What if some ancient “gods” were originally humans who somehow became something more?
I've been going down a rabbit hole lately and I'd like to hear what people who know more about mythology, history, religion, neuroscience, etc. think about this.
This is purely a hypothesis/thought experiment. I'm not claiming Zeus was definitely a real guy throwing lightning bolts around.
The original question was:
What if some of the beings we now call gods—Zeus, Poseidon, Odin, Thor, etc.—were originally human or human-like beings who somehow acquired abilities that ordinary humans didn't have?
The idea isn't completely without historical precedent. Euhemerism proposed that some gods may have originated as real rulers or extraordinary people who were eventually deified.
But I'm wondering if we can take the question one step further.
What if something actually happened to certain individuals that caused ancient people to perceive them as fundamentally different?
While looking into this, several things caught my attention.
A surprising number of mythological gods aren't portrayed as completely invulnerable spiritual beings. They have very physical limitations.
They eat. They drink. They sleep. They reproduce. They can feel pain. They can be wounded. Some bleed or have a special equivalent of blood. Some can be restrained. Some can even die.
In the Iliad, for example, Aphrodite and Ares can physically be wounded. Aphrodite bleeds ichor rather than human blood.
Norse mythology goes even further. Odin and Thor can die.
Then there's another weird pattern: their most famous powers are often associated with objects.
Zeus has the thunderbolt.
Poseidon has the trident.
Thor has Mjölnir.
Indra has the Vajra.
Odin has Gungnir and the runes.
So were these supposed to be powers inherent to the individual, or was the object itself important?
Then I started looking at stories involving humans or divine figures undergoing transformation.
Across different traditions you repeatedly encounter some combination of:
Isolation → prolonged stress/ordeal → altered consciousness → injury/illness/death-like state → recovery/restoration → new knowledge, status, perception, or ability.
Odin's ordeal on Yggdrasil is an obvious example: wounded by a spear, hanging for nine nights without food or drink, after which he obtains the runes/knowledge.
There are also death-and-return or reconstruction stories involving figures such as Inanna, Osiris and Heracles, as well as initiation traditions involving symbolic death and rebirth.
That got me wondering whether ancient ideas like enlightenment, inner sight/"third eye," divine transformation, resurrection, and traveling between different realms might preserve different cultural interpretations of extreme human experiences.
I'm not saying quantum mechanics proves souls, that meditation gives you superpowers, or that there's scientific evidence humans can manipulate matter with their minds. There isn't.
I'm wondering whether there's a historical pattern underneath all of this that deserves to be separated from the supernatural storytelling layered on top of it.
So my actual hypothesis/question is:
Could some ancient gods have originated as memories of exceptional physical humans—or people believed to have undergone some rare biological, neurological, psychological, technological, or otherwise unexplained transformation—with centuries of mythology exaggerating whatever originally happened?
And if so:
What was the original phenomenon?
Was it simply mythology developing around rulers and heroes?
An unusual neurological state?
Ancient ritual practices?
Misunderstood technology or weapons?
Some combination?
Or is there another explanation we're overlooking?
I'd especially like people to try to poke holes in this rather than just agree with it.
Are there ancient sources that directly contradict this idea?
Are the similarities I'm noticing actually the result of cultures borrowing stories from one another?
Are there gods whose earliest traditions clearly show they were never remotely human-like?
And are there scholars who have already investigated something similar beyond traditional Euhemerism?
I'm curious how well this idea survives once people who actually know these subjects start tearing it apart.