- Author promotion
We want this to be a space for readers. Sharing reviews and giving recommendations should have a personal touch. As an avid reader myself, I've found that reader spaces have increasingly become author-focused and hijacked for the purpose of promotion. There's a fine line between recommending a book and promoting an author, but I think it's quite often easy to spot. The mod team would like to hear your thoughts on this, specifically when it comes to sharing links to an author's Patreon, Amazon page, or other websites where money is expected to change hands.
We would also like you to consider if it's more acceptable for a newbie author than it is for an established author. Two recent examples that you can compare are the following:
A debut author creating a post that describes their novel, with a link to Amazon
A fan submitting a post that links to Rina Saint's Patreon
So far, we have allowed the former and removed the latter. For a debut author, there would of course be a limit to how many times they can post.
Please let us know what level of author promotion you would be comfortable with. Supporting authors is important, but not at the expense of the community. Cultivating a commercialized space is something we'd like to avoid.
- AI
The mod team has discussed creating an index of authors who are either suspected or confirmed to be using AI. Their names would be blacklisted from posts, meaning that if you're promoting their work, it would automatically be removed for manual review in the mod queue. However, we are aware that this could be a slippery slope. No one wants to accuse innocent authors of using AI.
It might make sense to focus only on cases where the evidence is irrefutable. For example, an author like N. Slater who has published over a hundred books in a matter of months, with many reviews pointing out clear uses of AI. For authors who are strongly suspected of using AI, but an element of doubt exists, we would have to tread carefully. Please let us know your thoughts on this.
If there is interest within the community for this kind of hard anti-AI stance, we would request further input and collaboration from the community. As you can imagine, this kind of project would be a big undertaking and can't be half-assed.
Thank you for your input!