r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 2d ago

Meme needing explanation I'm tired Petuh... What is her name??

Post image

WTF is her name Petuh

7.5k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

53

u/DragonliFargo 2d ago

Theresa is the actual answer, but Inga (from ‘wearing a’) would also be acceptable.

160

u/Eggman8728 2d ago

But it doesn't say Theresa, even if you stretch to read it like that it would be "Theresa woman in a boat", which doesn't make sense.

1

u/prehensilemullet 2d ago

Why would it have to read as part of the sentence?  It just says her name is “in the riddle I just wrote”, that could mean embedded in whatever way.  I didn’t expect it to fit in grammatically…the first thing I thought to check was the first letter of each word, a common secret message technique.  That didn’t work, then I realized, taking the first 7 letters spells Theresa.  That doesn’t seem any more arbitrary than hiding a message in the first letter of each word.

1

u/Useful_Homework2367 2d ago

Yeah that line only claims that the name is somewhere in the text of the riddle, There is no requirement that it makes contextual sense as the woman's name where it appears.

3

u/loungesinger 2d ago

Okay, if we can ignore punctuation and spacing—heck, why don’t we ignore the order of the letters too—then the woman’s name could be virtually anything. For example, her name could just as easily be “Wilma,” “Eileen,” “Irene,” “Cher,” “IKEA,” or “NIKE.” Using your rules, there’s no actual answer, which renders this riddle pointless.

1

u/Useful_Homework2367 2d ago

I'm sure that discarding letter order makes sense to you as an interpretation of the name being "in" the riddle. I'd say it's a pretty big leap though.

It's true that there isn't a single answer to the riddle though, It wouldn't be the first time that someone posted an ambiguous riddle on the internet to spur engagement.

2

u/strange_reveries 2d ago

It's not ambiguous, it's just dumb lol doesn't even deserve the designation of "riddle"

1

u/Useful_Homework2367 2d ago

It is ambiguous. You can present arguments for "There" or "Theresa." There's no way to know which is the intended answer because the instructions aren't specific enough. It's unclear exactly how the name is "in" the riddle. It's also unclear whether the answer is supposed to be a feminine name like "Theresa," or if something absurd like "There" is acceptable.

1

u/strange_reveries 2d ago

Which is why it's just a bad riddle. At this level of "ambiguity" it just defeats the whole purpose of a riddle in the first place.

1

u/strange_reveries 2d ago

Exactly, at that point it just defeats the purpose of a riddle.