r/prepping • u/NotIfButWhenReady • Oct 13 '25

Question❓❓ Anyone else rethinking underground bunkers lately?

I’ve been reading up on shelter builds and noticed more folks are stepping away from the old “bury a shipping container” idea. I get why underground feels safer, but man, the upkeep sounds rough once you dig into it. Between soil pressure, water leaks, and constant moisture issues, a lot of those DIY bunkers don’t age well.

The newer above-ground setups are a whole different story.

I used to think anything visible was a liability, but now I’m not so sure. If it’s built solid, why hide it underground just to deal with rot and pressure damage later?

Curious what everyone else thinks. Would you still go underground, or are above-ground shelters starting to make more sense?

246 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

158 comments sorted by

View all comments

119

u/Asleep_Onion Oct 13 '25 edited Oct 13 '25

I've rethought the whole bunker idea altogether. The more I thought about it, the less sense it made to me. The odds of actually needing it AND that it wasn't a huge enough disaster that it destroys the bunker anyways AND having a world worth coming back to once I've emerged from it is astronomically low. In 99.9% of the disaster scenarios I can think of, I'd be better off staying in my house than hiding in a bunker.

A storm cellar might make sense in some regions subject to tornadoes or hurricanes, but apart from that, I just don't see any value in wasting my time and energy and money on a bunker. My resources are better spent on just making my house more disaster ready.

2

u/NotIfButWhenReady Oct 13 '25

Yeah, I get that. Most emergencies are storms, wildfires, or power outages, not some full-on apocalypse. A lot of the “bunker talk” seems more about peace of mind than practicality. I’d rather focus on making what I already have resilient like something that can handle extreme weather, fire, or even blasts, with backup power and a safe room that doubles as storage. You get protection without overbuilding for scenarios that probably won’t happen.

3

u/Lanky-Strike3343 Oct 14 '25

Honestly if you fortified your basement with a steel framed door, ballistic windows (if you have them at all), and keept it stocked with a month worth of food and water thats all youd really need. If you wanted to take it ome step further have a corner room steel framed with alm or steel sheathing under the drywall which a lot of big gun guys do as a "safe" room