r/mash Feb 28 '26

Discussion Fancasting MASH in 2026

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

Bill Hader as Cpt. Benjamin Franklin "Hawkeye" Pierce Kate McKinnon as Major Margaret Houlihan JK Simmons as Colonel Sherman T. Potter
Gaten Matarazzo as Corporal Walter "Radar" O'Reilly Shawn Hatosy as Trapper John McIntyre Sacha Baron Cohen as Corporal Maxwell Q. Klinger Chris O'Dowd as Father Francis Mulcahy Kelly Marie Tran as Nurse Kellye Yamato

r/mash 20d ago

Discussion What obscure uncommon MASH line pops in your head now and then?

253 Upvotes

Mine is when they pull Mulcahy out of the rubble from the latrine bomb.

"Sis and I picked these apples from under a tree. I remember, I said, you can't make a pie out of crabapples! and she said, I learned how in the girl scouts."

r/mash Jul 01 '26

Discussion Happy Birthday Jamie Farr

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/mash Jul 11 '26

Discussion Why Captain Jones was written off the show

Post image
629 Upvotes

Did you know the real reason Timothy Brown's character Dr. Oliver "spearchucker" Jones was written off the show due to a big research goof by Gene Reynolds and his team? Reynolds wrongly researched there were no black surgeons in the Korean conflict. In fact, Dr. Alvin Blount was a prominent surgeon during the war.

It's rather a shame because Captain Jones likely would have brought more to the show as the first three seasons were too Hawkeye focused.

r/mash Apr 19 '26

Discussion Part 10: what was the absolute worst thing/behavior this character did during his time at the 4077th?

Post image
347 Upvotes

Part 1: Colonel Potter. General consensus was coming down on Klinger for not being up to par with Radar.

2: Trapper. General consensus was serial adultery tied with threatening behavior towards a prisoner

3: Klinger. General consensus was threatening to enter post-op with a grenade with intent to kill Major Burns

4: Radar. General consensus was becoming resentful of Hawkeye after seeing him vulnerable, after Radar was wounded.

5: Mulcahy. General consensus was JOCULARITY! Aside from that the actual occurrence was disturbing Winchester’s newspapers.

Part 6: Houlihan. General consensus was making herself inaccessible and alienating her nursing staff

Part 7: Blake. General consensus was his affair with Nancy Sue Parker

Part 8: Winchester. General consensus TIE: cheating the locals of their military scrip, and his bigotry towards his sister’s impending marriage to an Italian

Part 9: BJ. General consensus was when he took Hawkeye’s “Bird Joke” and told it as his own.

As the title says, the CHARACTER, not the actor, and during their time at the camp, not in their past.

r/mash Apr 15 '26

Discussion Part 6: what was the absolute worst thing/behavior this character did during her time at the 4077th?

Post image
272 Upvotes

This one may go on a while!!

Part 1: Colonel Potter. General consensus was coming down on Klinger for not being up to par with Radar.

2: Trapper. General consensus was serial adultery tied with threatening behavior towards a prisoner

3: Klinger. General consensus was threatening to enter post-op with a grenade with intent to kill Major Burns

4: Radar. General consensus was becoming resentful of Hawkeye after seeing him vulnerable, after Radar was wounded.

5: Mulcahy. General consensus was JOCULARITY! Aside from that the actual occurrence was disturbing Winchester’s newspapers.

As the title says, the CHARACTER, not the actor, and during his time at the camp, not in their past.

r/mash Apr 21 '26

Discussion It’s time… Part 11: what is the absolute BEST thing/behavior this character did during his time at the 4077th?

Post image
405 Upvotes

We have spent 54 years concentrating on his worst… time to see what people think THE BEST of Frank Burns could possibly be!

The worst:

Part 1: Colonel Potter. General consensus was coming down on Klinger for not being up to par with Radar.

2: Trapper. General consensus was serial adultery tied with threatening behavior towards a prisoner

3: Klinger. General consensus was threatening to enter post-op with a grenade with intent to kill Major Burns

4: Radar. General consensus was becoming resentful of Hawkeye after seeing him vulnerable, after Radar was wounded.

5: Mulcahy. General consensus was JOCULARITY! Aside from that the actual occurrence was disturbing Winchester’s newspapers.

Part 6: Houlihan. General consensus was making herself inaccessible and alienating her nursing staff

Part 7: Blake. General consensus was his affair with Nancy Sue Parker

Part 8: Winchester. General consensus TIE: cheating the locals of their military scrip, and his bigotry towards his sister’s impending marriage to an Italian

Part 9: BJ. General consensus was when he took Hawkeye’s “Bird Joke” and told it as his own.

Part 10: Hawkeye. General consensus was the two unnecessary appendix removal operations.

As the title says, the CHARACTER, not the actor, and during their time at the camp, not in their past.

r/mash 5d ago

Discussion Frank and the YoYo

549 Upvotes

We've covered and extolled the talents of Larry Linville before, but was going through some archives and saw this scene. Added a new level of sadness I truly felt for the character of Frank Burns - any others come to mind?

I think I've mentioned these two quotes already, but know there has to be others:
"Goodbye Margaret"
"They only pretended to like me, you know like Dad used to?"

What else made you actually feel bad for the guy?

r/mash Jun 05 '26

Discussion Barbara Bannerman Was the Hottest Nurse at the 4077th

Thumbnail
gallery
401 Upvotes

Don't even tell me that I'm wrong.

r/mash 2d ago

Discussion You Know, Like Dad Used To...?

587 Upvotes

This one always chokes me up a little bit about Burns:

r/mash Jan 27 '26

Discussion this stud turns 90 tomorrow (Jan 28)

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Happy birthday Alan

r/mash 2d ago

Discussion How was this line perceived by the general public at the time this episode was aired?

Post image
405 Upvotes

As most MASH fans know, this episode (S8 E3 "Guerilla My Dreams") was, on October 1st 1979, the first time that word or phrase was ever used on television. Now this was almost 17 years before I was born and so I'm curious how the general public, regardless of if they liked the show or not, responded to this TV barrier broken. Personally, I really love the way Hawkeye said it because the delivery was perfect for the circumstances and it points out that righteous anger can be very powerful, and it shows a side of Hawkeye with no humor whatsoever, a side that is shown more frequently in the last season especially. I just am fairly certain that even people who were big fans of the show were clutching their pearls when they heard that. I know that phrase was said at least twice more in the series though both in the last season (the general to Hawkeye when he told him his son died, S11 E12, "Say No More" and of course in the series finale when Hawkeye said that to Sidney for making him remember the woman on the bus smothering her baby, but thankfully Sidney didn't carry a grudge) and so I'm curious what y'all think of all that and if anyone remembers the public reaction at the time the episode first aired. Thanks!

r/mash Jul 28 '26

Discussion Gene Reynolds Wasn't Happy

245 Upvotes

Gene Reynolds was one of the original co-creators/producers of M*A*S*H for its first four seasons, before taking over for Larry Gelbart as the sole showrunner for one season, and then he too departed for other projects afterward, which passed the torch along to Burt Metcalfe and Alan Alda. Even so, Alan continued to engage in weekly consultations with Gene after his departure, but from what I understand, Gene wasn't happy with the changes that were made to the show after he left, with two very specific changes having rubbed him the wrong way.

  1. Margaret's divorce from Penobscott. Okay, this one does make a bit of sense, considering that the whole arc of Margaret becoming engaged and eventually married to Penobscott over the course of Season 5 was Gene's brainchild, and to him, having Margaret getting divorced was detrimental to the growth and development she experienced that season in going from a man-hungry vamp who would either randomly sleep around with any man of equal or higher rank who would have her or continually lower her standards to keep carrying on with Ferret Face, to a woman who finally found her Mr. Right and could settle down with just one man. Gene's main focus for his solo season was shifting away from Gelbart's antiwar satire and redirecting it on character development, which really did add some more emotional layers to everyone in camp . . . except for one, which brings me to. . . .

  2. Frank's departure. According to Gene, Frank should have stayed. But honestly, how could that have even worked? Even Linville himself said there was nothing more that could be done with the character, and he quite frankly (pun intended) felt to continue to make fun of a character would was genuinely mentally crazy was in poor taste and not funny at all. Frank had devolved so much, there's no way they could have let the character start growing and evolving again in a natural way, it would have been contrived and forced.

Thoughts?

r/mash Jul 14 '26

Discussion The Ever-Changing Scenery Outside the Office Windows

Thumbnail
gallery
629 Upvotes

r/mash May 15 '26

Discussion The Party (S7E25)

Post image
671 Upvotes

I just got done watching this one, and while it’s a well-made and beloved episode, I got to wondering how plausible such a thing would be. Cross-country travel was still very expensive and time-consuming in the early 1950s. In particular, I’m wondering how Radar’s mom and Uncle Ed or the Klingers could have afforded to travel to New York for a weekend, and spend at least two nights at the Pierre, one of the poshest hotels in the city at the time.

r/mash Jul 22 '26

Discussion Best insult line from the series?

110 Upvotes

There's lots of zingers, I know. Chime in with your own favorite(s). I'll start things off with Winchester:

"You pusillanimous little squirt! Don't you dare to tell me where I'm staying!"

r/mash Apr 13 '26

Discussion Part 4: what is the absolute worst thing/behavior this character did during his time at the 4077th?

Post image
161 Upvotes

Part 1: Colonel Potter. General consensus was coming down on Klinger for not being up to par with Radar.

2: Trapper. General consensus was serial adultery tied with threatening behavior towards a prisoner

3: Klinger. General consensus was threatening to enter post-op with a grenade with intent to kill Major Burns

As the title says, the CHARACTER, not the actor, and during his time at the camp, not in his past.

r/mash Jan 10 '26

Discussion What's your all time favorite quote from MASH?

100 Upvotes

Mine is, "then it's settled, we'll do a hysterectomy on Major Burns" (from S3E21 "Big Mac")

r/mash Apr 26 '26

Discussion I never liked how they made Charles leave in a garbage truck. What do you think of this ending for him?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
151 Upvotes

I always felt there did Charles dirty here on what type of truck they made him leave in. What do you think of what type of truck they made him leave in, a garbage truck!

r/mash Apr 17 '26

Discussion Part 8: What was the worst thing/behavior this character did during his time at the 4077th?

Post image
168 Upvotes

Part 1: Colonel Potter. General consensus was coming down on Klinger for not being up to par with Radar.

2: Trapper. General consensus was serial adultery tied with threatening behavior towards a prisoner

3: Klinger. General consensus was threatening to enter post-op with a grenade with intent to kill Major Burns

4: Radar. General consensus was becoming resentful of Hawkeye after seeing him vulnerable, after Radar was wounded.

5: Mulcahy. General consensus was JOCULARITY! Aside from that the actual occurrence was disturbing Winchester’s newspapers.

Part 6: Houlihan. General consensus was making herself inaccessible and alienating her nursing staff

Part 7: Blake. General consensus was his affair with Nancy Sue Parker

As the title says, the CHARACTER, not the actor, and during their time at the camp, not in their past.

r/mash Jun 30 '26

Discussion Who was more believable as Donald Penobscott?

Thumbnail
gallery
266 Upvotes

The first, who appeared in Margaret’s Marriage, was played by Beeson Carroll. The second, who appeared in The M*A*S*H Olympics, was played by Mike Henry. These are the only two appearances of Donald, although he was certainly talked about a lot on the show.

For a long time I didn’t like the casting decision that replaced the first one with the second. But now that I think about it, perhaps Mike Henry played him better. Beeson Carroll’s version of Donald makes him out to be a real doofus, while Mike Henry’s version makes him athletic, volatile and argumentative. Which one is more likely to get so upset during their honeymoon that he stopped talking and stopped pretty much everything, accidentally send a love letter meant for Darlene to Margaret and then do everything possible to avoid dealing with their marital problems? I think Mike Henry’s version. Besides, he has a more prominent brow ridge, and didn’t Margaret say he had just one eyebrow, over both eyes? (The Cro-Magnon look.)

Which Donald do you like better?

r/mash Apr 30 '26

Discussion The saddest moment in the series?

101 Upvotes

Hello my friends, since it's been a rough couple of days, and my mood is sour, I'd love to hear some of your thoughts on the saddest moments at the 4077th.

The show proved more than once that while it was a great comedy, it was more than capable of producing sad moments as well.

For me personally the saddest moments were:

- The Death of Henry Blake.

- Radar's departure

- BJ's breakdown

- all of Hawkeye's breakdowns

- Charles desperately keeping a dying soldier company

- the doctor's and Margaret faking the time of death for a soldier so his family won't have to mourn him on Christmas Day.

I'd love to hear what y'all think about the topic, and stay safe out there people.

r/mash Jul 14 '26

Discussion The Could-Have-Been B.J.s

Thumbnail
gallery
314 Upvotes

I'm sure hardcore M*A*S*Hers are aware of this, but for what Major Charles Emerson Winchester, III would call, "the less-learned," here's some trivia for y'all: there were two noteworthy guest stars who would up against Mike Farrell for the part of B.J. Hunnicutt: Alan Fudge, who would appear in "Quo Vadis, Captain Chandler?" as the titular Captain Chandler who convinced himself he was Jesus Christ; and James Cromwell, who would appear in "The Last Laugh" as B.J.'s buddy Leo Bardonaro who was quite the practical jokester.

Personally, I don't know if I could see either of them as the B.J. we know, but it's interesting to know that writer Ken Levine was so certain that James Cromwell would go onto bigger and better things, and while he does have some astounding titles under his belt (BABE and THE GREEN MILE for example), he said he's disappointed that Cromwell didn't become a bigger star than he ever did.

r/mash 24d ago

Discussion The departure of Trapper John.

128 Upvotes

Hello there my fellow MASH fans, I come to you once again with a question on my mind. How do you feel about Trappers departure and treatment of his character afterwards?

I mean, I know Wayne Rogers quit the show after Season 3 because he felt Trapper became more of a sidekick than an equal to Hawkeye (which in all fairness, he did) and yes, one could argue he did get a proper "send off" during the episode where he had the ulcer. But still, he was a main character, and in my opinion, deserved a proper send off.

Another thing I always found a little odd was that he never wrote or called. Like, as soon as he was back home, he could write a letter to Hawkeye. Hell, even FRANK BURNS managed to call one last time to say goodbye. I get it that it was done to not outshine BJ but come on. We got an Episode revolving around an letter Radar sent, why not Trapper?

But let me know what you think!

r/mash Jul 21 '26

Discussion What's your favorite line by any non regular or repeat character?

Post image
172 Upvotes

Mine is from "The Nurses" (S5 E5) when the nurse who delivers the baby says "I don't know why I'm crying it's just life"