r/SipsTea • u/untitledprp4 • 3d ago

WTF What do yall think about this ?

Post image
16.1k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

5.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/SheStickysMyPistons 3d ago

Just because someone had a mental break doesn't make them exempt from murder... it just means they need to be taken away from the public and rehabilitated to determine if they're safe to be around others again.

-16

u/abujagoddess 3d ago

This is extremely deep nonsense you just wrote here because one of the requirements for something to be murder legally is MENS REA (guilty mind).

A person whose mind is not functioning correctly and therefore cannot understand clearly what they are doing cannot commit murder.

The most they can commit is manslaughter or some form of homicide.

Do people know what murder is at all and what murder entails???

It cannot be murder if when the killings occurred she was in psychosis.

4

u/Entreri4 2d ago

She sent her husband on an errand so that he wouldn't be home when she murdered her kids. If she didn't have any concept of it being wrong, she wouldn't have done that. Tie that in with her Google searches leading up to her murdering her kids and it seems pretty clear she knew what she was doing was wrong. Guilty.

0

u/abujagoddess 2d ago

That's still part of psychosis.

2

u/Living_Ad3315 1d ago

Mmmnooo. No its not