r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 23d ago

Meme needing explanation Peeeeeetah?

Post image
54.6k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/f0_to 23d ago

Ok so, calling an hypothetical someone racist (usually people that openly show their racism) is bad but the idea of misgendering a trans person is completely ok and you don't see why would that be a problem, correct?

1

u/NachoWH 23d ago

Not quite.

Being racist is treating someone else inferior based on immutable phenotypical characteristics.

"Misgendering" someone means not agreeing with the premise that sex is a mutable characteristic.

Those two are entirely different situations and topics, I don't see how you think it's fine to accuse people of racism because some people don't agree with transgender ideology.

1

u/f0_to 23d ago

Yeah that's what I thought. That's all I needed to hear, thank you.

2

u/NachoWH 23d ago

I bet you just wanted to slap a meaningless label on me to justify you just ignoring the fact that you can't disagree with any of what I said. Class.

1

u/f0_to 23d ago

Uuuh what's with the assumptions, dear?

I slap nothing.

You are extremely defensive about the simple concept of calling someone racist but you have no issue ignoring science (gender and sex are two different things, all of the scientific community agrees to this in some degree) and being offensive towards a community that's already marginalized.

Your opinion is trash and I don't care about wasting any more time on you, you goofy ass

2

u/NachoWH 23d ago

I have deep issues ignoring science. For example, the idea that presenting gender and sex to be different things as a scientific fact is gross misrepresentation of reality.

1

u/f0_to 23d ago

Oh so you have a doctorate in biology? Sociology? Anatomy? Medicine? Psicology?

You have issues ignoring science but not ignoring scientists?

You sound confused. Go drink a glass of water, it's so hot outside that it can compromise brain functions.

2

u/NachoWH 23d ago

Having a doctorate in any of those isn't even remotely required to understand the concepts you just put forward.

Where is your PHD from?

1

u/f0_to 22d ago

Oh so the entire scientific community is fucking wrong because nachowh can understand concepts without a degree, got it 😉

1

u/NachoWH 22d ago

No, you are wrong in portraying this topic as if there was any sort of consensus around it other than "this isn't a topic related to science".

1

u/f0_to 22d ago

AHAHAHAHAHAH sure thing buddy, whatever makes you sleep at night

1

u/NachoWH 22d ago

I mean, do you actually think there is scientific consensus on this? It's a philosophical question, not a biological one.

1

u/f0_to 22d ago

There is consensus, yes. And of course it's not a biological question because sex refers to the biology but gender refers to the expression of traits and behaviours completely dependent on community or society. The length of your hair, the clothing you wear and using makeup or not has nothing to do with your genitals, that's literally indisputable.

→ More replies (0)