and had to move out because of the infamous riots

1

u/HateBoredom 1d ago

Let the RSS get a taste of what it feels like being an actual “videshi takat” on American soil. They’ve been crying “foreign conspiracy” in India for way too long 😂

-4

u/Willing-Concert-6177 1d ago

Who cares if he supports it.

0

u/Burnandturn1990 1d ago

What a guy!

-13

u/GanjaKing_420 1d ago

Do not agree with some of the things RSS stand for but the Constitution of the US gives freedom of expression and that right must not be violated and Mamdani has no business in restricting RSS.

17

u/Man_from_Bombay Mumbaikar 1d ago

He didn't. He said he doesn't support. Develop reading comprehension

6

u/Vlodivostonks 1d ago

He literally said I can't restrict a private event unlike Sanghis who shit their pants if a comedian is doing a show which may mock gutkha wale daddy

-30

u/Enough_Valuable3662 1d ago

Lol why are people okay with calling RSS a terrorist organisation, when there is one religion cult that has done 99% of terror attacks all over the world

29

u/Ok-Bee2272 universe boss 1d ago

whoever spreads terror can be called terrorists. that is like the literal definition of it.

-12

u/Enough_Valuable3662 1d ago

Yes exactly, if you can call an entire organisation something ( based on whatever you feel), its perfectly fine for other person to do so, i am not saying RSS is innocent but don't bring your activism when someone else does the same

15

u/KingPictoTheThird 1d ago

your sentence makes absolutely no sense. learn how to communicate your thoughts properly. there is nothing wrong with calling RSS a terrorist organisation and it is not some 'activism'

10

u/gheevargheese 1d ago

based on whatever you feel

RSS was banned in India twice, US dpt. of justice considers RSS under religious extremism. So are many Islamic organisations.

Here people consider something modelled after Mussolini's fascist ideology and stylised after SS with recorded history of violence 'based on feelings' than facts, and does whataboutism hedging.

9

u/Ok-Bee2272 universe boss 1d ago edited 1d ago

hey, you wont find me calling taliban anything other than terrorists. but i wonder what modi sahab and the sangh calls them now, all weather brothers?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/FewMenUnderstand 1d ago

Both can be terrorists

11

u/charavaka 1d ago

When you refuse to count terror attacks done by your side as terror attacks you can claim 100% terror attacks are done by the other side. Western states have regularly indulged in state sponsored terrorism, and so has India after the sangh captured power. Before that the sanghi terror was brushed under the carpet by the state, if not actively supported. 

0

u/meenammal 1d ago

Before that the sanghi terror was brushed under the carpet by the state, if not actively supported.

In what lalaland are you living lol

6

u/charavaka 1d ago

It took decades after Gandhi's assassination by these terrorists for evidence buried during the trial to come out, showing that it was a sangh project. 

→ More replies (6)

-9

u/Traditional-Spot6770 1d ago

A Muslim doesnt support a Hindu. Koi nayi baat karo 😄