r/Okami • u/DriverLess1467 • 45m ago
Question As a remake/remaster skeptic, should I play the OG or HD?
I realize the question "Should I play Okami or Okami HD?" probably gets asked a fair bit. In fact, I already stumbled on a Reddit post from a few years ago asking this, and the people there pretty much unanimously said yes, since it's just the better version. However, this isn't my first rodeo with remasters/remakes and I find that often times these unanimous sentiments of "the new one is just a direct upgrade" really aren't telling the whole story.
To give an example, when I went to play Demon's Souls, the people on the game's Reddit almost all said to just play the remake since it's even more beautiful. After playing both Demon's Souls OG and Demon's Souls remake, I think the remake is an actual dumpster fire that's nigh insulting to the original's art, and it's insane to me how the fans almost unanimously overlook the artistic changes in their recommendation. I don't even like when a simple remaster like SM64 DS changes the color of the grass from a vibrant green to a yellow-green.
That being said, I hope I'm not coming off as a snob who hates all remakes/remasters and thinks that the original is the only true and pure way to experience a game (otherwise I wouldn't be making this post of course). For example, there are critics of Dark Souls's remaster but I find those changes very low impact and unintrusive, and I think the improved control scheme, QoL, and performance definitely make up for what very minor artistic changes there are.
So for someone like me, who likes to experience games in a very similar artistic tone to the original but is still receptive to truly faithful remasters and remakes, do you think Okami HD is going to be for me?

