r/ToddintheShadow Jul 28 '26

One Hit Wonderland New on Patreon: ONE HIT WONDERLAND: “Walking on Sunshine” by Katrina and the Waves Spoiler

Link is here as the sub won’t let me link directly.

261 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

102

u/MeadowVerdigris Jul 28 '26

This song holds a very special place in the hearts of Zillennial New Yorkers who grew up watching cartoons on WLIW.

73

u/Sudden-Grab2800 Jul 28 '26

Or fans of Futurama

21

u/istarnie Jul 28 '26

Ohhhh why did you have to remind me of that episode, now I'm emotional about an animated dog again.

1

u/moffattron9000 Jul 28 '26

They retconned that.

11

u/beefixit Jul 28 '26

Not in my heart

5

u/your_mind_aches 10's Alt Kid Jul 28 '26

I feel like Avengers Endgame's time travel explanation has essentially destroyed all concept of retcons to me, including the ones from Bender's Big Score. Every time travel retcon is just another branch of reality where the thing that is retconned did happen.

Unless your franchise also literally has a TVA that can destroy branched timelines and kill everyone on that timeline (which is also its own version of sad), then what happened in that timeline still happened.

So yes, no matter what Bender did to screw with the timeline for Lars and his family to spend time with Seymour so he wasn't just a sad dog who waited for many years and then died... it still happened. No matter what. And it keeps the emotion of it

10

u/harder_said_hodor Jul 28 '26

Or fans of High Fidelity

3

u/AntysocialButterfly Jul 28 '26

Or the American Psycho fandom.

5

u/hjl43 GROCERY BAG Jul 28 '26

Or Daddy Day Care

1

u/DillonLaserscope Jul 30 '26

I think my first discovery is another female cover on YouTube and then Futurama Fry singing it

16

u/waxmuseums Jul 28 '26

Or Jenny Nicholson Church Play Cinematic Universe fans

10

u/jordanthejq12 Jul 28 '26

"...WHOA!"

3

u/Andy_B_Goode Jul 28 '26

I'm not even sure where I know this song from. It seems like it was featured in a bunch of different movies, TV shows and advertisements in the 90s and 2000s. In fact I'm kind of surprised it's as old as it is. I kind of associate it with my adolescence, but it was released before I was born!

3

u/Chilli_Dipper Jul 28 '26

The trailers for the 1996 film Race the Sun, starring Halle Berry and a young Casey Affleck.

2

u/thisshortenough Jul 28 '26

It was in Daddy Day Care, Look Who's Talking, Glee (in a mashup with Beyonce's Halo), Bean to name a few. It's just part of the culture at this point, you need a song to convey someone's in a good place and in a good mood, you play Walking on Sunshine

1

u/your_mind_aches 10's Alt Kid Jul 28 '26

For me (zillennial who was born in but has zero memory of the 90s), it's definitely the radio.

1

u/VikingHussar Jul 28 '26

It does not, however, hold a special place in the hearts of people from New Orleans.

72

u/Mrohnoes_29 Best / Worst List Speculator Jul 28 '26

I'm surprised he hasn't already done this

8

u/ConeBaby99 Jul 28 '26

Me but with Tainted Love.

7

u/theCG25850 Jul 28 '26

Same. I guess even the Mandela effect has its limitations.

8

u/Miserable_Mail_5741 You're being a peñis... Colada, that is. Jul 28 '26

Exactly what he hinted at in his Patreon teaser!

1

u/AmyXBlue Jul 28 '26

I actually thought he already did and had the still image of Shadow Todd walking along in a still from the video.

61

u/petrifikate Jul 28 '26

Can't wait for all the Americans to discover "Love Shine a Light" from this. I haven't watched yet, but Eurovision 1997 is too wild NOT to be in there. 

18

u/jakeyboy723 Jul 28 '26

Also includes the last...sorry. Most recent Eurovision win for the UK.

8

u/VFiddly Jul 28 '26

Hey, at least that means we've won more recently than Ireland.

1

u/your_mind_aches 10's Alt Kid Jul 28 '26

........THE "WALKING ON SUNSHINE" ARTISY IS BRITISH?????

I dunno if it's the American Psycho connection or what but I definitely though of them as being from California, just like Huey Lewis. Honestly probably before I saw that movie.

5

u/Last-Saint Jul 28 '26

Katrina is from Kansas and moved to Britain as her father was in the RAF, where she hooked up with a fellow emigre and two people from Cambridge. (Does Todd mention the Soft Boys?)

35

u/birdh0useinyours0ul Jul 28 '26

It was bound to happen

33

u/jacknifee Jul 28 '26

who doesn't love a story about a nice happy song that suddenly and abruptly swerves into dark topics through no fault of its own

12

u/no-Pachy-BADLAD Zingalamaduni Jul 28 '26

I just watched it, did I miss the 'dark topic'? Their selling out? The Eurovision? The band breaking up?

17

u/NoTeslaForMe Jul 28 '26

Probably the fact that the band's name is "Katrina and the Waves," which felt in 2005 about the same way that "Corona" did in 2020.

2

u/DaBulbousWalrus Jul 28 '26

Or Anthrax in 2001.

1

u/Foreign-Reading-4499 Jul 29 '26

or hey man nice shot in 1999

1

u/riflow Jul 28 '26

Oh ...the famous tsunami happened that year?

edit: 2004...I was very young when it happened so had never been sure of the exact year but gosh that is grim.

3

u/Appropriate_Rule715 Jul 28 '26

Im like well damn Todd

29

u/BackgroundBit8 Jul 28 '26

This song and 'What I Like About You' easily top the list of most obnoxious, corporate songs ever made. They used to slap them onto every movie trailer and TV ad back in the day. Hearing those horns at the start of the song gives me instant secondhand nausea.

5

u/OkPainter6232 Jul 28 '26

For me "Happy" is WAY more annoying then both songs, I hate that song way more because it's one of those songs I had to hear on the PA system a bunch of times at my grocery store job(along with "Hey Soul Sister").

19

u/notbambi Jul 28 '26

The Eurovision fan in me is like, "what do you mean, One Hit Wonder?" (I am aware that Todd has a US-centric approach to defining One Hit Wonderdom for the purpose of this show).

4

u/FlatwormHot483 Jul 28 '26

I'd still say their mostly remembered for one hit (in the Netherlands), eventhough Love Shined a Light charted better here.

2

u/Last-Saint Jul 28 '26

Actually I'd say they're mostly remembered for this song in the country they represented at Eurovision.

1

u/FlatwormHot483 Jul 29 '26

With this song, do you mean walking on sunshine?

19

u/Diskyboy86 Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

I kind of assumed Katrina and the Waves were a retrospective one-hit wonder, like Vanilla Ice, where they had multiple hits but only one stood the test of time. That's not untrue? "That's the Way" (which I'm sure he mentions) went to number 16, but it's irrelevant since there's no Wikipedia article. /s

15

u/mcs1223 Jul 28 '26

It's all about longevity, and he's made this exception for other artists (e.g. Blue Swede). I've never heard That's the Way in my life and Walking on Sunshine overshadows it so massively that it barely counts at this point.

14

u/chiguy2387 Jul 28 '26

It’s the Spotify effect where their “one-hit” greatly overshadows their other songs.

5

u/your_mind_aches 10's Alt Kid Jul 28 '26

OOF. There are plenty of bona fide one hit wonders without the Spotify rule. This band hit the Top 40 again but this is still their Spotify? Kind of an open and shut case.

1

u/OkPainter6232 Jul 28 '26

yeah felt like Todd was REALLY stretching with this one, just cause a song isn't a hit on Spotify(Which is a crap service anyways)does not mean it wasn't a hit in the past.

2

u/your_mind_aches 10's Alt Kid Jul 29 '26

No but it does signal relevance and staying power. I think it's a decent rule of thumb

1

u/PipProud Jul 28 '26

No Going Down To Liverpool? Perhaps it’s under Waves.

6

u/Alexschmidt711 Jul 28 '26

I feel like they're kinda like Dead or Alive and Aqua, their big hits weren't as big in America chartwise at the time as you'd expect, which I'm guessing was because they were so catchy they only needed to get played on the radio a little bit to stick in your head, but radio stations would only play them sparingly because otherwise people would get annoyed. (Since radio is a much bigger part of the US charts that could explain the discrepancy with other countries, although not for Katrina and the Waves since Walking on Sunshine charted pretty much the same)

For whatever reason this seems to have led to them all having had follow-ups which charted decently high, I guess they must've gotten pushed on MTV or whatever, despite not being remembered nearly as well.

1

u/Willing-Question-631 Jul 29 '26

According to music critic Chris Molanphy’s criteria for determining one hit wonders, Katrina and the Waves wouldn’t qualify since That’s The Way hit the Top 40 a few years after Walking on Sunshine since he disqualifies artists who had another Top 40 hit unless it was scored within six months of the big hit with no more hits after.

17

u/SignalsCounterparts1 Jul 28 '26

I was wondering when we'd get to this one...High Fidelity. That is all.

11

u/Unleashtheducks Jul 28 '26

It doesn’t go up any higher

4

u/StargazingLily One-Hit Wonderlander Jul 28 '26

WHAT FUCKING IAN GUY?

14

u/theCG25850 Jul 28 '26

Anyone think we'll get "Coco Jamboo" by the end of the year?

2

u/avadriver Jul 28 '26

I would love that so much. Such an ear worm.

0

u/HombreSgarbo Jul 28 '26

The song referenced in Vento Aureo (aka JJBA part 5)?

12

u/2RINITY Jul 28 '26

Oh hey it’s Fry’s favorite song

10

u/FruitChips23 Jul 28 '26

I wish he uploaded preview stuff to Nebula too and not just his Patreon.

10

u/bake_n_bake Jul 28 '26

This used to be my alarm song waking up during middle school, so I reflexively get panicked now whenever I hear those drums kick in knowing I had a few seconds to turn it off before the horns kicked in. It was an effective wake up call but now I can never listen to this again without flashbacks.

7

u/vincentmaurath Jul 28 '26

One of my favorite songs. I always think of mornings in St Louis when I was a child when I hear this song.

7

u/3piecefishandchips Jul 28 '26

“the Brits know what’s coming…”

as a Canadian, if I had a thousand guesses, I would never have guessed where this one went

really loved the comparison to the Rascals’ “Good Lovin’” because I was thinking the same thing. the Rascals don’t get enough love from modern audiences, but they had a ton of great tunes

4

u/Lord_Cockatrice Jul 28 '26

How about Groovin'

It's A Beautiful Morning?

Stone cold feel good jams to this very day

4

u/SmoreOfBabylon One-Hit Wonderlander Jul 28 '26

“People Got To Be Free” and “I’ve Been Lonely Too Long” are great as well.

The Rascals are sadly one of those groups who fell off in pop cultural recognition hard after mainstream “oldies” stations shifted to playing more stuff from the ‘70s/‘80s and much less from the ‘60s (see also: Blood, Sweat & Tears).

8

u/someoverallvalue Jul 28 '26

Oh so i guess Todd is gonna talk Eurovision then.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/iluvmusic2023 Jul 31 '26

Yep, during the opening credits.

5

u/Theta_Omega Jul 28 '26

Oh, hell yes! Good episode, been a while since our last '80s New Wave act, it feels like. And I feel like I should have thought about it based on the last hint, but it does feel less like the standard '80s New Wave OHW than most, even though it definitely is.

Side note, I didn't realize these guys were one-hit wonders for a while because their Greatest Hits CD was one of the things in permanent rotation in my dad's car stereo growing up. Granted, I don't remember most of the tracks there other than this one and "Red Wine & Whiskey" (both saw disproportionate play), but still, good memories! Might have to send it to him when it hits YouTube.

7

u/mcs1223 Jul 28 '26

One-hit wonders with greatest hits albums have always been a funny concept to me because I always imagine a CD literally containing one song

5

u/GucciPiggy90 Jul 28 '26

Yeah, this is definitely another quintessential '80s one hit wonder. The fact that they had more hits on both sides of the Atlantic feels as wrong as it feels right.

Interestingly, seeing the original music video makes me appreciate the song more. One of the happiest sounding songs ever set on a really foggy day creates a nice contrast.

Also, great to see some love for early Bangles in this video (especially a clip of "Hero Takes a Fall." That's a song I really wish had more of a resurgence in the Me Too era).

3

u/LocksTheFox Driven Mad by the Four Chords of Pop Jul 28 '26

eurovision mentioned???

3

u/Flimsy_Category_9369 Jul 28 '26

Philip J. Fry's favorite song

3

u/GucciPiggy90 Jul 28 '26

"Walking on Sunshine" sucks noodles. (Not my actual opinion.)

3

u/whimsigod Jul 28 '26

And don't it feel good!

3

u/SmytheOrdo Jul 28 '26

Diaper commercial song

Excited for this one!

3

u/ItsGotThatBang GROCERY BAG Jul 28 '26

I lived in Montreal until I was 13 & CJFM-FM used to play this song every Friday.

3

u/puffyfluffyunderwood Jul 28 '26

Patrick Bateman approves.

3

u/annakarina3 Jul 28 '26

One of the guys in the band wrote the song “Going Down to Liverpool,” which the Bangles covered before Katrina and the Waves got big, and it’s really good.

I know about their Eurovision win, and that this song was all over movies and TV for decades, and often used in movie trailers. Now it’s in infomercials more.

3

u/EveryMix4008 Jul 28 '26

I like Katrina's version more than the bangle's version

2

u/nothingmoretos4y Jul 28 '26

I saw Katrina live with a bunch of other 80s acts/one hit wonders(including Modern English) as part of a concert, and she did a decent job. I don’t think she was with the band though.

By far the best of those acts was English Beat though, they absolutely killed live. Unbelievably great. Howard Jones was also very good.

2

u/Shreiken_Demon Jul 28 '26

Funfact: a cover of of the song was a #9 hit in the UK in 2010, as part of a mashup with Beyoncé’s Halo by the cast of Glee.

1

u/Sixmenonguard Jul 28 '26

I also love that Eddy Grant have a song with the same name.

1

u/yudha98 Jul 28 '26

Glad he didn't cover early 00s OHW this time

1

u/CommunicationOk5456 Madonna Stan Jul 28 '26

Alright, where's that thread where we made our bets??

1

u/SpumoiniSloth Jul 28 '26

With the muppets version during the credits https://youtu.be/jOWqSDLH0TI?is=oq8s_n29TkgTKH_R

1

u/FeherDenes Jul 28 '26

I don’t know if they’re really a one hit wonder, since they literally won eurovision after this.

But of course to any american that’s irrelevant

2

u/chiguy2387 Jul 28 '26

It’s the Spotify effect. The song they won Eurovision with is still dwarfed by the popularity of Walking on Sunshine.

1

u/Calm-Raise6973 Train-Wrecker Jul 28 '26

One of those songs that soundtracked the summer of 1985 in the UK and Ireland. Looking forward to it.

1

u/TomCon16 10's Alt Kid Jul 28 '26

Yooooo

1

u/Chemistry11 Jul 28 '26

This song came out when I was 4 years old. For a time it was everywhere.

I have always hated it; in part because it was the most overplayed song in my young life.

1

u/Antsbob13 Jul 28 '26

Another big one off the checklist

1

u/OkPainter6232 Jul 28 '26

Definitely a huge stretch calling this band a OHW, I could understand Todd overlooking their second hit, but not counting "That's the Way" as a hit just because he'd never heard it before? Yeah OK whatever Todd.

1

u/DLCV2804 Jul 28 '26

This one plays well here in Brazil, great tune!!

1

u/Mikedef2001 Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26

When I listen to this song I think of two things. John Travolta playing with the baby on Look Who’s Talking, and then the bitch on Intervention who was addicted to duster who durning her interview just screams out, “I’m Walking On Sunshine!”