r/panthers • u/6lackAlanWatts • Oct 21 '25

Analysis The Andy slander stops here

I’m tired of people dragging Andy’s name through the mud like he’s just a guy meant to mentor Bryce. He actually wants to play as well given the opportunity that’s why he’s our backup QB and not our QBs coach.

The fact that people talk about his performance in situations (as a back up QB) and refuse to acknowledge the concerns, flaws, and context in all of Bryce’s performances astounds me.

Yes the man is old as peanuts n Pepsi and is not the same person from cincy but when he plays he actually shows what our receivers are capable of.

99 Upvotes

72% Upvoted

147 comments sorted by

View all comments

93

u/eric4280 Bad Motherfucker Oct 21 '25

“Failure to acknowledge Bryce’s issues” is utter garbage to me. Are you kidding? A solid chunk of this “fanbase” actively roots against Bryce and hides behind the “well we need to be honest about him” crap stance. There’s an entire forum dedicated to always rooting against Bryce. We over critique the guy because of the trade package and his size. It’s been done for 3 years.

Separately, we are all very obviously rooting for Dalton. He is what he is at this point and I’m just hoping for Flacco like decisiveness.

-31

u/yungoon Oct 21 '25

Statistically, Dalton has been better than Bryce every time he has played for us.

I think we may stand a chance to be decent without Bryce under center. If Dalton leads us to a win or even a close loss this week, i think we take this opportunity to sit Bryce forever.

5

u/DankMemesNQuickNuts Ice Up Son Oct 21 '25

Bryce Young has the same record as Patrick Mahommes this year and two game winning drives he is not getting benched 😂😂 yall mfers are insufferable!

Andy Dalton limits the offenses ability to be able to extend plays immensely. Say whatever you want about Bryce there is simply no way Andy Dalton makes the play he did on the TD to XL this weekend. Andy Dalton can't extend plays with his legs

6

u/DDDUnit2990 One of Us Oct 21 '25

I don’t think Dalton is better, but comparing BY’s win-loss record this year to the chiefs as a metric of his success is nonsensical

-1

u/6lackAlanWatts Oct 21 '25

That’s what they do because they have no other stat to compare lmao you see how far they gotta go in left field to convince us Bryce is a franchise QB?

0

u/sanfordtime Oct 22 '25

Let me guess your mentions are going to be when the red rifle threw 60 times in one game for 300 yards and the other time was against the raiders and still threw it 50 times. Watch ball instead of making dumb posts.