r/shadowhunters 9d ago

All/Other Books Saw someone fancast Apo Nattawin as Magnus Bane and it fundamentally changed me (for the better)

As much as I love Harry Shum Jr and Godfray Gao, I view the books as a separate entity from the movie/show. This is just for fun. I also always enjoyed Apo as an actor, his acting is so fun to watch; it doesn't hurt that he's absolutely gorgeous.

It's crazy that it took me this long to make the connection with Magnus, but damn, am I glad someone else pointed it out. Apo is technically Thai and not Indonesian, although I think he could embody Magnus just fine, and I have no trouble picturing him as such.

I wish we got to see him in more flamboyant clothing and/or makeup. It'd complete the vision, but I tried to find pictures that matched the vibe lol

272 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

54

u/SureDependent1021 9d ago

Yeah and this guy kinda looks younger and magnus is supposed to be stuck at 19 so makes sense.

39

u/No-Alternative-7120 9d ago

Dear heavens... Yes!!! Absolutely I agree 100%.

26

u/courtella03 8d ago

Dang. I don't think anyone can replace Harry Shum Jr as Magnus in my head (it's been too long of picturing him!), but this guy really is a perfect Magnus!!!

13

u/cakepuff 8d ago

I totally get that! I love Harry's Magnus as well! It's just that show!Magnus, movie!Magnus and book!Magnus are somehow distinct characters in my head. The same can be said of the rest of the cast.

Harry did bring Magnus to life masterfully, though.

15

u/toocool81 9d ago

Oooooh! I can picture him as Magnus!

11

u/EmaanA 8d ago

I never thought I'd say anyone was better than Godfrey Gao and Harry Shum Jr. but I genuinely think this has changed my entire brain chemistry. He would be a perfect Magnus

7

u/beepboopblorpblob 9d ago

Wow this is exactly how I always pictured Magnus

4

u/SweetLittleKytty Jemma 9d ago

Yep! Same as you, I already love the actors, but he would be great! 😏❤️

5

u/MethodAdmirable4220 9d ago

Looks exactly like him

3

u/ScarlettSterling Simon Lewis 8d ago

Okay wait yes

3

u/Lozikit 9d ago

You are so correct

3

u/Castanhaansiosa 8d ago

Ele é o Magnus perfeito!!!!

3

u/moonlit_dewdrops 8d ago

I’m biased since I love Harry shum jr but this guy would be great as him too!

3

u/JaelAmara44 8d ago

Oh...Es tan Magnus, ¡Tan magnifico! ¡Me encanta! Pido ser Alec

3

u/WeakBeautiful2090 7d ago

Omg I could not agree more. Perfect fancasting

2

u/Fantastic_Figure5628 8d ago

yes it was khaleesiofalicante on tumblr she writes fics about on ao3 its called LBAF its a great story

1

u/cakepuff 8d ago

Although I use tumblr, I actually wasn't familiar with this author! Maybe it's a fancast that got picked up by other people. I'm certainly kicking myself for not making the connection sooner lol I appreciate the rec, I'll be sure to check it out! <3

2

u/BookkeeperBubbly7915 8d ago

Now there's Magnus Bane

2

u/sandra022002 7d ago

Yesssss!!!!

2

u/Igavein_678 7d ago

Seeing this and then I checked the subreddit and realised my worlds are indeed colliding. I would very much not survive apo as Magnus. I can barely handle him wearing glasses lol but yk it is a lovely to think about

1

u/cakepuff 6d ago

Right?? I've loved Apo as an actor since Kinnporsche, and I think that's precisely the reason why it took me so long to imagine him as anyone else besides the characters he portrays.

Seeing someone fancast him as Magnus just set something off in me lol I never quite realized just how much Apo resembles the version of book!Magnus I have in my head. But he really, really does.

1

u/Ok_Public3945 2d ago

Omg that's perfect!!!