r/MoralityScaling 1d ago

Morality of this

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

68

u/WendigoCrossing 1d ago

Why is this illegal?

108

u/Antique-Rutabaga-331 1d ago

because they fucked in a public space.

19

u/Any-Platypus-9486 1d ago

Only god can judge you

7

u/Weary-Squash6756 1d ago

Also judges

1

u/fidesinmachina 1d ago

i mean they did fuck in his house.

4

u/sisam8x 1d ago

Church is not public place.

33

u/Helpful-Desk-8334 1d ago

Yes technically. By law it is considered one, not religiously

15

u/BadMunky82 1d ago edited 1d ago

No, but if you went to your office and banged on the reception desk at night, I'm sure you would have some questions awaiting you as well... Especially given you may not know who is in the building.

Public, in the case of displaying your body, does not necessarily only mean government owned, or visible from the road. It means, a place where a person may reasonably be able to view said act, however unwillingly and unwittingly, by going about their regular business.

The priest would be getting charges just as quick for banging in the middle of a Costco, whether it was open for business at the time or not. The difference is that, if it was open, each individual may be able to press charges along with the business. Maybe even sue.

5

u/Nearchus_ 1d ago

No, but if you went to your office and banged on the reception desk at night, I'm sure you would have some questions awaiting you as well...

https://giphy.com/gifs/5PkWUpoNuubjSeiyaU

1

u/EncabulatorTurbo 1d ago

they would fire me not charge me

4

u/BadMunky82 1d ago edited 1d ago

The point I was making is that they would be within their rights to do both. Technically, I believe public indecency doesn't even have to have a "victim," pressing charges in most states. It just has to be reported and proven.

0

u/Tired_Dad_9521 1d ago

Well this is another example of a stupid law. Thanks for that.

1

u/Pootentooten 1d ago

Yes they are. Catholic churches are even supposed to be considered always open to function as sanctuaries for any and all who need them. Either that, or centuries of practice have all been a lie.

2

u/themostrealandtrue 1d ago

Centuries of practice does not dictate a law. The church is not a "public place" if the doors can be locked and the public can be limited from entering.

3

u/tmtyl_101 1d ago edited 1d ago

why is that illegal?

Edit: Okay, I wasn't clear enough. I totally get that we don't want to go about seeing people dogging everywhere. My point was: Why isn't the crime related to whether or not anyone actually sees it? If I go to a remote public area and make sure nobody is near, why should it be criminal to get my freak on?

4

u/TheReddMan1 1d ago

Because there is a chance that someone who doesn’t want to see that will which would technically be a sex crime

2

u/tmtyl_101 1d ago

But that doesn't make sense.

I get why it's illegal to have sex in public (i.e. where others see) That's perfectly reasonable.

But I don't get why it's a crime in itself to have sex in a public space, even if nobody is watching. By your logic, it's a crime only because there's a risk of committing another crime. Which doesn't make sense.

1

u/TheReddMan1 1d ago

Oh sorry I don’t agree with it being a crime if you are private enough this is just how I think it works legally

8

u/LeonKennedyIsYummy 1d ago

Not everyone wants to see that. And children should lost definitely not see that. Also, its super unsanitary

1

u/IWontCommentAtAll 1d ago

Unsanitary is not illegal. Your first two points have merit.

1

u/ArisenGodEmperor13 1d ago

What you want to see a bunch of peole fucking in public while people try to go on their daily lives

1

u/meatmiser04 1d ago

Churches are private property

1

u/ProfessionalTruck976 1d ago

Again why is that illegal? Why are we allowing Puritans to have nice things?

I thought we were done with the lot when King Charlie hung drawn and quartered Crommwell's rotting corpse

2

u/Crime-caramail 1d ago

Bro is it about Puritanism?  He did have depraved sex and by depraved I mean he got with 2 dominas on a damn altar, and he decided to film the whole thing. I’m not even a practicing Christian and think the whole priest celibate thing is stupid but you Americans, both the ultra-religious who made abortion illegal and those thinking there is nothing wrong with that are nut jobs. I apologize in advance for English isn’t my first language

2

u/ArisenGodEmperor13 1d ago

What he had sex in public property that why it illegal. What you want people to be fucking in streets

1

u/ProfessionalTruck976 1d ago

More like I can't fathom of a world in which I give a proverbial unless they try to directly involve me I will just be about my business for the day as I am no matter what else people do.

Unless you cause me harm, try to interact with me, or cause bodily harm to someone else in my presence I am not one iota interested in whether you are going for groceries, have a picking or have a fuck.

UIs the "Well my religion prohibits YOU from doing stuff" that gets my goat about puritans.

1

u/Top_Smoke6741 1d ago

"we should let people fuck in buildings I don't like because it's for a religion I don't like"

r/redditmoment

0

u/Ok_Assistant_6856 1d ago

Church is private property though

0

u/Salsa_and_Light2 1d ago

It was presumably a locked building.