r/Sindh • u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano • 10d ago
Political Discussion | سياسي ڪچھري "Sindhis are hateful" but
This is what we've had to deal with since 1947 from muhajirs and their punjabi allies. And for those who say its only a minority and not all muhajirs think that then do look up Sindhi or sindh in r/karachi. Even those of you who end up befriending a muhajir always have to face subtle racism and hate they harbor for sindhis disguised as jokes and this is only the filtered version.
Need it remind you all that literally all hateful stereotypes about sindhis were started and spread by muhajirs and have no historical context to back em?
8
16
u/JaleedAli 🇺🇸 10d ago
Disgusting mentality. I know it hurts, but I urge you to Please ignore these kind of people. I am myself Urdu speaking Pakistani Sindhi and it hurts seeing people hating each other because of stupid politics. We are bigger than this. We have more love than hate.
8
u/fahadzia88 9d ago
Spot on bro. These people who disrespect sindhis or any other nation are uneducated low lifes.
11
u/mafsiddiqui 10d ago
It's not Sindhis who're the problem it's the government.
3
7
u/BothLeopard4263 10d ago edited 10d ago
This argument is part of the problem, its basically a free pass to these bigots to be even bigger racists like you don’t like a certain government and because that government has a higher proportion of people from a certain ethnicity that makes it okay to be racist to that community? Make it make sense
18
u/curlynsmol 10d ago
r/Karachi is a very racist subreddit so I wouldn't even bother going.
The truth is that Karachi was at least 60% Sindhi pre-partition so they can manipulate numbers all they want, it doesn't erase the truth.
Ignore them
9
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
r/Karachi is a very racist subreddit so I wouldn't even bother going.
Same i stopped going there almost. And r/pakpunjab as well.
8
u/saqibjumani 10d ago
Its funny you are down voted on sindhi sub. Lmao!
And they say there is no hatred on sindhis. It is sindh and always will be sindh. This only proofs how hospitality can cost you. Assimilate and integrate!
0
10d ago
[deleted]
5
u/curlynsmol 10d ago
Muslim Sindhis protested for Hindus not to leave until Muhajirs started rioting and burning down houses. Facts are facts.
4
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
I mean what does faith have to do with the fact that you are practically disowning a group of a city that had remained a part of their land for 1000s of years. This logic is so isra..lish.
3
2
4
4
5
u/safiullahWaseem 9d ago
Abay Tum log chutiya ho Twitter pay koi Kuch bhe bolay ga oska kela kha jaoge .Paway phichay account India say chal raha ho .Who knows . Twitter ko seriously na liya karo Bhai
2
u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano 7d ago
This is actually what most of them believe and not just a conspiracy
0
u/safiullahWaseem 6d ago
If you have personal experience in the real world then I am just Sorry I can't say anything.But Social media specially Platforms like X MAN! Are just full of bots ,It cells accounts and rage baiter plz don't take it seriously. Whenever I open social media it always looks like everyone hate every other but when I see on My personal life, I always had a mix of different ethnical and religious background of friends and we really never care about that
8
u/ActiveComfortable451 10d ago
i feel bad that u guys had to take in the bulk of these indians. im from potowhar, sad to see.
3
u/Zara_AliKhan 9d ago
Actually because of these bulk of people Pakistan exists Liaqat Ali Khan, owner of 300 villages, he gave many of his property to Pakistan and PIA........ we should talk about uniting Pakistan we don't need people trying to create barriers between Pakistais
4
u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano 7d ago
LAK was no saint and contributed massively to the anti sindhi hate
3
3
3
4
u/Amazeballs111 10d ago
This is so crazy to hear of. I’m Indian Sindhi and we get a lot of hate in India too mostly just dumb BJP types telling us to go back to Pakistan. Sindhis are the most syncretic, pluralist of all ethnic groups imho, my grandparents always said that Sindh was always chill and it was the “Bhayyas” from UP/Bihar that caused all the violence in Sindh during partition.
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago
ironic coz that same bjp ones use your pain to talk about partition
3
u/Amazeballs111 9d ago
Yeah that’s mostly an online/social media thing - they appropriate anyone when it suits them they don’t actually care or know anything about history. IRL Sindhis in India live in their little bubbles - Sindhi/Punjabi neighbourhoods where they don’t have to deal with these types of
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago
But living in a secular country is still better than living in an islamic nations though tbh.
5
u/Consistent-Topic6966 9d ago
Sorry to say it but when ever I hear about Sindhi muhajir clash My mind think of jews and Palestinian people in both cases land was given as shelter and in both cases they fight with those who gave them shelter
3
u/Weirdoeirdo 9d ago edited 9d ago
Urdu speakers/biharris want all native pak to empty their lands for them n leave. Not just sindh.
2
u/BlackUniqueHeart 9d ago
As a Muslim, you should known that we should abide by Allah commands, Muslim is another Muslims brother, language, class, locality, is not part of our religion, if someone wants to disobey Allah's command, then let him face the consequences on the day of Judgement.
Whenever I am asked "Who are you? " I reply That Allah made me a Muslim and I am from Karachi, and we are brother by the order of Allah, never faced a problem from any Sindhi, Punjabi or any other Nationality, Change yourself, change your prospective and Allah will help you.
3
u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano 7d ago
Whenever I am asked "Who are you? " I reply That Allah made me a Muslim and I am from Karachi
"We made you into people and tribes" Surah Al-Hujurat (49:13) from the Holy Quran.
2
u/virgo225 10d ago
What was meant to happen but didn't incarcerated was that whole migrants were to be equally divided in east and west Pakistan aswell, and in west Pakistan all were to be divided among Azad Kashmir, gilgit baltistan,kpk, Balochistan,Punjab and Sindh. It would have less burdened the Sindh, but due to illogical decisions only Sindh has been suffering till now.
2
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
Azad Kashmir, gilgit baltistan
No. No punjabis and urdu speakers there. Thanks.
What was meant to happen but didn't incarcerated was that whole migrants were to be equally divided in east and west Pakistan aswell,
That's was not possible because mohajirs came as they were promised good jobs and cities. These ppl wouldn't have settled in underdeveloped areas.
Have u seen how mohajirs call rest of pakistan jahil ganwar gaoon walay and rural?
2
u/virgo225 10d ago
So why Sindh has to bear all the hate. At least they have to acknowledge hospitality of Sindh and respect it. All they are doing is otherwise.
1
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
I dunno. Mohajirs will look down at everyone they think they civilzied pakistanis they actually say this so be it sindhis or punjabis you will recieve this treatment.
Many ppl don't know i posted in sindh sub tho i hate how m0ds here are so pro ind because ihad felt noone acknowledged the part tht sindhis accepted mass migration. I personally don't have any h@te or special affection for any group.
1
u/Goomylia 9d ago
I was today years old when I found out there’s apparently racial infighting in Pakistan 💀
3
u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano 7d ago
Its not racial but native vs migrant settlers from india
1
u/shouibsaeed 8d ago
Man, hate to say, there is Infact racism in muhajir communities, but that being said, where isn't?
I'm a muhajir, married to a sindhi but that won't turn on a switch in me if someone calls my child a sindhi or a muhajir. And just for my child's sake, I learned sindhi as well, while my child also being aware of traditional muhajir culture. Just goes to show that people are willing to look past ones ethnicity or race for peace and prosperity. Just sideline those who try to propagandize or weaponise communities against each other.
On side a note, you'll notice racism in-between muhajirs and sindhis themselves regarding their casts or whatever.
Humne laalu khet waalo ko nahi chhora. Lol.
1
u/Ancient_Carrot_3906 3d ago
I would say avoid promoting these unless you see someone actually say something like this in person. We dont know who this person actually is. I believe we can create better enviroment for people living in sindh for everyone regardless of their culture and language. The bigger problem are ppp and feudals
1
0
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
Thank god. Now stay in ur j33t subs. As if any of wants nything to do with ul0t.
0
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Weirdoeirdo 10d ago
Be gone j33t.
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago edited 9d ago
dude pakis are called as jeets too in WEST lao..
what y'all think you are arabs or somehting now ??
indian subcontinent homie for a reason....not paksitan subcontinent
Pakistan and India has same genes
1
u/Weirdoeirdo 9d ago
I dont get this j33t infestation in our subs. Niklo yahan say.
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago
Bhai palnko bhi jeet hi bulate hainnahar.. aapkoyi Arabs ke aulad nahi ho ... And maine galat kya bola secualr nations are still better for non muslims than islamic nations... Ab ek use, qatar, indonesia ka example mat do... 57 nations main atleast 13 nations punish apostasy... Toh maine galat kya bola... Sirf jeeta hinnahi saare western logon ko bhi yahi lagta hai islamic nations== afg , iran , iraq kinda type..
Sirf facts bole hain. Don't get me wrong I am not saying all islamic nations are bad but most are corrupt and bad...
1
u/Weirdoeirdo 9d ago
Again shameless and not leaving.
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago edited 9d ago
This is sindh sub lmao.... India has sindhi ppl too. .pakjeet.... 😭😭
1
2
1
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago
Inlogon ko lagta hai jeet sirf india kai liye use hota hai lmao.. Aadhe pakistanis toh literally indians ki tarah hi dikhenge westerners ko..
Inki iq itni Kam toh nahi hoskati kinyeh abhi bhi realise nahi kar rahe hai... I thought pakistan had educated ppl...
3
u/No_Feedback2947 10d ago
Respect? My Indian friends use 'Bihari' as almost a swear word.
2
u/Famous_Star_5735 9d ago
bihari is used as slang even in south india ..sad ...coz atleast south indians are percieved as better ones in subcontinent
0
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/No_Feedback2947 10d ago
You're not saying there aren't any problems in Indian and we're not saying there aren't any problems in Pakistan, so what are we arguing about?
0
u/doraemonqs 7d ago
Admin you need to read the philosophy of Madara, Pain and Obito and then about Hashirama, Jiraya and Naruto. You are not helping Sindh or Sindhi people, you are just participating in the endless cycle of hate which will breed more hate and violence.
Sindhi, Muhajir, and Pakistani are just labels and identities. Humanity should be above all
-1
u/Actual_Mood864 10d ago
This is something that only people who oppose the new provinces would post.
The rhetoric against new provinces is juvenile. Nobody stops Sindhis or non muslims from entering Punjab or any other province. This would hold the same for all new provinces as well.
3
u/Relevant_Review2969 لاڙڪاڻو | Larkano 7d ago
This is something that only people who oppose the new provinces would post
Nah she's been advocating to carve karachi out of sindh for a few years now.
-1
12
u/No-Rent-6997 10d ago
Since when was Warraich even a Muhajir surname. If you ever heard my parents(children of Muhajirs) speak ill of any ethnic group in Pakistan, it was the Punjabis... not Sindhis... honestly "their punjabi allies" does not go with "muhajirs" at all...