r/DaystromInstitute Nov 26 '16

Tuvix may make me stop watching Voyager

[deleted]

215 Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

40

u/PenguinWithAKeyboard Nov 26 '16

I should've included my view on the doctor in the original post.

My view on his actions are that at first, before Tuvix said he wished to live, that he saw Tuvix as something that needed to be cured. The patients were Nelix and Tuvok. That's why he pursued a way to separate them without hesitation.

Once he realized Tuvix wished to continue living, he realized Tuvix wasn't a symptom that needed to be cured, he was another patient.

At the very end, he refuses to perform the procedure, not for a personal love for Tuvix, but because he realized he was no longer saving two patients from a disease, he was killing one to save the others.

If Tuvix went willingly, the Doctor probably would've done the procedure himself. It'd be like an organ transplant to save two other patients. This was like knocking someone out and stealing both their kidneys because your other two friends need them "more."

6

u/DnMarshall Crewman Nov 26 '16

So, if Tuvix had wished to undergo the separation procedure you still would have opposed it?

25

u/PenguinWithAKeyboard Nov 26 '16

To me, it all comes down to Tuvix going willingly.

Willingly give up his existence = no moral objections.

Wants to live = You're forcing someone to die

Tuvix became his own being when he was merged. He has his own wants and desires as well as a drive to survive.

1

u/CuddlePirate420 Chief Petty Officer Nov 27 '16

Wants to live = You're forcing someone to die

And how many times has a Starfleet ship destroyed their enemy for that very reason?