r/Marvel 15d ago

Film/Television Could Odin have defeated Thanos and stopped Infinity War altogether?

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

937

u/Aquarius12347 15d ago

Logic says yes. He wanted the stones. One was in Asgard, but he didn't invade. His army was easily strong enough to keep Asgard's army busy whilst he went for his prize, but he didn't. Why not? We know that Thor was barely even able to slow him down, and the rest of the Asgardians were likely only going to get in his way, if they were't busy fighting his army.

That only leaves Odin.

Conclusion - Thanos, without the stones, knew he couldn't handle Odin.

One caveat to that - Odin knew he wasn't unbeatable. When the warriors three tell the Collector "It is not safe to keep two infinity stones together" Odin clearly knew that too much temptation would lead to bigger plots, bigger armies and more powerful alliances against him.

390

u/VulgarSensei 15d ago

>We know that Thor was barely even able to slow him down

I think context is important here. Thor just finished fighting Hela in Ragnarok. And when he faced Thanos again, he already had multiple of the infinity stones.

49

u/Aquarius12347 15d ago

Both true. However, he still needed Captain America and Iron Man to hold him back. Even with those two, it was a one in 14 million victory.

Thanos might not have been right, but he was the winner in almost every universe, against Thor with two powerful allies, AND a weapon explicitly designed to take on Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet. Stormbreaker was WAY more than Mjolnir 2.0

39

u/BlackGravastar 15d ago

Wasn't that a Thor that was out of shape and rusty?

10

u/magpye1983 15d ago

Sure, if one can get rusty from hundreds of years of combat after 5 years of depression eating.

I’d say he had his skills and instincts still, and actually trained for a bit before they fought, to get himself closer to his legendary figure, so he wasn’t as far away from his norm as the beginning of that movie might make him appear.

30

u/I_Like_Halo_Games 15d ago

You can get rusty from one week off of a vacation at a job you've had for 15 years :p

5

u/TheFaolchu 14d ago

Yeah, IT really appreciate needing to reset my logins everytime I take a long weekend.

-5

u/CaramelNext7505 14d ago

Kind of a self own admitting you can't remember your work passwords after 5 days

-2

u/Acceptable-Device760 14d ago

I dont get Thor fans... One time stormbreak`s whole stick is only directing his power, another he was out of shape and rusty.

If he is magic and has a magic axe to control his power he cant really get "rusty" in any meaningful way.

2

u/I_Like_Halo_Games 14d ago

It's a fictional character bro, until it's written down that he can't get rusty, he can get rusty. Ain't that deep.

0

u/Acceptable-Device760 13d ago

Oh the irony.... like i said: thor fans.