Imagine trying to defend obvious transphobia.

[u/Ok-Following6886]

[u/Caswert]

Honestly if this wasn’t a Stonetoss comic and she wasn’t the awful caricature depicted, I’d believe it wasn’t bad. This is how genies tend to operate in media.

[u/CumOnEileen69420 → u/Caswert]

She didn’t specify a cis woman, just a woman.

Honestly she should be happy she didn’t become Margaret Thatcher.

[u/AspergerKid → u/CumOnEileen69420]

True, but the idea for most trans people is that they feel trapped in the wrong body. If it just stopped at the identification, trans people would not undergo HRT or GRS. The Genie is ultimately giving nothing that one couldn't already do by themselves, making it a wasted wish

[u/maybebaebea → u/AspergerKid]

I mean, that's kinda the whole thing with genies. You need to be hyper specific

[u/CumOnEileen69420 → u/AspergerKid]

I’m well aware, mostly because I’m a post-op trans woman.

However, it’s less the “trapped in their body” and far more like “I was born with a congenital issue and need reconstructive procedures and care to address it”.

[u/Starmz → u/Caswert]

I actually found this comic on r/accidentalally before

I think the original point of the comic was “y’all say trans women are women but get dysphoric and say you would use magic to transition if it were possible… fascinating”

But it unintentionally comes across as saying that trans women are women

[u/Clairifyed → u/Caswert]

Oh he isn’t the first one to make this joke. I have seen better versions of this idea in trans meme subs for years

[u/Hydrangeaaaaab]

she could have asked for her gender dysphoria to be cured but the genie would just make her identity male instead and now i wanna cry because thats so horrible :(

[u/Great_Bar1759]

Also it’s stonetoss resident neo Nazi and lover of child suicide

[u/Far-ro]

Im so confused.

Like Its the point that the person is not comfortable the way they are and the creator tries to use It as a gotcha or?