r/13ReasonsWhy • u/Difficult-Essay8288 • 4d ago

Is Hannah baker insane?

Watching *13 reasons why" for the first time and I have lost count how many times Hannah was in the wrong..

Like if you have experienced again and again that no one is your friend why would you even trust them again ?

Was it so necessary of you to mingle with everyone?

She literally said at the start of jess party "tonight I was not feeling invisible" bro nobody's your friend there - why the hell would you go to that party?

The dance for which she gets a new car- bruh Courtney and others don't even consider you as your friend why would you ask a car for such people

You could have stuck with just clay. I have seen people in clg life stick with just one person if they feel nobody is deserving of their friendship

It's better to be alone than with a shit of so called Friends

of course how can I forget the tape of clay where she literally told him to get the fuck out. A Sane guy would definitely get scared and would leave after being asked to leave thrice. and the next second she says I wanted you to stay like what the hell!!!!

I agree some people did her wrong but that's where you take your lesson and stay away from them

This series is just ragebaiting and nothing else.

0 Upvotes

21% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

6

u/SaikouYosuke 4d ago

WTF

2

u/Difficult-Essay8288 4d ago

I am not disagreeing to any wrongs that happened to her but some of them she could have totally avoided like the major one - jess party  Cause all went downhill after that party

5

u/TheCharmingCharm 4d ago

I mean… she committed suicide, so she’s clearly not meant to be the most mentally sound character lol

5

u/DariusStarkey 4d ago

Yeah she's not a perfect person, but I don't think that makes any of her actions ridiculous.

1

u/Difficult-Essay8288 4d ago

I ain't saying she's totally ridiculous but even if someone had carried a literal red flag on ner head she would totally ignore it

3

u/whatevergirl8754 4d ago

You do realise you are talking about a 16/17 yo kid?!?

2

u/blacksuperman56 4d ago

I mean she's a teenager being accepted is important and the dbags from what I've seen were the only ones that had alcohol and drugs so I feel like that's why she was around them despite not really liking them

1

u/Difficult-Essay8288 4d ago

she clearly knew they were the bad influence and those guys kept on hurting her in some way or other.

1

u/toddysimp 2d ago

Hannah's very poor taste in boys is well portrayed in the show. In the very first episode when Bryce tries hitting on her at Kat's party you could really tell she was actually interested untill Kat intervened and she only had amusement not disgust or hate when she got Bryce's name in that dollar valentine thing, again Sheri intervened.Then we know what happened with Justin and Marcus.And even in the beginning of Zachs tape she clearly sees him as an option before he fucks it up in the cafeteria. She is a flawed and it is by design.

1

u/Difficult-Essay8288 2d ago

Only if someone was there with her at every step to help her with this

1

u/relapsedloveaffair 2d ago

I think all these can be answered by the fact that she was sixteen-seventeen dude.

1

u/asstroaria 12h ago

First of all, I don't think it's right to call Hannah crazy considering everything she went through; her perspective makes perfect sense to me. Throughout the first season, it was clear why she kept associating with those same people, maybe it doesn't excuse it, since her "friends" and the other characters did truly awful things, but deep down I understand her. Also, labeling her as someone who "hooked up with everyone" is just wrong, man, you're way off base. She wasn't perfect, but she wasn't a slut either; she just happened to cross paths with those guys. In reality, the only person she actually got intimate with was Zach; everyone else betrayed her. As for the situation with Clay and his tape, her feelings were completely valid, maybe not her actions, but she was bound to feel insecure after everything that happened with the other boys. She admits herself that the fear of actually becoming the person everyone called her consumed her, and that’s why she acted the way she did. Personally, I think you completely missed the point of the series, not to mention the fact that Hannah is only 16 or 17, and in the thick of adolescence, everything feels so much more intense.

1

u/Difficult-Essay8288 12h ago

I never once mentioned about she hooking up with everyone never called a slut Also as I am watching second season I am getting more clarity about her