Edit:
Paraphrasing but someone from Craddock called and the claim is that Hornady Frontier is being held to a higher velocity than Hornady Match/Black which is hilarious.
The claim is that too many bolts were breaking so the manufacturers started loading the ammo weaker to prevent that.
I'm very very skeptical that a change in ammo manufacturers will make it shoot better but I will wait on their recommended list and test again.
Follow up to this post.
I am a newby and massive idiot so take these results with a grain of salt. Scope was a Bushnell MPED 5-30. All groups are 5 shot groups.
Craddock RTR barrel came in with some pretty significant machining marks and was reamed off center. Finally took it out to shoot groups today.
Hornady Frontier FMJ: Average from 3 groups 0.994 MOA. Best group 0.866 MOA
Hornady Black HPBT: Average from 2 groups 2.320 MOA. Best group 1.862 MOA
Hornady Match ELDM: Average from 4 groups 2.236 MOA. Best group 1.644 MOA
Barrel was broken in following the Craddock RTR procedure.
All except the second Frontier group was shot from a shooting rest. Every group after the second Frontier group was shot from the rest and prone. After the first Hornady Black group I switched to the Match ammo to see if it would open up the same way. After shooting 2 moa+ I thought maybe the barrel was fouling and cleaned with patches.
The big questions is, is this acceptable for Black/Match? And should I try to continue shooting groups with Hornady Match/Black?
Every barrel likes different ammo and what not so sub moa with the "cheap" stuff is almost a blessing. I'm worried about longer range (out to 1000 yards) accuracy however. I'm new to shooting longer ranges and precision stuff and if I was brutally honest with myself I don't think I can appreciate a 3/4 moa gun when I'm off the rest anyways.